Tobacco Cases 1808-2012

Index by Decade
1800's 1870's 1880's 1890's 1900's
1910's 1920's 1930's 1940's 1950's
1960's 1970's 1980's 1990's 2000's

Com v Colquehouns et al., 2 Hen & Munf 213; 12 Va 403 (April 1808) (business practices case)

Thompson's Administrator v Thompson's Executor, 20 Va (6 Munf) 514 (4 March 1820) (inheritance issues re tobacco farmer's widow)

Parsons v Armor, 28 US 413; 7 L Ed 724 (ED La, Jan 1830) (bad debt case)

Commonwealth v Benjamin J. Harris (Virginia, 1830's) (murders by tobacconist)

Prigg v Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, 41 US (16 Peters) 539; 10 L Ed 1060 (1842) (pro-slavery case)

Commonwealth of Massachusetts v Thompson, 53 Mass (12 Metc) 231 [51 LNS 562] (March 1847) (outdoor smoking case; banned due to foreseeability of fires)

Syers v Jonas, 2 Ex 111 (Mass, 1848) (pricing case)

Dixon v Myers & Co, 48 Va (7 Grattan) 240 (Jan 1851) (title to tobacco burned before delivery to buyer)

Marshal Ableman v Sherman M. Booth, 59 US 479; 15 L Ed 465 (9 May 1856) (fugitive slave case accessory to tobacco farmer activity; see commentary by Lewis Tappan, et al., Proceedings of Convention [New York, 1855], p 31.)

Dred Scott v Sandford, 60 US 393; 15 L Ed 691 (1857) (aiding/abetting tobacco farmer activity, by C. J. Roger Taney, on the world's worst court)

Durden v McWilliams & Smith, 31 Ala 438 (1858) (husband-wife tobacco dispute case)

Ableman v Booth, 62 US (21 How) 506; 16 L Ed 169 (7 March 1859) (fugitive slave case accessory to tobacco farmer activity)

Williams v Jones 3 Hurlst & C 256; 159 Eng Rep 528; 13 ALR 989 (Crt of Exchequer, 11 June 1864) (fire case)

Williams v Jones 3 Hurlst & C 602; 159 Eng Rep 668 (Exchequer Chamber, 7 Feb 1865). SCB: 3 Hurlst & C 256; 159 Eng Rep 528

Lincoln Assassination Conspiracy Trial, 8 Am St Trials 25-494 (DC, 1865) (assassination accessory to tobacco farmer activity)

U.S. v Surratt, 27 Fed Cas 1367 (# 16,423) (May 1865) (smoker crime case, re 14 April 1865 Lincoln assassination, accessory to tobacco farmer activity)

Ex parte Mudd, 17 Fed Cas 954 (# 9,899) (Sep 1868) (smoker crime case, re 14 April 1865 Lincoln assassination)

US v Surratt, 6 DC 306 (6 Nov 1868) (smoker crime case, re 14 April 1865 Lincoln assassination)

The Cherokee Tobacco, 78 US 616; 20 L Ed 227 (WD Ark, Dec 1870) (tax exemption case)

United States v Henderson's Tobacco, 78 US 652; 20 L Ed 235 (Dec 1870) (tax case)

United States v Quantity of Tobacco, 27 Fed Cas 639 (# 16,105) (SD NY, May 1871)

United States v Quantity of Tobacco, 27 Fed Cas 639 (#16,104) (Circ Ct, 1871). SCB: #16,105 (business practices case)

United States v Quantity of Tobacco, 27 Fed Cas 665 (#16,106a); 5 Ben 547; 16 Int Rev Rec 132; 15 Int Rev Rec 19 (SD NY, 19 Jan 1872). SCB: #16,105

Blackwell v Armistead, 3 Fed Cas 546 (#1,474); 3 Hughes 163; 5 Am Law T 85 (WD Virginia, March 1872)

United States v Quantity of Tobacco, 27 Fed Cas 650 (#16,106); 6 Ben 68 (SD NY, May 1872)

Blackwell v Wright, 73 NC 310 (Fall 1874) (business practices case)

Pace v Burgess, 92 US 372; 23 L Ed 657 (ED Va, Oct 1875) (tax case)

Blackwell v Wright, 74 NC 733 (Jan 1876). SCB: 73 NC 310

W. T. Blackwell & Co v W. G. Dibrell & Co, 3 Fed Cas 549 (#1,475); 3 Hughes 151; 17 Am Law Reg (NS) 516; 14 OG 633 (ED Virginia, 13 Jan 1878)

Lilienthal's Tobacco v United States, 97 US 237; 24 L Ed 901 (21 Jan 1878)

Carver v State, 69 Ind 61; 35 Am Rep 205; 1879 WL 5712 (Nov 1879) (addiction case)

Shipman v Graves, 41 Mich 675; 3 NW 177 (21 Oct 1879)

Carroll v Eitheiler, 1 F 688 (ED Pa, 6 April 1880)

Parker v School District, 73 Tenn (5 Lea) 525 (Sep 1880)

Kensett v Stivers, et al, 10 F 517 (SD NY, 8 Nov 1880) (tax case)

Hier, et al v Abrahams, et al, 82 NY (37 Sickels) 519 (16 Nov 1880) (trademark case, alleging fraudulent imitation)

Bradley v Murray, 66 Ala 269 (Dec 1880) (divorce case, tobacco is not a "necessity" for spouse to provide)

Mueller v State, 76 Ind 310; 40 Am Rep 245 (May 1881) (addiction case)

Guiteau's Case, 10 F 161-203; 14 Am St Trials 1-158 (DC, 25 Jan 1882) (smoker crime case, insanity defense re 25 July 1881 Garfield assassination)

Nash v Page, 80 Ky 539, 44 Am Rep 490 (Sep 1882) (public tobacco warehouse case banning discrimination)

Turner v State of Maryland, 107 US 38; 2 S Ct 44; 27 L Ed 370 (La, 5 Feb 1883) (business practices case, affirming constitutionality of state tobacco inspection law; conviction in state court upheld)

Snyder v Marks, 109 US 189; 3 S Ct 157; 27 L Ed 901 (2 Nov 1883) (tax case)

Heard v Flannagan, 10 Victoria Law Rpts 1 (1884) (fire case)

Re Paul, 94 NY 497 (Jan 1884) (banning tobacco manufacture outside factories, in rooms and apartments)

17 Opinions US Attorney General 646 (25 Jan 1884) (tax case, classification of tobacco scraps)

Matter of Jacobs, 33 Hun 374; 2 NY Cr 346 (Oct 1884) (tobacco manufacture in tenements)

Snyder v U.S., 112 US 216; 5 S Ct 118; 28 L Ed 697 (La, 17 Nov 1884) (tax case)

Matter of Jacobs, 2 NY Cr 539; 98 NY 98; 50 Am Rep 636 (20 Jan 1885). SCB: 33 Hun 374; 2 NY Cr 346

Cohn v Spalding, 24 Fed 19 (CC ND Ill, 26 May 1885) (tax case, classification of tobacco scraps)

Blackwell Durham Co v McElwe, 94 NC 425 (Feb 1886) (trademark case)

Turpin v Burgess, 117 US 504; 6 S Ct 835; 29 L Ed 988 (5 April 1886) (tax case, alleging tax on tobacco manufacture was on exports, banned by the constitution)

Bloete v Simon, 19 Abb NC 88 (NY, May 1887) (business practices label case)

Eaton v Lancaster, 79 Me 477; 10 A 449 (29 June 1887) (fire case)

Strasser v Moonelis, 11 Cent Rep 461; 108 NY 611 (6 March 1888). SCB: 23 Jones & S 197 (union label case)

People v Fisher, 57 Sup Ct Rep N Y (50 Hun) 552 (NY, Jan 1889) (cigar label case)

State v Ohmer, 34 Mo App 115; 1879 WL 1764 (5 Feb 1889) (cigar sale ban, leading to this early addiction case)

Cigar Makers Protective Union No 98 v Conley, 40 Minn 243; 3 LRA 125 (11 March 1889) (fraudulent use of label case)

Commonwealth v Marzynski, 149 Mass 68; 21 NE 228 (6 May 1889)

Carson v Ury, 39 F 777; 5 LRA 614 (CA Mo, 2 Sep 1889) (business practices case alleging fraudulent label)

Talbott v Stemmons' Executor, 89 Ky 222; 12 SW 297 (24 Oct 1889) (Kentucky case upholding decedent's promise to will $500 if grandson remained nonsmoking)

Kaufman v Farley Mfg Co, 78 Iowa 679; 43 NW 612 (28 Oct 1889) (cigar jobber termination case)

Castro v Seeberger, 40 F 531 (CA 7, Ill, 1890) (tax case)

D'Estrinoz v Gerker, 43 Fed 285 (ED Pa, 8 April 1890). SCB: GA 5251 (trade practices case)

State v Heidenhain, 42 La Ann 483; 7 So 621; 21 Am St Rep 388; 51 LNS 562 (21 April 1890) (second hand smoke (TTS) ban case pursuant to tobacco's then-known adverse effects, to protect in public travel, the right to fresh and pure air)

Weener v Brayton, 152 Mass 101; 8 LRA 640 (24 June 1890) (fraudulent use of label case)

Hamer v Sidway, 57 Hun 229; 11 NYS 182 (1 July 1890) (upholding a trust granting $5,000 to nephew on condition of "refraining from the use of liquor and tobacco," upheld)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v Reid Tobacco Co, 104 Mo 53; 24 Am St Rep 314 (Oct 1890) (trademark infringement case)

School Dist of Ft. Smith v Maury, 53 Ark 471; 14 SW 669 (25 Oct 1890) (school board authority to deal with smokers)

Herron v Dibrell, 87 Va 289; 12 SE 674 (8 Jan 1891)

In re Blumlein, Rosenwald, Cullmans, and Schubart, 45 F 236 (SD NY, 2 Feb 1891) (leaf tobacco tax case)

Hamer v Sidway, 124 NY 538; 27 NE 256 (14 April 1891). SCB: 57 Hun 229; 11 NYS 182

McVey v Brendel, 144 Pa 235; 13 LRA 377 (5 Oct 1891) (business practices label case)

In re Blumlein, 49 F 228 (SD NY, 5 Jan 1892) (leaf tobacco tax case)

Field v Clark, 143 US 649; 12 S Ct 495; 36 L Ed 294 (29 Feb 1892) (tax case, constitutional challenge, alleging it didn't pass as text was not in congressional journal)

Joseph v Macowsky, 96 Cal 518; 31 P 914 (30 Nov 1892) (trademark misrepresentation case)

Sheldon and Castro v U. S., 5 CCA 282; 55 F 818 (CA 7, Ill, 11 Feb 1893) (tax case, classification of tobacco scraps)

Isaacs v Jonas, 148 US 648; 13 S Ct 677; 37 L Ed 596 (La, 10 April 1893) (tax case)

U.S. v Isaacs, 148 US 654; 13 S Ct 679; 37 L Ed 598 (La, 10 April 1893) (tax case)

In re Blumlein, 5 CCA 142; 55 F 383 (CA 2, NY, 18 April 1893). SCB: 49 F 228 (leaf tobacco tax case)

State v Johnson, 118 Mo 491; 24 SW 229 (7 Dec 1893)

Chicago, M. & St. P. Ry. Co. v Lowell, 151 US 209; 14 S Ct 281; 38 L Ed 131 (8 Jan 1894) (smoker injury case, injured while ignoring a warning sign posted by railroad)

Bonsack Machine Co v Elliott, 63 F 835 (SD NY, 4 April 1894) (patent infringement case re cigarette machine)

Seeberger v Castro, 153 US 32; 14 S Ct 766; 38 L Ed 624 (Ill, 16 April 1894) (tax case). SCB: 40 F 531

Spalding v Castro, 153 US 38; 14 S Ct 768; 38 L Ed 626 (16 April 1894) (tax case)

Western District Warehouse Co v Harris, 16 Ky L R 93 (30 May 1894) (uninsured tobacco warehouse fire)

Metz v Hagerty, 51 Ohio St 521; 38 NE 11 (20 June 1894) (tax case)

Bonsack Machine Co v National Cigarette Co, 64 F 858 (SD NY, 2 Oct 1894) (slightly different machine is not a contempt of court issue, when patent office issues a patent)

Erhardt v Schroeder, 155 US 124; 15 S Ct 325; 39 L Ed 94 (NY, 12 Nov 1894) (tax case)

United States v Rosenwald, 67 F 323 (CA 2, 5 March 1895) (leaf tobacco tax case)

State v Bishop, 128 Mo 212; 31 SW 9; 49 Am St Rep 569; 29 LRA 200 (12 May 1895) (misuse-of-union-label case)

Bonsack Machine Co v S F Hess & Co, 68 F 119 (WD Va, 28 May 1895) (cigarette machine royalty case)

Commercial Insurance Co v Friedlander, 156 Ill 595; 41 NE 183; 16 ALR3d 774 (15 June 1895) (fraud allegations case)

Bonsack Machine Co v Elliott and National Cigarette & Tobacco Co, 69 F 335 (CA 2, 28 June 1895) (patent infringement case). SCB: 63 F 835

Re Minor, 5 Inters Com Rep 329; 69 F 233 (W Va, 10 July 1895)

Bonsack Machine Co v Smith, 70 F 383 (WD NC, 28 Sep 1895) (patent and monopoly case)

Com v Mudgett, 4 Pa. Dist. 739; 1895 WL 3712 (Pa, 30 Nov 1895) (smoker mass murder case)

Wright v Duke, 91 Hun 409; 36 NYS 853; 72 St R 375 (18 Dec 1895) (trade case; defrauding partner when selling his interest, by concealing a lucrative contract, impacting company value)

Com v Mudgett, 174 Pa 211; 34 A 588 (4 March 1896). SCB: 4 Dist 739

Richmond & Allegheny Ry Co v Patterson Tobacco Co, 92 Va 670; 24 SE 261 (12 March 1896)

State v Gerhardt, 145 Ind 439; 44 NE 469 (19 June 1896)

Iowa v McGregor, 76 F 956 (ND Iowa, 23 July 1896)

Garrett v T. H. Garrett & Co, 24 CCA 173; 78 F 472 (CA 6, Ky, 8 Dec 1896) (business practices case, alleging imitative labels and wrongful use of trade name)

People v Duke, 19 Misc 292; 44 NYS 336 (Jan 1897)

Adam Roth Grocer Co v Lewis, 69 Mo App 446 (23 Feb 1897) (tobacco ownership issue)

U.S. v American Tobacco Co, 166 US 468; 17 S Ct 619; 41 L Ed 1081 (12 April 1897) (tax stamps refund case)

State v Goetze, 43 W Va 495; 27 SE 225; 64 Am St Rep 871 (24 April 1897)

In re May, 82 F 422 (D Montana, 5 Aug 1897)

Sawrie v Tennessee, 82 F 615 (MD Tenn, 30 Sep 1897)

McGregor v Cone, 104 Iowa 465; 73 NW 1041; 65 Am St Rep 522; 39 LRA 484 (24 Jan 1898)

Richmond & Allegheny Ry Co v Patterson Tobacco Co, 169 US 311; 18 S Ct 335; 42 L Ed 759 (21 Feb 1898). SCB: 92 Va 670; 24 SE 261

Schroeder v US, 87 F 201 (SD NY, 8 March 1898) (tax case)

U.S. v Lies, 170 US 628; 18 S Ct 780; 42 L Ed 1170 (NY, 23 May 1898) (tax case). SCB: 38 US App 655; 20 CCA 651; 74 F 546

U.S. v Rothschild & Bro, 87 F 798 (SD NY, 27 May 1898) (tax case)

Gundling v City of Chicago, 176 Ill 340; 52 NE 44; 48 LRA 230 (24 Oct 1898)

Austin v State, 101 Tenn (17 Pickle) 563; 48 SW 305; 70 Am St Rep 703; 50 LRA 478 (22 Dec 1898) (cigarette ban)

Western Assurance Co v Ray, 105 Ky 523; 49 SW 326 16 ALR3d 774 (1 Feb 1899) (fraud allegations case)

US v Schroeder, 33 CCA 376; 93 F 448 (CA 2, NY, 1 March 1899). SCB: 87 F 201 (tax case)

Rickard v Du Bois, 97 F 96 (D Conn, 2 Aug 1899)

Blaufield v State, 103 Tenn 593; 53 SW 1090 (20 Nov 1899)

Central of Georgia Railway Co v Hammond, 109 Ga 383; 34 SE 594 (2 Dec 1899)

U.S. v Two-hundred Twenty Patented Machines, 99 F 559 (ED Pa, 5 Feb 1900) (business practices case; cigar machines confiscated for taxes)

Commonwealth v Grinstead, 108 Ky 59; 55 SW 720 (10 March 1900)

Gundling v Chicago, 177 US 183; 20 S Ct 633; 44 L Ed 725 (Ill, 9 April 1900). SCB: 176 Ill 340; 52 NE 44 (See "Medicolegal: Power to Regulate Sale of Cigarettes," 35 J Am Med Ass'n 298-299 [4 Aug 1900])

John Bad Elk v U.S., 177 US 529; 20 S Ct 729; 44 L Ed 874 (SD, 30 April 1900)

Rickard v Du Bois, 103 F 868 (CA 2, Conn, 25 July 1900) (patent application rejected for alleged fraudulent intent). SCB: 97 F 96

U.S. v 246˝ Pounds of Tobacco, 103 F 791 (ND Wash, 14 Aug 1900)

Anargyros v Egyptian Amasis Cigarette Co, 54 App Div 345; 66 NYS 626 (9 Nov 1900) (trademark infringement case, as ex-employee used a similar style)

Austin v State of Tennessee, 179 US 343; 21 S Ct 132; 45 L Ed 224 (Tenn, 19 Nov 1900) (issue of whether commerce clause preempts state cigarette ban). SCB: 101 Tenn (17 Pickle) 563; 48 SW 305; 70 Am St Rep 703; 50 LRA 478

Chesapeake & O R Co v Com. of Kentucky, 179 US 388; 21 S Ct 101; 45 L Ed 244 (3 Dec 1900) (segregation era railroad passengers case; Kentucky law ordered railroad to provide segregated cars; pursuant to the law, blacks were forced into the "smoking car . . . alleged to be small, badly ventilated, unclean, and fitted with greatly inferior accommodations")

Rothschild & Bro v U.S., 179 US 463; 21 S Ct 197; 45 L Ed 277 (NY, 17 Dec 1900) (tax case). SCB: 87 F 798

Barker v Harvey, 181 US 481; 21 S Ct 690; 45 L Ed 963 (13 May 1901) (citing The Cherokee Tobacco case, supra, as still valid precedent)

U.S. v Czolgosz, 14 Am St Trials 159-231 (24 Sep 1901) (third assassination of a President by a smoker)

Louisville & N R Co v Eubank, 184 US 27; 22 S Ct 277; 46 L Ed 416 (Ky, 27 Jan 1902) (shipping charges case)

Patton v Brady, 184 US 608; 22 S Ct 493; 46 L Ed 713 (ED VA, 17 March 1902) (tobacco tax case)

U.S. v Lee Yen Tai, 185 US 213; 22 S Ct 629; 46 L Ed 878 (21 April 1902) (reaffirming validity of The Cherokee Tobacco decision, supra)

Northern Pac Ry Co v Adams, 54 CCA 196; 116 F 324 (CA 9, Wash, 19 May 1902) (smoker killed by fall from train)

Hirschhorn v Bradley, 117 Iowa 130; 90 NW 592 (20 May 1902) (mfr attempt to terminate cigar sales agent)

Felsenheld / Merry World Tobacco v U S, 186 US 126; 22 S Ct 740; 46 L Ed 1085 (19 May 1902) (confiscated tobacco, banned for having anything other than tobacco therein)

Pannell, et al v Louisville Tobacco Warehouse Co, et al, 113 Ky 630; 68 SW 662 (Ky App, 6 June 1902) (tobacco warehousemen fees case)

Pannell, et al v Louisville Tobacco Warehouse Co, et al, 82 SW 1141 (Ky App, 12 Nov 1902). SCB: 113 Ky 630; 68 SW 662

Cook v Marshall County, 119 Iowa 384; 93 NW 372; 104 Am St Rep 283 (2 Feb 1903)

Hirschhorn v Nelden-Judson Drug Co, 26 Utah 110; 72 P 386 (1 May 1903) (manufacturer v sales agent)

Penniston v Newman, 117 Ga 700; 45 SE 65 (25 June 1903)

State ex inf Crow, Atty Gen v Continental Tobacco Co, 177 Mo 1; 75 SW 737 (15 June 1903) (price fixing case)

Hodge v Muscatine County, 121 Iowa 482; 96 NW 968; 104 Am St Rep 304 (22 Oct 1903)

Whitwell, Joseph P v Continental Tobacco Co, 125 F 454 (CA 8, Minn, 12 Nov 1903) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

A Steinhardt & Bro v United States, 126 F 443 (SD NY, 17 Nov 1903) (issue of defining smokers' articles)

Cornell v Coyne, 192 US 418; 24 S Ct 383; 48 L Ed 504 (23 Feb 1904) (tax case, citing tobacco precedents and issues back to the Civil War)

Northern Pac Ry Co v Adams, 192 US 440; 24 S Ct 408; 48 L Ed 513 (Wash, 23 Feb 1904) (smoker killed by fall from train). SCB: 54 CCA 196; 116 F 324

United Cigarette Machine Co v Wright, 132 F 195 (ED NC, 9 Sep 1904) (accounting issues)

Continental Tobacco Co v Larus Bro Co, 66 CCA 557; 133 F 727 (CA 4, Va, 15 Nov 1904) (trade case, alleging infringement by confusing illiterates)

Falk and American Cigar Co v U.S., 145 F 574 (D NY, 22 Dec 1904)

Cook v Marshall County, 196 US 261; 25 S Ct 233; 49 L Ed 471 (Iowa, 16 Jan 1905) (preemption issue in tax case). SCB: 119 Iowa 384; 93 NW 372; 104 Am St Rep 283

Hodge v Muscatine County, 196 US 276; 25 S Ct 237; 49 L Ed 477 (Iowa, 16 Jan 1905) (preemption issue in tax case). SCB: 121 Iowa 482; 96 NW 968; 104 Am St Rep 383

Werckmeister v American Tobacco Co, 138 F 162 (SD NY, 23 March 1905) (business practices case, alleging copyright infringement)

Kappes v Chicago, 119 Ill App 436 (27 March 1905)

Com of Massachusetts v Strauss, 188 Mass 229; 74 NE 308 (19 May 1905) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Detroit & T S L R Co v Campbell, 140 Mich 384; 103 NW 856 (8 June 1905)

Alperson v Whalen, 74 Neb 680; 105 NW 474 (19 Oct 1905)

G. Falk & Bro and American Cigar Co v US, 146 F 484 (CA 2, NY 17 Jan 1906). SCB: 145 F 574 (tax case)

American Tobacco Co v Polisco, 104 Va 777; 52 SE 563 (18 Jan 1906) (trade case)

McQuerry v Metropolitan Street Railway Co, 117 Mo App 255; 92 SW 912 (5 Feb 1906)

Hale v Henkel, 201 US 43; 26 S Ct 370; 50 L Ed 652 (SD NY, 12 March 1906) (anti-trust case subpoena during investigation)

McAlister, Dir, Am Tobacco Co v Henkel, 201 US 90; 26 S Ct 385; 50 L Ed 671 (12 March 1906) (anti-trust case, subpoena during investigation)

Dempsey v Stout, 76 Neb 152; 107 NW 235 [51 LNS 562] (22 March 1906)

U.S. Tobacco Co v McGreenery, 144 F 531 (D Mass, 23 March 1906) (unfair trade practices case)

Werckmeister v American Tobacco Co, 74 CCA 682; 144 F 1023 (CA 2, 4 April 1906). SCB: 138 F 162 (business practices case, alleging copyright infringement)

American Tobacco Co v Werckmeister, 76 CCA 647; 146 F 375 (CA 2, 4 April 1906) (copyright infringement case). SCB: 138 F 162

State v Lowry, 166 Ind 372; 77 NE 728; 4 LRA (NS) 528; 9 Ann Cas 350 (26 April 1906) (ban on cigarette manufacture, giveaway, and sales)

Com of Massachusetts v Strauss, 191 Mass 545; 78 NE 136; 11 LNS 968 (17 May 1906), rev den 207 US 599 (1907) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case, conviction upheld)

United States v MacAndrews & Forbes Co, 149 F 823 (SD NY, December 1906) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

United States v MacAndrews & Forbes Co, 149 F 836 (SD NY, 17 Jan 1907)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Allen Bros Tobacco Co, 151 F 819 (WD Va, 20 March 1907) (trademark infringement and unfair competition case)

A. Santaella & Co v Otto F. Lange Co, 84 CCA 145; 155 F 719 (CA 8, Iowa, 17 June 1907) (cigar salesman termination case)

Locker v American Tobacco Co, 121 App Div 443; 106 NYS 115 (4 Oct 1907) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Strauss v Com of Massachusetts, 207 US 599; 52 L Ed 358; 28 S Ct 253 (15 Oct 1907) SCB: 188 Mass 229, 74 NE 308; 191 Mass 545, 78 NE 136, 11 LNS 968

State v Goodrich, 133 Wis 242; 113 NW 388; 14 Ann Cas 932; 11 CJ 766 (15 Oct 1907) (cigarette ban like Iowa's)

American Tobacco Co v Werckmeister, 207 US 284; 28 S Ct 72; 52 L Ed (2 Dec 1907). SCB: 76 CCA 647; 146 F 375

U.S. v G Falk & Bro, 204 US 143; 27 S Ct 191; 51 L Ed 411 (7 Dec 1907) (tax case). SCB: GA 4124, T.D. 19715; 145 F 475; 146 F 484 (tax case)

Werckmeister v American Tobacco Co, 207 US 375 (CA 2, 16 Dec 1907). SCB: 138 F 162; 74 CCA 682; 144 F 1023

People ex rel. Berlizheimer v Busse, 231 Ill 251; 83 NE 175 (17 Dec 1907)

Owen County Burley Tobacco Society v Brumback, 128 Ky 137; 107 SW 710 (7 Feb 1908) (issue of telling a tobacco farmer to not sell outside the association, pooling sales)

Hairston v Danville & W R Co, 208 US 598; 28 S Ct 331; 52 L Ed 637 (Va, 24 Feb 1908) (eminent domain case, taking private land to aid tobacco company transport)

Fifth Ave Coach Co v City of New York, 58 Misc 401, 111 NYS 759; 145 N Y S Rep (March 1908) (affirming City authority to regulate tobacco advertising)

Fifth Ave Coach Co v City of New York, 126 App Div 657; 110 NYS 1037; 144 N Y S Rep (5 June 1908) (refusing injunction to ban City from regulating tobacco advertising). SCB: 58 Misc 401, 111 NYS 759

U.S. Tobacco Co v American Tobacco Co, et al., 163 F 701 (SD NY, 10 July 1908) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Larus & Bro Co v American Tobacco Co and Weisert Bros Tobacco Co v American Tobacco Co, 163 F 712 (SD NY, 10 July 1908) (denying rehearing of 163 F 701)

United States v American Tobacco Co, 164 F 700 (SD NY, 15 Dec 1908)

United States v American Tobacco Co, 164 F 1024 (SD NY, 15 Dec 1908)

Monarch Tobacco Works v American Tobacco Co, 165 F 774 (WD Ky, 21 Dec 1908) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Fifth Ave Coach Co v City of New York, 194 NY 26, 86 NE 824; 21 LRA(NS) 744; 16 A & E Ann Cas 695 (5 Jan 1909) (affirming City authority to regulate tobacco advertising. SCB: 58 Misc 401, 111 NYS 759; 126 App Div 657, 110 NYS 1037

State v Sbragia, 138 Wis 579; 119 NW 290 (26 Jan 1909)

American Tobacco Co v Commonwealth, 115 SW 754 (Ky App, 29 Jan 1909) (anti-trust case)

American Tobacco Co v Commonwealth, 115 SW 755 (Ky App, 3 Feb 1909) (reversing conviction)

American Tobacco Co v Commonwealth, 115 SW 756 (Ky App, 3 Feb 1909) (indictment was not written pursuant to the revised statute)

American Tobacco Co v Polacsek, 170 F 117 (SD NY, 5 March 1909)

American Tobacco Co v Com, 116 SW 1176 (Ky App, 25 March 1909) (monopoly case re ban on raising/lowering prices above/below market value). SCB: 115 SW 754

Commonwealth v Fisher, 226 Pa 189; 75 A 204 (3 Jan 1910)

M'Lauchlan v Anderson, 1 Scot Law Times 127; 48 Sc L Rep 349; 4 SWCC 376 (1 Feb 1910)

Ware-Kramer Tobacco Co v American Tobacco Co, 178 F 117 (ED NC, 8 March 1910) (monopoly case)

Watson v Kentucky & Indiana Bridge & R Co, 137 Ky 619; 126 SW 146 (Ky App, 18 March 1910)

City of Seattle v Dencker, 58 Wash 501; 108 P 1086 (28 May 1910)

Ware-Kramer Tobacco Co v American Tobacco Co, 180 F 160 (ED NC, 16 June 1910) (criminal conspriacy issue, violation of criminal law can result in damage to private citizen)

Watson v Kentucky & Indiana Bridge & R Co, 137 Ky 619; 129 SW 341 (17 June 1910). SCB: 137 Ky 619; 126 SW 146

Collins v Com of Ky, 141 Ky 565; 133 SW 233 (13 Jan 1911) (tobacco farmer pooling case)

Maloney v Com of Ky, 141 Ky 570; 133 SW 235 (13 Jan 1911) (tobacco farmer pooling case)

Norfolk & W.R. Co v Dixie Tobacco Co, 111 Va 813; 69 SE 1106 (26 Jan 1911) (business practices case; issue of damage to tobacco in shipment)

Hershberg v City of Barbourville, 142 Ky 60; 133 SW 985; 1911 Ky LEXIS 130; 34 LNS 141; Ann Cas 1912D, 189 (3 Feb 1911)

United States v American Tobacco Co, 221 US 106; 31 S Ct 632; 55 L Ed 663 (NY, 29 May 1911). SCB: 164 F 700

Fifth Ave Coach Co v City of New York, 221 US 467; 31 S Ct 709; 55 L Ed 815 (29 May 1911) (case upholding City authority to regulate tobacco advertising). SCB: 126 App Div 657; 110 NYS 1037; 58 Misc 401, 111 NYS 759; 194 NY 26, 21 LRA(NS) 744, 86 NE 824; 16 A & E Ann Cas 695

American Tobacco Co v Bland, 145 Ky 157; 140 SW 69 (27 Oct 1911) (business case, resisting worker compensation claim)

United States v American Tobacco Co, 191 F 371 (15 Nov 1911). SCB: 164 F 700

American Tobacco Co v Globe Tobacco Co, 193 F 1015 (D Mich, 2 Dec 1911) (unfair trade practices case)

Burley Tobacco Society v Thomas, 145 Ky 748; 141 SW 66 (8 Dec 1911) (tobacco farmer sold outside the society's sprocess)

Burley Tobacco Society v Thomas, 145 Ky 750; 141 SW 67 (8 Dec 1911) (tobacco farmer sold ouside the society's process)

In re Leaf Tobacco Board of Trade of the City of New York, 222 US 578; 32 S Ct 833; 56 L Ed 323 (11 Dec 1911)

Locker v American Tobacco Co, 194 F 232 (22 Jan 1912) (issue of specificity in allegations, where guilt of others is shown, and this defendant knew)

Latimer v U S, 223 US 501; 32 S Ct 242; 56 L Ed 526 (PR, 19 Feb 1912) (trade case, re tax on sweepings used in cigarettes)

United Cigarette Machine Co v Wright, 193 F 1023 (CA 4, NC, 12 March 1912) (business practices case) SCB: 132 F 195; 156 F 244

Com. of Kentucky v International Harvester Co of America, 147 Ky 564; 144 SW 1064 (Ky App, 16 March 1912) (first in a series of convictions, under Kentucky law letting tobacco growers but not manufacturers market in combination)

Com. of Kentucky v International Harvester Co of America, 144 Ky 795; 146 SW 12 (Ky App, 18 April 1912) (second conviction)

Burley Tobacco Society v Monroe, 148 Ky 289; 146 SW 725 (Ky App, 10 May 1912) (tobacco farmer pooling case)

Int'l Harvester Co of America v Com of Kentucky, 148 Ky 572; 147 SW 1199 (Ky App, 28 May 1912) (third conviction)

Locker v American Tobacco Co, 197 F 495 (SD NY, 18 July 1912) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case; only government can get a preventive injunction; a private individual can only get after-the-fact damages)

Locker v American Tobacco Co, 200 F 973 (SD NY, 29 Nov 1912) (issue of specificity)

Burley Tobacco Society v Gillaspy, 51 Ind App 583; 100 NE 89 (12 Dec 1912)

Athanasaw v U S, 227 US 326; 33 S Ct 285; 57 L Ed 528 (24 Feb 1913) (crime case, white slave issue, girl recruited for debauchery by smokers)

American Tobacco Co v People's Tobacco Co, Ltd, 204 F2d 58 (CA 5, La, 12 April 1913) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Texas & P R. Co v Stewart, 228 US 357; 33 S Ct 548; 57 L Ed 875 (Texas, 21 April 1913) (passenger injured leaving smoking car)

Norfolk & W.R. Co v Dixie Tobacco Co, 228 US 593; 33 S Ct 609; 57 L Ed 980 (12 May 1913) (business practices case; issue of damage to tobacco in shipment). SCB: 111 Va 813; 69 SE 1106

Manson v Forth & Clyde Steamship Co, [1913] SC 921; 50 Scot L R 475; [1913] WC & Ins Rep 399; 6 BWCC 830 (23 May 1913) (worker cigarette fire case)

Lebus v Stansifer, 157 SW 727 (Ky App, 17 June 1913) (pooling case)

Allen v State, 10 Okla Crim Rep 75; 133 P 1138 (26 July 1913)

State v Olson, 26 ND 304; 144 NW 661; LRA 1918B, 975 (29 Nov 1913)

City of Zion v Behrens, 262 Ill 510; 104 NE 836; 51 LNS 562 (21 Feb 1914)

International Harvester Co of America v Com. of Kentucky, 234 US 216; 34 S Ct 853; 58 L Ed 1284 (8 June 1914) (business practices case; Kentucky law allowed tobacco growers to market in combination, but banned manufacturers from doing so; convicted IHC in three different courts; IHC appealed on constitutional grounds including vagueness, and prevailed). SCB: (a) 147 Ky 564, 144 SW 1064, (b) 144 Ky 795, 146 SW 12, and (c) 148 Ky 572, 147 SW 1199

Collins v Com. of Kentucky, 234 US 634; 34 S Ct 924; 58 L Ed 1510 (22 June 1914) (farmer vs tobacco pool case). SCB: 141 Ky 565; 133 SW 233

Malone v Com. of Kentucky, 234 US 639; 34 S Ct 926; 58 L Ed 1512 (22 June 1914) (farmer vs tobacco pool case). SCB: 141 Ky 570; 133 SW 235

Locker v American Tobacco Co, 218 F 447 (CA 2, 10 Nov 1914) (a law violation is not proof of harm per se to a private individual)

People v Blumerich, 183 Mich 133; 149 NW 1040 (18 Dec 1914)

Commonwealth v American Tobacco Co, 162 Ky 716; 172 SW 1085 (11 Feb 1915) (tax case)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v Cannon, 132 Tenn 419; 178 SW 1009; LRA 1916A 940; Ann Cas 1917A 179 (25 Aug 1915)

Commonwealth v American Tobacco Co, 167 Ky 157; 180 SW 58 (2 Dec 1915) (price fixing case, remanded to apply the Brent decision)

United Cigar Stores v Stewart, 144 Ga 724; 87 SE 1034 (22 Feb 1916) (tax case)

D. H. Watzen & Co v Louisville Tobacco Warehouse Co, 240 F 919 (CA 6, Ky, 17 Nov 1916)

Chludzinski v Standard Oil Co, 176 App Div 87; 162 NYS 225 (28 Dec 1916)

Balch v State ex rel. Grigsby, Co Atty, 65 Okl 146; 164 P 776 (30 Jan 1917) (public nuisance case)

Tandy & Fairleigh Tobacco Co v Hopkinsville, 174 Ky 189; 192 SW 46 (23 Feb 1917) (tax case)

Haller v City of Lansing, 195 Mich 753; 162 NW 335; LRA 1917E, 324 (9 April 1917) (worker compensation case involving fire)

Dzikowska v Superior Steel Co, 65 PLJ 502; 31 York Law Record 67 (23 April 1917). SCB: WCAB. (Pennsylvania worker compensation case)

American Tobacco Co v Troutman, 175 Ky 436; 194 SW 543 (4 May 1917) (business case, resisting worker compensation claim)

Olson v State of North Dakota, 245 US 676; 38 S Ct 13; 62 L Ed 542 (17 Oct 1917). SCB: 26 ND 304; 144 NW 661

Post Printing & Publishing Co v Brewster, Atty Gen of Kansas, 246 F 321 (D Kan, 8 Dec 1917)

M. B. Fahey Tobacco Co v Senior, 247 F 809 (ED Pa, 22 Dec 1917) (copyright and trademark case)

Dzikowska v Superior Steel Co, 259 Pa 578; 103 A 351; LRA 1918F, 888 (7 Jan 1918). SCB: 65 PLJ 502; 31 York 67

In re Betts, 66 Ind App 484; 118 NE 551 (18 Jan 1918) (worker compensation case)

People's Tobacco Co v American Tobacco Co, 246 US 79; 38 S Ct 233; 62 L Ed 587; Ann Cas 1918C, 537 (4 March 1918). SCB: 204 F2d 58 (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Dawkins v Billingsley, 69 Okla 259; 172 P 69 (9 April 1918)

Pillars v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 117 Miss 490; 78 So 365 (15 April 1918) (dangerous tobacco product liability case)

State v C. C. Taft Co, 183 Iowa 548; 167 NW 467; 9 ALR 390 (7 May 1918) (institutionalizing the right to fresh and pure air via an 1897 cigarette ban)

Whiting-Mead Commercial Co v Industrial Accident Commission, 178 Cal 505; 173 P 1105; 5 ALR 1518 (3 July 1918) (workers' compensation case)

M. B. Fahey Tobacco Co v Senior, 164 CCA 495; 252 F 579 (CA 3, Pa, 27 July 1918) (copyright and trademark case). SCB: 247 F 809

American Tobacco Co v Bowling Green, 181 Ky 416; 205 SW 570 (27 Sep 1918) (tax case)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v City of Lexington, 181 Ky 503; 205 SW 592 (4 Oct 1918) (license case)

Rish v Iowa Portland Cement Co, 186 Iowa 443; 170 NW 532 (23 Jan 1919)

Compania General de Tabacos de Filipinas v Alhambra Cigar, 249 US 72 (Philippines, 3 March 1919) (trade-name infringement case)

Taft Co, et al v Abbey, 185 Iowa 1069; 171 NW 719 (11 April 1919) (upholding reporting violators of the 1897 cigarette sales ban, including owners of buildings wherein illegal sales occured)

C. C. Taft Co v State of Iowa, 252 US 569; 40 S Ct 345; 64 L Ed 720 (15 March 1920). SCB: 183 Iowa 548; 167 NW 467; 9 ALR 390

Taylor v Industrial Commission, 31 OCA 390; 13 Ohio App 262 (19 June 1920)

State v Nossaman, 107 Kan 715; 193 P 347; 20 ALR 921 (6 Nov 1920)

Palmer v Keene Forestry Ass'n, 80 NH 68; 112 A 798; 13 ALR 995 (1 Feb 1921) (smoking-caused fire case)

Jefferson v Derbyshire Farmers, Ltd, [1920] All Eng 129; 2 KB 281; 13 ALR 989 (3 Feb 1921)

United Cigar Stores Co v United Confectioners, 92 NJ Eq 449; 113 A 226; 17 ALR 779 (28 Feb 1921) (unfair competition by deceptive similarity to another's business)

Gray v Central Warehouse Co, 181 NC 166; 106 SE 657 (6 April 1921) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Beech Nut Packing Co v P. Lorillard Co, 287 F 271 (D SD NY, 9 June 1921)

Nossaman v State of Kansas, 258 US 633; 42 S Ct 314; 66 L Ed 802 (20 March 1922). SCB: 107 Kan 715; 193 P 347

Jones v Union Guano Co, 183 NC 338; 111 SE 612 (19 April 1922) (tobacco farmer case saying deleterious ingredients in fertilizer injured tobacco crop).

Schwartz v Michigan Warehouse Co, 219 Mich 401; 189 NW 1 (20 July 1922)

Feeney v Standard Oil Co, 58 Cal App 587; 209 P 85 (20 July 1922)

Federal Trade Commission v P Lorillard Co and American Tobacco Co, Inc, 283 F 999 (D SD NY, J. Manton, 3 Oct 1922) (discovery denied)

Ottinger v School District No 25, 157 Ark 82; 247 SW 789 (5 Feb 1923) (P 790 cites that his tobacco chewing "might be a good reason for not employing him in the first instance; but it would not be a sufficient ground for his discharge after he had been employed." Reason for latter: "He had been employed by the school district to teach two schools prior to the execution of the contract in question, and his personal habits were well known.")

Wright v Hirsch, 155 Ga 229; 116 SE 795 (2 March 1923) (tax case)

Tobacco Growers' Co-op Assn v Jones, 185 NC 265; 117 SE 174 (11 April 1923) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Storm v Industrial Accident Commission, 191 Cal 4; 214 P 874 (12 April 1923)

Payne v Combs, 198 Ky 749; 249 SW 1031 (24 April 1923)

State v P Lorillard Co, 181 Wis 347; 193 NW 613 (1 May 1923) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Springer v North, 205 App Div 754; 200 NYS 248 (19 June 1923)

Keyser Canning Co v Klots Throwing Co, 94 W Va 346; 118 SE 521; 31 ALR 283 (26 June 1923) (fire case, court recommended firing the smoker causing it)

Brown v City of Thomasville, 156 Ga 260; 118 SE 854 (7 Sep 1923) (cigarette license denial case)

Northern Wisconsin Cooperative Tobacco Pool v Bekkedal, 182 Wis 571; 197 NW 936 (13 Nov 1923)

Kaletha v Hall Mercantile Co, 157 Minn 290; 196 NW 261 (7 Dec 1923) (worker's compensation case, fire-issue, employee Santa Claus' beard set ablaze)

Potter v Dark Tobacco Growers' Co-op Assn, 201 Ky 441; 257 SW 33 (Ky App, 21 Dec 1923) (four-year pooling agreement)

Adams v Southern Bell Telephone & Telegraph Co, 295 F 586 (CA 4, SC, 5 Feb 1924)

Jones v Union Guano Co, 264 US 171; 44 S Ct 280; 68 L Ed 623 (NC, 18 Feb 1924) (tobacco farmer case saying deleterious ingredients in fertilizer injured tobacco crop). SCB: 183 NC 338; 111 SE 612

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Loftin, 99 So 13 (Miss, 25 Feb 1924) (dangerous tobacco case)

Federal Trade Com'n v Errera, 7 FTC 375 (5 March 1924) (unfair competition by deceptive similarity to another's business)

Federal Trade Commission v American Tobacco Co, 264 US 298; 44 S Ct 336; 68 L Ed 696 (17 March 1924) (business practices case; issue of discovery subpoena to ascertain any unfair competition). SCB: 283 F 999

Tanton v McKenney, 226 Mich 245; 197 NW 510; 33 ALR 1175 (24 March 1924) (student expelled from teaching college, due to tobacco addiction)

Beech Nut Packing Co v P. Lorillard Co, 299 F 834 (D NJ, 7 May 1924)

Dark Tobacco Growers' Co-op Assn v Mason, 150 Tenn 228; 263 SW 60 (7 June 1924) (its arbitrariness, coercion and suppression doesn't necessarily make the association illegal)

Lloyd v Richardson, 158 Ga 633; 124 SE 37 (23 July 1924) (tax case)

Dark Tobacco Growers' Co-op Assn v Dunn, 150 Tenn 614; 266 SW 308 (29 Nov 1924)

Kraus v American Tobacco Co, 72 Penn L J 844 (1924) (dealer alleging manufacturer conspiracy in restraint of trade)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Stringer, 103 So 5 (Miss, 2 March 1925) (product liability case)

Kraus v American Tobacco Co, 283 Pa 146; 129 A 60 (13 April 1925). SCB: 72 PLJ 844

Beech Nut Packing Co v P. Lorillard Co, 7 F2d 967 (CA 3, NJ, 11 Sep 1925). SCB: 299 F 834.

Kraus v American Tobacco Co, 284 Pa 569; 131 A 487 (23 Nov 1925). SCB: 72 PLJ 844; 283 Pa 146, 129 A 60

American Tobacco Co v FTC, 9 F2d 570 (CA 2, J. Manton, 20 Oct 1925) (unfair trade case). SCB: 283 F 999

Brame v Dark Tobacco Growers Co-op, 212 Ky 185; 278 SW 597; 62 CJ 1075 n 8 (18 Dec 1925)

Burley Tobacco Growers Co-op Assn v Rogers, 88 Ind App 469; 150 NE 384 (27 Jan 1926) (conspiracy in restraint of trade case)

Rhode Island Hospital Trust Co v Doughton, 270 US 69; 46 S Ct 256; 70 L Ed 475 (1 March 1926) (tax case)

List v Burley Tobacco Growers' Co-op Assn, 114 Ohio St 361; 151 NE 471 (16 March 1926) (business practices case)

Tobacco Growers' Co-op. Ass'n v Danville Warehouse Co, 144 Va 456; 132 SE 482 (16 March 1926) (business practices case)

Tiralongo v Stanley Works, 104 Conn 331; 133 A 98 (8 April 1926) (worker's compensation case, involving fire)

Gospel v Southern Carbon Co, 4 La App 272 (7 May 1926)

Mack v Hugger Brothers Construction Co, 153 Tenn 260; 283 SW 448 (22 May 1926) (fire case)

Burley Tobacco Growers Co-op Assn v Samples, 215 Ky 276; 284 SW 1069 (Ky App, 22 June 1926) (tobacco pooling case; issue of whether the entire crop was delivered, was for the jury to decide)

Flowers v Williams-Rieves Lumber Co, 5 La App 49 (30 June 1926)

State v Salt Lake Tribune Publishing Co, 68 Utah 187; 249 P 474 (17 Sep 1926)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v United States, 61 Ct Cls 693 (15 Dec 1926)

Burley Tobacco Growers Co-op Assn v Devine, 217 Ky 320; 289 SW 253 (Ky App, 17 Dec 1926) (a tobacco farmer can stop raising tobacco; but not to evade the tobacco pool, via pretense of having transferred the farming to his daughter)

Lionel's Cigar Store v McFarland, 162 La 956; 111 So 341 (3 Jan 1927) (tax case)

Northern Wisconsin Cooperative Tobacco Pool v Oleson, 191 Wis 586; 211 NW 923 (11 Jan 1927)

Beech Nut Packing Co v P. Lorillard Co, 273 US 629; 47 S Ct 481; 71 L Ed 810 (11 April 1927). SCB 299 F 834, 7 F2d 967

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v U.S., 274 US 215; 47 S Ct 581; 71 L Ed 1006 (2 May 1927) (t). SCB: 61 Ct Cls 693

Federal Trade Commission v American Tobacco Co, 274 US 543; 47 S Ct 663; 71 L Ed 1193 (31 May 1927). SCB: 9 F2d 570

Doscher v Query, 21 F2d 521 (ED SC, 15 Aug 1927) (tax case)

Weiner v Commonwealth, 221 Ky 455; 298 SW 1075 (21 Oct 1927)

Burley Tobacco Growers Co-op Assn v Pennebaker Home for Girls, 221 Ky 718; 299 SW 734 (25 Oct 1927) (issue of stolen tobacco, in a pooling situation)

Liberty Warehouse Co v Burley Tobacco Growers' Co-op Marketing, 276 US 71; 48 S Ct 291; 72 L Ed 473 (20 Feb 1928) (private remedy for unlawful trade practices; with history of such cases)

Asotsky v Beach, 319 Mo 810; 5 SW2d 22; 62 ALR 95 (9 April 1928) (tax case)

Burley Tobacco Growers Co-op Assn v Boyd, 6 SW2d 241 (Ky App, 1 May 1928) (failure to account for the tobacco delivered to the pool)

Exchange Drug Co v State Tax Commission, 218 Alabama 115; 117 So 673 (10 May 1928) (tax case; see also 1980's activism by an Alabama Mayor)

Compania General de Tabacos de Filipinas, 26 Philippines Official Gazette #65 p 1712 (31 May 1928) (tax case)

Smokador Mfg Co v Tubular Products Co, 27 F2d 948 (D Conn, 18 July 1928) (trademark infringement issues)

Fischer v R. Hoe & Co, Inc, 224 App Div 335; 230 NYS 755 (20 Sep 1928)

Burley Tobacco Growers Co-op Assn v Tipton, 11 SW2d 119 (Ky App, 27 Nov 1928) (case re the 1% fee to the pooling association, issue of its alleged inactivity)

Exchange Drug Co v State Tax Commission, 278 US 577; 49 S Ct 176; 73 L Ed 515 (2 Jan 1929). SCB: 218 Alabama 115; 117 So 673 (tax case)

Porto Rican-American Tobacco Co v American Tobacao Co, 30 F2d 234 (CA 2, PR, 7 Jan 1929) cert den 279 US 858 (1929) (monopoly issue, predatory pricing, dumping below cost in Puerto Rico to undercut competition)

Wickham v Glenside Woolen Mills, 225 App Div 838; 232 NYS 917 (16 Jan 1929)

State v Lagomarcino-Grupe Co, 207 Iowa 621; 223 NW 512 (5 Feb 1929) (licensing aspects case)

Smokador Mfg Co v Tubular Products Co, 31 F2d 255 (CA 2, Conn, 4 March 1929). SCB: 27 F2d 948 (trademark infringement issues)

Burley Tobacco Growers Co-op Assn v Roeder, 88 Ind App 649; 165 NE 330 (6 March 1929) (fraud allegations)

Gilchrist v Interborough Rapid Transit Co, 279 US 159; 49 S Ct 282; 73 L Ed 652 (NY, 8 April 1929) (rapid transit rate case, referencing ban on having more than one smoking car per train)

Compania General de Tabacos de Filipinas, 279 US 306; 49 S Ct 304; 73 L Ed 704 (8 April 1929). SCB: 26 POG #65 p 1712

Brennan v City of Seattle, 151 Wash 665; 276 P 886 (23 April 1929)

American Tobacco Co v Porto Rican-American Tobacco Co, 279 US 858; 49 S Ct 353; 73 L Ed 999 (29 April 1929). SCB 30 F2d 234

Yore v Pacific Gas & Electric Co, 99 Cal App 81; 277 P 878 (21 May 1929)

Mack v Hugger Brothers Construction Co, 10 Tenn App 402 (20 July 1929)

Wickham v Glenside Woolen Mills, 252 NY 11; 168 NE 446 (15 Oct 1929). SCB: 225 App Div 838; 232 NYS 917

Wood v Saunders, 228 App Div 69; 238 NYS 571 (10 Jan 1930) (gas station fire caused by smoker smoking while refueling)

Wood v Saunders, 228 App Div 705; 239 NYS 768 (22 Jan 1930)

Foley v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 136 Misc 468; 241 NYS 233 (1 April 1930)

Rushing v Texas Co, 199 NC 173; 154 SE 1 (2 July 1930) (gas station fire case)

Dattilo's Case, 273 Mass 333; 173 NE 552 (28 Nov 1930) (worker's smoker fire led to his compensation case)

Wood v Saunders, 255 NY 594; 175 NE 327 (6 Jan 1931). SCB: 228 App Div 705; 239 NYS 768

Lovallo v American Brass Co, 112 Conn 635; 153 A 783 (3 March 1931)

Foley v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 232 App Div 833; 249 NYS 924 (6 March 1931). SCB 136 Misc 468; 241 NYS 233

Rogers, Richard, Stockholder v American Tobacco Co, 243 Misc 306; 257 NYS 321 (13 March 1931) (stockholder is entitled to see company records)

Maloney Tank Mfg Co v Mid-Continent Petroleum Corp, 49 F2d 146 (CA 10, 30 March 1931) (oil company fire caused by employees' smoking on the job)

State v Packer Corp, 77 Utah 500; 297 P 1013 (7 April 1931)

Scott v P Lorillard Co, 108 N J Eq 153; 154 A 515 (10 April 1931) (stockholder case)

Rogers v American Tobacco Co, 233 App Div 708; 249 NYS 993 (8 May 1931) affirming 257 NYS 321

Weiner v D. A. Schulte, Inc, 275 Mass 379; 176 NE 114 (26 May 1931)

State v Packer Corp, 78 Utah 177; 2 P2d 114 (30 July 1931). SCB: 77 Utah 500; 297 P 1013

Rogers v Hill, George, President, Am Tobacco Co, 53 F2d 395 (SD NY, 29 Oct 1931) (stockholder case alleging excessive pay to company officials)

Rogers v Hill, Pres, ATC, 53 F2d 398 (SD NY, 29 Oct 1931) (stockholder case alleging excessive pay to company officials)

Rogers v Guaranty Trust Co, 53 F2d 398 (29 Oct 1931) (accompanying stockholder case)

Scott v P Lorillard Co, 109 N J Eq 417; 157 A 388 (10 Dec 1931). SCB 108 N J Eq 153; 154 A 515

Ford Hopkins Co v Iowa City, 240 NW 687 (9 Feb 1932) (cigarette license denial case)

Rogers v Guaranty Trust Co and American Tobacco Co, 60 F2d 106 (SD NY, 16 Feb 1932) (rejection of stockholder case)

Packer Corp v State of Utah, 285 US 105; 52 S Ct 273; 76 L Ed 2d 643 (23 Feb 1932). SCB: 78 Utah 177; 2 P2d 114

Burnet, Comm'r of Int Revenue v Commonwealth Improvement Co, 57 F2d 47 (CA 3, 17 March 1932) (tax case). SCB: 20 BTA 1189

American Tobacco Co v Grider, 243 Ky 87; 47 SW2d 735 (18 March 1932) (business case, resisting worker compensation claim)

Capone v U.S., 286 US 553; 52 S Ct 503; 76 L Ed 1288 (2 May 1932) (smoker pattern of crime case). SCB: 56 F2d 927; 30 STC 885

Rogers v Hill, 60 F2d 109 (CA 2, NY, 13 June 1932) (reversing the lower court decision)

Rogers v Guaranty Trust Co and American Tobacco Co, 60 F2d 114 (CA 2, 13 June 1932)

Gates v Hughson, 186 Ark 348; 53 SW2d 581 (24 Oct 1932) (licensing aspects case)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v Rankin, 246 Ky 65; 54 SW2d 612 (18 Nov 1932)

Burnet, Comm'r of Int Revenue v Commonwealth Improvement Co, 287 US 415; 53 S Ct 198; 77 L Ed 399 (12 Dec 1932). SCB: 57 F2d 47 (tax case)

Allen v Posternock, 107 Pa Super 332; 163 A 336 (16 Dec 1932) (fire case; beauty salon smoker injured customer, by smoking while using flammable chemicals, violating employer no-smoking rule)

Rogers v Guaranty Trust Co and American Tobacco Co, 288 US 123; 53 S Ct 295; 77 L Ed 652 (23 Jan 1933). SCB: 60 F2d 106; 60 F2d 114

Rogers v Hill, 62 F2d 1079 (CA 2, 6 Feb 1933)

Bernstein v Marshalltown, 215 Iowa 1168; 248 NW 26; 86 ALR 782 (4 April 1933) (cigarette license denial case)

Ford Hopkins Co v Iowa City, 216 Iowa 1286; 248 NW 668 (15 May 1933) (affirming cigarette license denial). SCB: 240 NW 687

Rogers v Hill, 289 US 582; 53 S Ct 731; 77 L Ed 1385 (29 May 1933). SCB: 62 F2d 1079

Corum v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 205 NC 213; 171 SE 78 (11 Oct 1933)

Ex parte Nash, 55 Nev 92; 26 P2d 353 (3 Nov 1933)

Kelly v Louisiana Oil Refining Co, 167 Tenn 101; 66 SW2d 997 (13 Jan 1934)

Dye v Rule, 138 Kan 808; 28 P2d 758 (27 Jan 1934) (service station smoking-caused fire)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v Wallace, 69 SW2d 857 (Tex Civ App, 1 March 1934)

State v Louisiana Stores Co, Inc, 154 So 464 (La App, 4 May 1934) (licensing aspects case)

State v Southern Mercantile Co, Inc, 180 La 753; 157 So 551 (29 Oct 1934)

British-American Tobacco Co v Helvering, Com'r of Internal Revenue, 293 US 95; 55 S Ct 55; 79 L Ed 218 (5 Nov 1934) (tax case)

Supervisor of Public Accounts v Montreuil, 157 So 783 (La App, 26 Nov 1934) (tax case)

United States v Butler, et al., Receivers of Hoosac Mills Corp, 297 US 1 (1935)

Keith v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 207 NC 645; 178 SE 90 (28 Jan 1935) (dangerous tobacco case, injury due to big green bug embedded in tobacco, alleged due to manufacturing process)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v Meyer, 101 Ind App 420; 194 NE 206 (14 Feb 1935) (case alleging copyright infringement)

Triplett v Western Public Service Co, 128 Neb 835; 260 NW 387 (26 April 1935) (prairie fire caused by workers' smoking)

Haddix v Tomich, 245 App Div 727; 280 NYS 56 (3 June 1935)

Kendrick v Adamson, 51 Ga App 402; 180 SE 647 (15 June 1935) (jailed drunk smoker fire death)

Ex parte Kimberlin, 126 Tex 60; 86 SW2d 717 (9 Oct 1935)

Triplett v Western Public Service Co, 129 Neb 799; 263 NW 229 (8 Nov 1935). SCB: 128 Neb 835; 260 NW 387

Sheppard v Musser, 89 SW2d 222 (Tex Civ App, 22 Nov 1935) (tax case)

Torosian v Industrial Accident Commission, 11 Cal App 2d 204; 53 P2d 384 (10 Jan 1936)

Gorman v State, 130 Tex Crim 149; 93 SW2d 1145 (5 Feb 1936) (licensing aspects case)

Burton v Crowell Publishing Co, 82 F2d 154 (CA 2, NY, 10 Feb 1936) (depraved "Camel" cigarette ad case, alleging obscenity, indecent exposure, deformity, mental perversion, salaciousness, etc.)

Dow Drug Co v Nieman, 57 Ohio App 190; 13 NE2d 130 (17 Feb 1936) (product liability case)

Sheppard v Musser, 127 Tex 193; 92 SW2d 219 (13 March 1936). SCB: 89 SW2d 222

Block v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 163 Misc 858; 296 NYS 920 (26 April 1936) (product liability case)

Jones v Eastern Greyhound Lines, Inc, 159 Misc 662; 288 NYS 523 (9 June 1936) (travel case, fellow passenger, a smoker, causing injury by smoking on the bus)

Delk v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 180 SC 436; 186 SE 383 (10 June 1936) (product liability case)

Musser v Sheppard, 299 US 513; 57 S Ct 121; 78 L Ed 379 (9 Nov 1936). SCB: 127 Tex 193; 92 SW2d 219

Flynn v Department of Labor & Industries, 188 Wash 346; 62 P2d 728 (30 Nov 1936) (worker's compensation case)

Ex parte Winn, 61 Okla Crim 1; 64 P2d 927 (31 Dec 1936) (licensing aspects case)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v United States, 299 US 383; 57 S Ct 239; 81 L Ed 294 (4 Jan 1937) (tax case)

Block v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 162 Misc 325; 296 NYS 922 (15 Jan 1937). SCB: 163 Misc 858; 296 NYS 920

Supervisor of Public Accounts v Twelve Cases of Smoking Tobacco, 172 So 364 (La App, 8 Feb 1937) (tax case with licensing aspectse)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v United States, 300 US 686; 57 S Ct 28; 81 L Ed (1937). SCB: 299 US 383

Hood v Tabor Academy, 296 Mass 509; 6 NE2d 818 (24 Feb 1937) (student expelled for smoking in village)

Currin v Henry Wallace, Secretary of Agriculture, 19 F Supp 211 (ED NC, 19 April 1937)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Com'r of Internal Revenue, 22 F Supp 187 (MD NC, 27 April 1937) (tax case)

Illinois Cigarette Service Co v City of Chicago, 89 F2d 610 (CA 7, Ill, 29 April 1937)

Vincennes Steel Corp v Gibson, 194 Ark 58; 106 SW2d 173 (17 May 1937) (outdoor fire in field caused by employee smoking)

Townsend v Yeomans, Attorney General of Georgia, 301 US 441; 57 S Ct 842; 81 L Ed 1210 (MD Ga, 24 May 1937) (warehousemen fees case)

Shuck v Carney, 22 Tenn App 125; 118 SW2d 896 (24 Nov 1937)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Robertson, Com'r of Internal Revenue, 94 F2d 167 (CA 4, NC, 4 Jan 1938) (tax case). SCB: 22 F Supp 187

Keilson Cigar Co v Braden, 59 Ohio App 562; 18 NE2d 986 (10 Jan 1938)

Com'r of Internal Revenue v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 35 BTA 949 (1938) (tax case)

Matter of Julep Tobacco Co, 27 FTC 1637 (27 Sep 1938) (unfair business practices case)

Matter of Green River Tobacco Co, 27 FTC 1547 (7 Nov 1938) (unfair business practices case)

Meditz v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 167 Misc 176; 3 NYS2d 357 (29 Jan 1938)

Herr v Simplex Paper Box Corp, 330 Pa 129; 198 A 309 (31 March 1938)

Henry Wallace, Secretary of Agriculture v Currin, 95 F2d 856 (CA 4, NC, 5 April 1938). SCB: 19 F Supp 211

Knecht v Castleman River Railroad Co, 25 F Supp 650 (D Pa, 9 April 1938)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Robertson, Com'r of Internal Revenue, 304 US 563; 58 S Ct 944; 82 L Ed 1530 (25 April 1938). SCB: 22 F Supp 187; 94 F2d 167 (tax case)

R J Reynolds Tobacco Co v Robertson, Com'r of Internal Revenue, 304 US 589; 58 S Ct 1045; 82 L Ed 1549 (23 May 1938). SCB: 22 F Supp 187; 94 F2d 167; 304 US 563, 58 S Ct 944, 82 L Ed 1530

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Com'r of Internal Revenue, 97 F2d 302 (CA 4, 6 June 1938). SCB: 35 BTA 949 (tax case)

Meditz v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 25 NYS2d 315 (21 June 1938). SCB: 167 Misc 176; 3 NYS2d 357

Philip Morris and Co v Stephano Brothers, 331 Pa 278; 200 A 605 (30 June 1938) (dividends on stock case)

Mulford v Smith, 24 F Supp 919 (MD Ga, 7 Oct 1938)

Knecht v Castleman River Railroad Co, 25 F Supp 652 (D Pa, 16 Nov 1938)

British-American Tobacco Co v United States, 89 Ct Cl 438; 1939 WL 4266 (Ct Cl, 1939)

DeLape v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 25 F Supp 1006 (D Cal, 17 Jan 1939)

Moise v Fruit Dispatch Co, 135 Neb 684; 283 NW 495 (20 Jan 1939)

Currin v Henry Wallace, Sec'y of Agriculture, 306 US 1; 59 S Ct 379; 83 L Ed 441 (NC, 30 Jan 1939). SCB: 19 F Supp 211; 95 F2d 856 (case of opposition to Tobacco Inspection Act)

Helvering, Com'r of Internal Revenue v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 306 US 110; 59 S Ct 423; 83 L Ed 536 (30 Jan 1939). SCB: 97 F2d 302; 35 BTA 949 (tax case)

Webb v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 121 W Va 115; 2 SE2d 898 (14 March 1939) (smokers' rights case)

Mulford v Smith, 307 US 38; 59 S Ct 648; 83 L Ed 1092 (17 April 1939). SCB: 24 F Supp 919 (tobacco quota case)

Knecht v Castleman River Railroad Co, 104 F2d 677 (CA 3, Pa, 12 June 1939). SCB: 25 F Supp 650, 652

McAfee v Travis Gas Corp, 131 SW2d 139 (Tex Civ App, 28 June 1939) (on-job gas pipeline explosion caused by smoker smoking, leading to injury)

Head v Cigar Sales Co, 188 Ga 452; 4 SE2d 203 (13 July 1939)

Bradford Dyeing Assoc'n v NLRB, 106 F2d 119 (CA 1, 2 Aug 1939) (issues including discharge for smoking)

Automatic Devices Corp v Cuno Engineering Corp, 34 F Supp 144 (D Conn, 19 Sep 1939) (cigar lighter patent infringement case)

Stone v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 172 Misc 591; 14 NYS2d 922 (3 Oct 1939) (case alleging copyright infringement)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v DeLape, 109 F2d 598 (CA 9, Cal, 26 Jan 1940). SCB: 25 F Supp 1006

Ploch v City of St. Louis, 345 Mo 1069; 138 SW2d 1020 (6 Feb 1940) (case citing addiction)

Rogers v Hill, 34 F Supp 358 (SD NY, 27 March 1940) (request to reopen prior case, other stockholders alleged fraud in the prior Rogers cases, request denied)

In the Matter of Philip Morris & Co, Ltd., 32 FTC 278 (31 Dec 1940) (unfair business practices case)

Automatic Devices Corp v Sinko Tool & Manufacturing Co, 112 F2d 335 (CA 7, ND Ill, 27 April 1940) (patent infringement case)

In re Porto Rican American Tobacco Co, 112 F2d 655 (CA 2, 17 June 1940)

NLRB v Bradford Dyeing Assoc'n, 310 US 318; 60 US 918; 84 L Ed 1226 (20 May 1940). SCB: 106 F2d 119 (issues including discharge for smoking)

Automatic Devices Corp v Cuno Engineering Corp, 34 F Supp 146 (D Conn, 7 June 1940) (patent infringement case). SCB: #4 F Supp 144

Stone v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 260 App Div 450; 23 NYS2d 210 (1 Nov 1940). SCB: 172 Misc 591; 14 NYS2d 922 (case alleging copyright infringement)

Lindner v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 23 NYS2d 923 (10 Dec 1940)

Lindley v McKay, 201 Ark 675; 146 SW2d 545 (13 Jan 1941)

Tyson v Plymouth Country Club, 57 Montg (Pa) 140; 41 Pa D & C 116 (14 Jan 1941) (patron at bar was injured by clothing burned from smoker standing adjacent setting clothing afire)

People v Sabato, 25 NYS2d 315 (21 Jan 1941)

Automatic Devices Corp v Cuno Engineering Corp, 117 F2d 361 (CA 2, Conn, 3 Feb 1941) (patent infringement case) SCB: 34 F Supp 144; 34 F Supp 146

Axton-Fisher Tobacco Co v Ziffrin Trunk Lines, 36 F Supp 777 (WD Ky, 10 Feb 1941) (cigarettes lost-in-shipment case

McKinney v Bland, 188 Okla 661; 112 P2d 798 (25 March 1941) (fire damages caused by employee smoking)

Hughes v Georgia Power Co, 65 Ga App 163; 15 SE2d 466 (21 May 1941)

Heller v Boylan, 29 NYS 2d 653 (27 May 1941) (stockholder case alleging personal loan by George Hill to himself, using corporate funds; courts said, courts hesitate to interfere in corporate affairs, unless there is fraud by management)

McAfee v Travis Gas Corp, 137 Tex 314; 153 SW2d 442 (4 June 1941). SCB: 131 SW2d 139 (fire case, employee smoked around gas pipe, which was leaking, resultant explosion caused injury to another person)

Ward v State of Texas, 158 SW2d 516 (Tex Cr App, 18 June 1941) (issues including being "burned by lighted cigarettes being applied to his body," p 518, to extort confession to crime)

McDonough v Sears, Roebuck & Co, 127 NJL 158; 21 A2d 314 (25 July 1941) (worker compensation case, employee injured self smoking despite employer ban)

United States v American Tobacco Co, 39 F Supp 957 (ED Ky, 4 Aug 1941) (expert witness opinion requires a factual foundation)

In the Matter of Detroit Candy & Tobacco Jobbers Assn, Inc, 33 FTC 1193 (27 Aug 1941) (unfair business practices case)

United States v American Tobacco Co, 39 F Supp 957 (ED Ky, 4 Aug 1941) (unlawful monopoly case)

Edmonds v City of St. Louis, 348 Mo 1063; 156 SW2d 619 (25 Sep 1941)

Caudle v F. M. Bohannon Tobacco Co, 220 NC 105; 16 SE2d 680 (8 Oct 1941)

Cuno Engineering Corp v Automatic Devices Corp, 314 US 84; 62 S Ct 37; 86 L Ed 58 (10 Nov 1941) (c) (patent infringement case). SCB: 34 F Supp 146; 117 F2d 361

Lisenba v People of State of California, 314 US 219; 62 S Ct 280; 86 L Ed 166 (8 Dec 1941) (smoker murdered his wives, 1932-1935, using hammer blows, snake bite, drowning, for accidental death insurance). SCB: 89 P2d 39 reh den 14 Cal 2d 403, 94 P2d 569

National Labor Relations Bd v P. Lorillard Co, 314 US 512 (5 Jan 1942) (unfair labor practices, ordered to obey NLRB decision)

Western Pipe & Steel Co v Industrial Accident Commission, 49 Cal 2d 108; 121 P2d 35 (13 Jan 1942)

Century Insurance Co v Northern Ireland Road Transport Board, [1942] AC 509 (HL); 1 All Eng 491 (4 Feb 1942)

Penn Tobacco Co, 34 FTC 1636 (9 Feb 1942)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 34 FTC 1689 (22 May 1942)

Ward v State of Texas, 316 US 547; 62 S Ct 1139; 86 L Ed 1663 (1 June 1942) (issues including burning suspect with cigarettes to extort confession to crime) SCB: 158 SW2d 516

United States Lighterage Corp v Petterson Lighterage & Towing Corp., 45 F Supp 754 (D NY, 11 June 1942) (issue of stevedores' smoking with cargo damaged as a result)

American Tobacco Co v Whitney Transfer Co, 291 Ky 281; 163 SW2d 817 (Ky App, 19 June 1942) (case involving shipper fire destroying cigarettes in transit)

London Tobacco Co, 36 FTC 282 (10 March 1943)

Miles v Southeastern Motor Truck Lines, Inc, 295 Ky 156; 173 SW 2d 990 (25 June 1943) (automobile accident involving smoking causing fire thus compounding damage)

McDonough v Sears, Roebuck & Co, 130 NJL 530; 33 A2d 861 (16 Sep 1943). SCB: 127 NJL 158; 21 A2d 314

American Tobacco Co v Harrison, 181 Va 800; 27 SE2d 181 (11 Oct 1943) (trade case)

Richards v Creamer, 267 App Div 928; 46 NYS2d 769 (15 March 1944)

United States Lighterage Corp v Petterson Lighterage & Towing Corp, 142 F2d 197 (CA 2, NY, 26 April 1944). SCB: 45 F Supp 754

Ashcraft v State of Tennessee, 322 US 143; 64 S Ct 921; 88 L Ed 1192 (Tenn, 1 May 1944) (smoker confession-of-crime case)

Richards v Creamer, 267 App Div 1007; 48 NYS2d 685 (3 May 1944). SCB: 267 App Div 928; 46 NYS2d 769

Fossum v George A. Fuller Co, 70 RI 191; 38 A2d 148 (22 June 1944) (worker's compensation case)

Thomas v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 350 Pa 262; 38 A2d 61 (30 June 1944) (copyright infringement case alleging breach of contract, not paying for use of "Camel" advertising suggestion)

Brownhill v Kivlin, 317 Mass 168; 57 NE2d 539 (25 Oct 1944) (issue included smoker having a record of smoking and sleeping in car)

Advance Music Corp v American Tobacco Co, 183 Misc 855; 51 NYS2d 692 (2 Dec 1944) ("prima-facie" tort case).

American Tobacco Co, et al v United States, 147 F2d 93 (CA 6, Ky, 4 Dec 1944). SCB: 39 F Supp 957 (upholding monopoly conviction)

Stewart v Kelly, 68 Cal App 2d 122; 155 P2d 850 (19 Feb 1945)

Advance Music Corp v American Tobacco Co, 268 App Div 707; 53 NYS2d 337 (23 Feb 1945) ("prima-facie" tort case). SCB: 183 Misc 855, 51 NYS2d 692

McLellan v International Paper Co, 269 App Div 800; 55 NYS2d 56 (16 May 1945)

Puffin v General Electric Co, 132 Conn 279; 43 A2d 746 (12 July 1945) (worker compensation case)

McLellan v International Paper Co, 294 NY 967; 63 NE2d 597 (4 Oct 1945). SCB: 269 App Div 800; 55 NYS2d 56

Clayton v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 225 NC 563; 35 SE2d 691 (7 Nov 1945) (zoning issue)

Mack v Branch No. 12, Post Exchange, Fort Jackson, 207 SC 258; 35 SE2d 838 (9 Nov 1945)

R. L. Swain Co, Inc, 41 FTC 312 (28 Nov 1945)

Hannegan, Postm'r Gen'l v Esquire, Inc, 327 US 146; 66 S Ct 456; 90 L Ed 586 (4 Feb 1946) ("smoking-room type of humor")

Tomlinson v Sharpe, 224 NC 177; 37 SE2d 498 (20 March 1946)

Bradford's Case, 319 Mass 621; 67 NE2d 149 (29 May 1946) (worker compensation case)

Kotteakos v U.S, 328 US 750; 66 S Ct 1239; 90 L Ed 1557 (10 June 1946) (c) (issues including crime by cigarette and pinball machine business opeators)

American Tobacco Co v United States, 329 US 781; 66 S Ct 1125; 90 L Ed 1575 (10 June 1946). SCB: 147 F2d 93; 39 F Supp 957 (upholding tobacco company monopoly conviction)

Gruber v LaRusse, 95 Pittsburgh Legal Journal 361 (29 June 1946)

The Nurnberg Trial, 6 FRD 69 (1 Oct 1946) (background)

McLellan v International Paper Co, 271 App Div 857; 66 NYS2d 3 (20 Nov 1946). SCB: 294 NY 967; 63 NE2d 597

Town of Clinton v Ross, 226 NC 682; 40 SE2d 593 (20 Nov 1946)

Advance Music Corp v American Tobacco Co, 70 NYS2d; 296 NY 79; 70 NE2d 401 (21 Nov 1946) ("prima-facie" tort case). SCB: 183 Misc 855, 51 NYS2d 692; 268 App Div 707, 53 NYS2d 337

New York v Railway Express Agency, Inc, 188 Misc 342, 67 NYS2d 732 (21 Jan 1947) (cigarette advertising conviction upheld)

Tinsman Mfg Co v Sparks, 211 Ark 554; 201 SW2d 573 (21 April 1947)

Bauman's Administrator v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 305 Ky 344; 204 SW2d 327 (27 May 1947) (worker killed on job)

Columbian Rope Co v United Farm Equipment and Metal Workers, 7 Lab Arb (BNA) 450 (NY, 2 June 1947) (smoker discharge case)

Baltic Metal Products Co v United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers of America, 8 Lab Arb (BNA) 782 (NY, 5 Nov 1947) (smoker suspended 2 weeks for on-job smoking)

New York v Railway Express Agency, Inc, 297 NY 703; 77 NE2d 13 (20 Nov 1947). SCB: 188 Misc 342, 67 NYS2d 732 (cigarette advertising conviction upheld)

Curtiss-Wright Corp, Airplane Div v Int'l Union, United Automobile, Aircraft and Agricultural Implement Workers of American, 9 Lab Arb (BNA) 77 (Ohio, 29 Nov 1947) (smoker suspended one week for on-job smoking)

George v Bekins Van & Storage Co, 83 Cal App 2d 478; 189 P2d 301 (5 Feb 1948) (fire case; issue of smoking-caused warehouse fire). SCB:

Albany Insurance Co v Holberg, 166 F2d 311 (CA 8, Minn, 1 March 1948)

Com v Farrell, 322 Mass 606; 78 NE2d 697 (12 April 1948) (sadistic burning-by-cigarette case)

United States v Paramount Pictures, 334 US 131; 68 S Ct 915; 92 L Ed 1260 (3 May 1948) (anti-trust case set principles applicable to tobacco companies)

Triangle Conduit & Cable Co v FTC, 168 F2d 175 (CA 7, 12 May 1948) affd sub nom Clayton Mark & Co v FTC, 336 US 956 (1949)

Commonwealth v Abdo, 162 Pa Super 622; 60 A2d 419 (23 July 1948)

George v Bekins Van & Storage Co, 196 P2d 637 (Cal App, 9 Aug 1948). SCB: 83 Cal App 2d 478; 189 P2d 301

Kerr v Hudson Hotel Co, 204 Miss 396; 37 So 2d 630 (22 Nov 1948) (smoking-caused hotel fire case)

Railway Express Agency, Inc v New York, 336 US 106; 69 S Ct 463; 93 L Ed 533 (31 Jan 1949) SCB: 188 Misc 342, 67 NYS2d 732; 297 NY 703, 77 NE2d 13 (cigarette advertising conviction upheld)

Clayton Mark & Co v FTC, 336 US 956 (1949). SCB 168 F2d 175

Beecham v Falstaff Brewing Corp, 150 Neb 792; 36 NW2d 233 (2 Feb 1949) (unemployment comp case)

McKenna v Atlas Contractors Equipment Corp, 275 App Div 876; 88 NYS2d 668 (11 May 1949)

George v Bekins Van & Storage Co, 33 Cal 2d 834; 205 P2d 1037 (13 May 1949) (issue of smoker setting fire to warehouse, though forbidden to smoke on the job). SCB: 189 P2d 301; 196 P2d 637

Commonwealth v Flickinger, 165 Pa Super 95; 67 A2d 779 (15 July 1949) (licensing aspects case)

Gentry v Alexander, 311 Ky 344; 224 SW2d 143 (1 Nov 1949) (tobacco farmer rights case)

McKenna v Atlas Contractors Equipment Corp, 300 NY 317; 90 NE2d 479 (12 Jan 1950). SCB: 275 App Div 876; 88 NYS2d 668

Waskevitz v Clifton Paper Board Co, 7 NJ Super 1; 71 A2d 646 (1 March 1950) (worker's compensation job smoking case)

Matter of P. Lorillard Tobacco Co, 46 FTC 706 (13 March 1950)

140 Riverside Drive v Murdock, 276 App Div 550; 95 NYS2d 860 (28 March 1950) (zoning ordinance ban case)

Matter of R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 46 FTC 735 (31 March 1950)

Commonwealth v Flickinger, 365 Pa 59; 73 A2d 652 (22 May 1950). SCB: 165 Pa Super 95; 67 A2d 779

Matter of P. Lorillard Tobacco Co, 46 FTC 853 (24 May 1950)

Wise v Coleman, 360 Mo 829; 230 SW2d 870 (13 June 1950)

Flickinger v Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, 340 US 843; 71 S Ct 33; 95 L Ed 618 (9 Oct 1950). SCB: 365 Pa 59; 73 A2d 652

Bluestein v Scoparino, 277 App Div 534; 100 NYS 2d 577 (21 Nov 1950) (issue of smoker setting fire to factory, though forbidden to smoke on the job)

McCoy v Easley Cotton Mills, 218 SC 353; 62 SE2d 772 (15 Dec 1950)

P. Lorillard Co v Federal Trade Commission, 186 F2d 52 (CA 4, 29 Dec 1950)

Electric Storage Battery Co v United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers of America, 16 Lab Arb (BNA) 118 (Ind, 10 Jan 1951) (smoker discipline case)

Robert R. Walker, Inc v Kenosha Auto Transport Co, 239 SW2d 174 (Tex Civ App, 5 April 1951)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Federal Trade Commission, 192 F2d 535 (CA 7, 1 Nov 1951)

Robert R. Walker, Inc v Burgdorf, 150 Tex 603; 244 SW2d 506 (5 Dec 1951)

Matter of R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 48 FTC 682 (17 Jan 1952)

Hill-Luthy Co v Industrial Commission, 411 Ill 201; 103 NE 2d 605 (24 Jan 1952) (employee smoking case)

New Zealand Insurance Co v Brown, 110 Cal App 2d 411; 242 P2d 674 (18 April 1952) (issue of smoker death re smoking in bed)

In Re Texas City Disaster Litigation, 197 F2d 771 (CA 5, Tex, 10 June 1952)

DeMirjian v Ideal Heating Corp, 112 Cal App 2d 251; 246 P2d 51 (17 July 1952)

United States v Martin, 1 USCMA 674; 5 CMR 102 (Navy, 10 Sep 1952) (court martial smoking case)

Federal Trade Commission v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 108 F Supp 573 (D SD NY, 1 Dec 1952)

Standard Oil Co v Central States Petroleum Union, 19 Lab Arb (BNA) 795 (Ill, 13 Dec 1952) (smoker discharge case)

Philip Morris & Co, Ltd, Inc, 49 FTC 703 (29 Dec 1952)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v U.S., 201 F2d 819 (CA 6, Ky, 11 Feb 1953) (suit to recover excessive profits, defenses allowed)

United States v Assey, 9 CMR 732 (Air Force, 7 April 1953) (court martial smoking case)

Federal Trade Commission v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 203 F2d 955 (CA 2, NY, 4 May 1953). SCB: 108 F Supp 573

State v 483 Cases, 98 NH 180; 96 A2d 568 (5 May 1953)

General Drivers, Warehousemen, & Helpers, Local Union No. 89 v American Tobacco Co, 264 SW2d 250 (Ky, 2 June 1953 mod 5 Feb 1954) (labor relations case)

Dalehite v United States, 346 US 15; 73 S Ct 956; 97 L Ed 1427 (8 June 1953). SCB: 197 F2d 771

United States v Barnes, 12 CMR 735 (Air Force, 10 Sep 1953) (court martial smoking case)

Dworkin, Sec'y of Labor v J. T. Budd & Co, King Edward Tobacco Co, et al, 114 F Supp 865 (ND Fla, 29 Sep 1953) (tobacco mfg employees pay case)

People v Asta, 337 Mich 590; 60 NW2d 472 (5 Oct 1953) (licensing aspects case)

United States v Barnes, 12 CMR 204 (Air Force, 27 Nov 1953). SCB: 12 CMR 735

Fireman's Fund Insurance Co v Romero, 128 Cal App 2d 331; 275 P2d 83 (25 Oct 1954)

Eacurco v Haddad, 3 Ill App 2d 480; 122 NE 2d 605 (19 Nov 1954) (landlord tenant case, when tenant sprayed gasoline, then lit cigar, fire resulted, causing damage)

Olds v Wood, 196 Va 960; 86 SE2d 32 (7 March 1955)

Secor v Penn Service Garage, 35 NJ Super 59; 113 A2d 177 (1 April 1955) (worker compensation case, employee smoked around gasoline)

General Drivers, Warehousemen, & Helpers, Local Union No. 89 v American Tobacco Co, 348 US 978; 75 S Ct 569; 99 L Ed 762 (4 April 1955). SCB: 264 SW2d 250 (labor relations case)

People v Locricchio, 342 Mich 210; 69 NW2d 723 (14 April 1955) (licensing aspects case)

J. T. Budd & Co, King Edward Tobacco Co, et al v Mitchell, Sec'y of Labor, 221 F2d 406 (CA 5, Fla, 15 April 1955) (tobacco mfg employees pay case). SCB: 114 F Supp 865

Natco Corp v Mallory, 262 Ala 595; 80 So 2d 274 (28 April 1955)

Pritchard v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 134 F Supp 829 (D WD Pa, 2 Aug 1955)

Secor v Penn Service Garage, 19 NJ 315; 117 A2d 12 (27 Sep 1955). SCB: 35 NJ Super 59; 113 A2d 177 (fire case and worker compensation case, employee smoked around gasoline)

U.S. v Cigarette Merchandisers Assn, 18 FRD 497 (SD NY, 27 Oct 1955) (civil anti-trust case)

U.S. v Cigarette Merchandisers Assn, 136 F Supp 214 (SD NY, 23 Nov 1955) (criminal anti-trust case)

Wiseman v Industrial Accident Commission, 291 P2d 180 (Cal App, 14 Dec 1955)

De Mirjian v Ideal Heating Corp, 129 Cal App 2d 758; 278 P2d 114 (23 Dec 1955). SCB: 112 Cal App 2d 251; 246 P2d 51 (employee smoking on the job causing damages)

Mitchell, Sec'y of Labor v J. T. Budd & Co, King Edward Tobacco Co, et al, 350 US 473; 76 S Ct 527; 100 L Ed 565 (Fla, 26 March 1956) (tobacco mfg employees pay case) SCB: 114 F Supp 865; 221 F2d 406

U.S. v Bohannon Co, 232 F2d 756 (CA 6, Ky, 2 May 1956) (fire-destroyed tobacco)

Cooper v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 234 F2d 170 (CA 1, Mass, 24 May 1956) (product liability case)

People v Merkouris, 46 Cal.2d 540; 297 P2d 999 (25 May 1956) (crime situation; murderer hid gun in cigarette case)

Wiseman v Industrial Accident Commission, 46 Cal 2d 570; 297 P2d 649 (29 May 1956). SCB: 291 P2d 180

Pfeiffer v State, 226 Ark 825; 295 SW2d 365 (22 Oct 1956) (licensing aspects case)

Olin Mathieson Chemical Corp v Int'l Ass'n of Machinists, 28 Lab Arb (BNA) 29 (Conn, 4 Dec 1956)

United States v Borries, 23 CMR 667 (11 Feb 1957)

Crotty v Driver Harris Co, 45 NJ Super 75; 131 A2d 578 (22 April 1957) (worker compensation job smoking case)

Neeld v Giroux, 24 NJ 224; 131 A2d 508 (6 May 1957) (licensing aspects case)

United States v Borries, 23 CMR 421 (28 June 1957). SCB: 23 CMR 667

Petrie v Crucible Steel Co of America, 4 App Div 2d 905; 166 NYS2d 780 (19 Oct 1957) (worker's compensation case)

Petrie v Crucible Steel Co of America, 167 NYS 2d 1020 (20 Nov 1957). SCB: 4 App Div 2d 905; 166 NYS2d 780

Cooper v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 158 F Supp 22 (D Mass, 26 Dec 1957). Prior Decision: 234 F2d 170

Crotty v Driver Harris Co, 49 NJ Super 60; 139 A2d 126 (17 Feb 1958). SCB: 45 NJ Super 75; 131 A2d 578

Cit-Con Oil Corp v Oil, Chemical & Allied Workers International Union, 30 Lab Arb (BNA) 252 (La, 26 Feb 1958) (smoker discharge case)

United States v McMahan, 25 CMR 631 (Army, 24 March 1958)

Ross v Philip Morris & Co, 164 F Supp 693 (D WD Mo, 24 April 1958)

Cooper v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 256 F2d 464 (CA 1, Mass, 12 June 1958). SCB: 158 F Supp 22

Crooker v California, 357 US 433; 78 S Ct 1287; 2 L Ed 2d 1448 (30 June 1958) (another smoker murder case, murder of his paramour on her leaving him). SCB: 47 Cal 2d 348; 303 P2d 753

United States v Chasles, 9 USCMA 424; 26 CMR 204 (Air Force, 3 July 1958)

United States v Dozier, 9 USCMA 443; 26 CMR 223 (Army, 11 July 1958)

Matter of Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 55 FTC 354 (17 Sep 1958)

United States v McMahan, 27 CMR 512 (Army, 2 Oct 1958). SCB: 25 CMR 631

Cooper v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 358 US 875; 79 S Ct 112; 3 L Ed 2d 105 (27 Oct 1958). SCB: 158 F Supp 22; 256 F2d 464

Ferguson v Philip Morris, Inc, 176 Cal App 2d 605; 1 Cal Rptr 591 (23 Jan 1959) (sign injury)

Tobin v W. T. Grant Co, 17 Misc 2d 517; 191 NYS 2d 540 (23 Jan 1959) (worker's compensation case)

Gold-Tex Fabrics Corp, Mill Div v Textile Workers Union of America, Local 925, 32 Lab Arb (BNA) 103 (SC, 24 Jan 1959) (smoker suspended one month for smoking-on-job)

Petition of the Republic of France, 171 F Supp 497 (D SD Tex, 9 March 1959) (ship fire due to sailors smoking around flammable materials)

Padovani v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 23 FRD 255 (D ED NY, 17 April 1959)

Tobin v W. T. Grant Co, 8 App Div 2d 723; 187 NYS2d 989 (4 May 1959). SCB: 17 Misc 2d 517; 191 NYS 2d 540

United States v Martin, 28 CMR 822 (Air Force, 15 Sep 1959)

People v Merkouris, 52 Cal 2d 672; 344 P2d 1 (16 Sep 1959). SCB: 46 Cal.2d 540; 297 P2d 999, supra

Tobin v W. T. Grant Co, 9 App Div 2d 691; 191 NYS2d 1010 (19 Oct 1959). SCB: 8 App Div 2d 723; 187 NYS2d 989

Opinion of Attorney General of Kentucky, No 60-695, 1 UCCRS 679 (18 July 1960) (crop location issue)

Tierney v State, 223 Md 454; 164 A2d 916 (11 Nov 1960) (cigarette machine theft case)

Matter of Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 56 FTC 956 (24 Feb 1960)

Mitchell v American Tobacco Co, 183 F Supp 406 (D MD Pa, 27 April 1960)

Delaware Valley Marine Supply Co v American Tobacco Co, 184 F Supp 440 (ED Pa, 9 June 1960) (local store vs. manufacturer alleging conspiracy in restraint of trade)

Pressley v City of Chicago, 26 Ill App 2d 283; 168 NE2d 41 (14 June 1960)

Konieczka v Mt. Clemens Metal Products Co 360 Mich 500; 104 NW2d 202 (11July 1960)

Arthur v Santa Monica Dairy Co, 183 Cal App 2d 483; 6 Cal Rptr 808 (3 Aug 1960)

Hussey, et al v Campbell, Comm'r of Agriculture of Georgia, et al, 189 F Supp 54 (D SD Ga, 9 Nov 1960) (business practices case, issue of Federal Tobacco Inspection Act labeling clause pre-empting Georgia's)

Delaware Valley Marine Supply Co v American Tobacco Co, 199 F Supp 560 (ED Pa, 16 Nov 1960). SCB: 184 F Supp 440

Times Film Corp v Chicago, 365 US 43; 81 S Ct 391; 5 L Ed 2d 403 (23 Jan 1961) (movie censorship case noting that "An early version of Carmen was condemned on several different grounds. The Ohio censor objected because cigarette-girls smoked cigarettes in public.")

Padovani v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 27 FRD 37 (D ED NY, 7 Feb 1961)

Butcher Boy Refrigerator Door Co v NLRB, 290 F2d 22 (CA 7, Ill, 27 April 1961)

Petition of Republic of France v United States, 290 F2d 395 (CA 5, Tex, 5 May 1961). SCB: 171 F Supp 497

Mitchell v American Tobacco Co, 33 FRD 262 (D MD Pa, 19 July 1961). Prior Decision: 183 F Supp 406

Padovani v Bruchhausen, 293 F2d 546 (CA 2, NY, 31 July 1961). SCB: 27 FRD 37

Mitchell v American Tobacco Co, 28 FRD 315 (D MD Pa, 12 Oct 1961)

Pritchard v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 295 F2d 292; 22 NCCA3d 421 (CA 3, Pa, 12 Oct 1961). SCB: 134 F Supp 829 (danger to lungs case, the lung cancer danger was known decades before, case gives medical history overview)

Delaware Valley Marine Supply Co v American Tobacco Co, 297 F2d 199 (CA 3, 8 Dec 1961). SCB: 184 F Supp 440; 199 F Supp 560

Trial of Adolf Eichmann (Israel, 11 Dec 1961) (smoker crime case, part of leader's pattern)

Campbell, Comm'r of Agriculture of Georgia, et al v Hussey, et al, 368 US 297; 82 S Ct 327; 7 L Ed 2d 299 (18 Dec 1961). SCB: 189 F Supp 54 (business practices case, Federal Tobacco Inspection Act labeling clause pre-empts Georgia's)

Neil v State, 227 Md 298; 176 A2d 338 (26 Dec 1961) (cigarette machine theft case)

Thomas v Williams, 105 Ga App 321; 124 SE2d 409 (15 Feb 1962) (jailed drunk smoker fire death)

Campbell v Hussey, 368 US 1005; 82 S Ct 596; 7 L Ed 2d 547 (19 Feb 1962). SCB: 189 F Supp 54 (reh den)

United States v Republic of France, 369 US 804; 82 S Ct 644; 7 L Ed 2d 550 (26 Feb 1962). SCB: 171 F Supp 497, 290 F2d 395

Green v American Tobacco Co, 304 F2d 70 (CA 5, Fla, 2 May 1962) (product liability case)

Robinson v California, 370 US 660; 82 S Ct 1417; 8 L Ed 2d 758 (25 June 1962) (jailing sick people, e.g., drug addicts, violates the the 8th Amendment ban on cruel and unusual punishment; we know that "[t]he first step toward addiction may be as innocent as a boy's puff on a cigarette in an alleyway " so the better approach is to ban the gateway drug, as per the Tennessee and Michigan examples, hence prevent drug use as it is a problem disproportionately among smokers. The now rampant disregard of this constitutional principle is due to rampant bribery of legislators and judges.)

Maryland v Giles, 229 Md 370; 183 A2d 359 (18 July 1962) (rape-by-smokers case, had "demanded money and cigarettes")

United States v Harris, 32 CMR 878 (Air Force, 15 Oct 1962)

Amoroso v Tubular & Cast Products Mfg Co, 17 App Div 2d 1003; 233 NYS2d 909 (21 Nov 1962)

United States v Harris, 32 CMR 472 (Air Force, 15 Jan 1963). SCB: 32 CMR 878

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Hudson, 314 F2d 776 (CA 5, La, 14 March 1963) (product liability case)

Kentucky Tax Commission v American Tobacco Co, 370 SW2d 590 (Ky App, 19 April 1963) (tax case)

Lartique v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 317 F2d 19 (CA 5, La, 19 April 1963) (dangerous tobacco case)

Giles v Maryland, 372 US 767; 83 S Ct 1102; 10 L Ed 2d 137 (22 April 1963) SCB: 229 Md 370; 183 A2d 359 (rape-by-smokers case)

Giles v Maryland, 231 Md 387; 190 A2d 627 (6 May 1963) (rape-by-smokers case)

Green v American Tobacco Co, 154 So 2d 169 (Fla, 5 June 1963). SCB: 304 F2d 70 (strong duty concerning smokers re tobacco dangerousness)

Meredith v Ringling Bros Barnum & Bailey Combined Shows, Inc, 321 F2d 107 (CA 6, Ohio, 31 July 1963) (issue of smoking-caused circus fire)

State v Gallegos, 384 P2d 967 (Wyoming, 9 Sep 1963) (offering cigarette to minor could be criminal violation of health, welfare and morals of a minor)

Lartique v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 375 US 865; 84 S Ct 137; 11 L Ed 2d 92 (14 Oct 1963). SCB: 317 F2d 19

Amoroso v Tubular & Cast Products Mfg Co, 13 NY2d 992; 244 NYS2d 787; 194 NE2d 694 (21 Nov 1963). SCB: 17 App Div 2d 1003; 233 NYS2d 909

Green v American Tobacco Co, 325 F2d 673 (CA 5, Fla, 11 Dec 1963). SCB: 154 So 2d 169; 304 F2d 70

Clarke v Coats & Clarke, Inc, 97 RI 163; 196 A2d 423 (10 Jan 1964) (worker compensation employee smoking case)

Ross v Philip Morris & Co, 328 F2d 3 (CA 8, Mo, 26 Feb 1964)

U.S. Industrial Chemical Co v International Union of Operating Engineers, 64-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8481 (Ill, 5 March 1964) (smoker discharge case)

Haskell Mfg Co, Inc v Int'l Union of Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers, 64-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8647 (Pa, 13 May 1964) (smoker suspended thirty days for smoking-on-job)

American Tobacco Co v Green, 377 US 943; 84 S Ct 1349; 12 L Ed 2d 306 (25 May 1964). SCB: 325 F2d 673

Merritt v United States, 332 F2d 397 (CA 1, Massachusetts, 1 June 1964) (military sergeant renting private home, caused fire, smoking in bed)

Caraco Ship Supply v Amalgamated Meat Cutters and Butcher Workmen of North America, 64-3 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8961 (Calif, 12 Aug 1964) (smoker discharge case)

Fine v Philip Morris, Inc, 239 F Supp 361 (D SD NY, 26 Oct 1964) (issue of multiple causes of action arising from tobacco smoke harm)

Sellars v State, 237 Md 58; 205 A2d 296 (7 Dec 1964) (stolen cigarettes)

John Strange Paper Co v Int'l Bro of Pulp, Sulphite and Paper Mill Workers, 65-1 ARB (CCH) § 8075 (Wisc, 2 Feb 1965)

House of Tobacco, Inc v Calvert, 387 SW2d 74 (Tex Civ App, 10 Feb 1965)

People v Portelli, 15 NY2d 235; 205 NE2d 857; 257 NYS2d 931 (11 March 1965) (a case wherein according to the Miranda decision, "the police brutally beat, kicked and placed lighted cigarette butts on the back of a potential witness under interrogation for the purpose of securing a statement incriminating a third party," an example helping lead to the famous Miranda decision requiring police to tell suspects their rights, one of the incidents wherein cigarette factors impact American law concepts)

Columbus Show Case Co v Sheetmetal Workers Int'l Ass'n, 65-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8347; 44 Lab Arb (BNA) 507 (Ohio, 7 April 1965) (smoker suspended two months for smoking-on-job)

Cucuzzella v Bilinski, 58 Del 414; 210 A2d 297 (6 May 1965)

State v Footlick, 2 Ohio St 2d 206; 31 Ohio Ops 2d 411; 207 NE2d 759 (2 June 1965) (illegal sale case, merchandise including tobacco)

Dobson v Don January Roofing Co, 392 SW2d 153; 20 ALR3d 887 (Tex Civ App, 3 June 1965)

Giles v Maryland, 239 Md 458; 212 A2d 101 (13 July 1965) (rape-by-smokers case)

Pritchard v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 350 F2d 479 (CA 3, Pa, 26 July 1965)

House of Tobacco, Inc v Calvert, 394 SW2d 654 (Tex, 6 Oct 1965). SCB: 387 SW2d 74

Dobson v Don January Roofing Co, 394 SW2d 790 (Tex, 13 Oct 1965). SCB: 392 SW2d 153

Granger v Deaconess Hospital of Grand Forks, 138 NW2d 443 (ND, 23 Nov 1965) (fire case; smoking in hospital oxygen tent, smoker sued hospital for letting her smoke there, when severe injury resulted)

Aldridge v Saxey, 242 Or 238; 409 P2d 184 (22 Dec 1965) ("it cannot be said that" a smoker "is a person of normal sensibilities")

Welby Division of Elgin Nat'l Watch Co v United Packinghouse, Food and Allied Workers, 66-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8105 (Ill, 30 Dec 1965) (smoker suspended 30 days for smoking-on-job)

N. Tilli & Sons, Inc v Commonwealth, 420 Pa 28; 215 A2d 653 (4 Jan 1966)

State v Aspell, 5 Ohio App 2d 44; 34 Ohio Ops 2d 131; 213 NE2d 748 (14 Jan 1966) (cigarette machine theft case)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v Pritchard, 382 US 987; 86 S Ct 549; 15 L Ed 2d 475 (17 Jan 1966). SCB: 350 F2d 479

U.S. Rubber Co, Ball Band Plant v Int'l Bro of Teamsters, Chauffeurs, Warehousemen and Helpers of America, 66-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8239 (18 Jan 1966)

State v Aspell, 5 Ohio App 2d 230; 34 Ohio Ops 2d 371; 214 NE2d 834 (1 March 1966). SCB: 5 Ohio App 2d 44; 34 Ohio Ops 2d 131; 213 NE2d 748 (cigarette machine theft case)

Pate v Robinson, 383 US 375; 86 S Ct 836; 15 L Ed 2d 815 (7 March 1966) SCB: 22 Ill 2d 162, 174 NE2d 820; 368 U.S. 995; 345 F2d 691 (brain-damaged suicidal smoker murder case)

Bouillier v Samsan Co, 100 RI 676; 219 A2d 133 (25 April 1966) (employee violating employer rule smoked on the job, injured self, filed workers' compensation claim)

Miranda v Arizona, 384 US 436; 86 S Ct 602; 16 L Ed 2d 694 (13 June 1966) (the famous case ordering police to read suspects their rights, citing as one example of police abuses, the 1965 Portelli case wherein "the police brutally beat, kicked and placed lighted cigarette butts on the back of a potential witness under interrogation for the purpose of securing a statement incriminating a third party")

Hirst v Gardner, Secretary, HEW, 365 F2d 125 (CA 7, Ind, 21 July 1966) (smoker Social Security disability case)

McGee v Adams Paper & Twine Co, 26 App Div 2d 186; 271 NYS2d 698 (7 July 1966) (smoking-caused building fire and death and widow's compensation claim)

Decar Plastic Corp v Int'l Ass'n of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, 66-3 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8810 (Wisc, 26 Aug 1966)

Epstein dba Stratford International Tobacco Co v Lordi, 261 F Supp 921 (D NJ, 14 Dec 1966) (licensing case)

Pritchard v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co, 370 F2d 95 (CA 3, Pa, 22 Dec 1966). SCB: 350 F2d 479; 382 US 987; 86 S Ct 549; 15 L Ed 2d 475

McGee v Adams Paper & Twine Co, 19 NY2d 673; 278 NYS2d 864; 225 NE2d 555 (16 Feb 1967). SCB: 26 App Div 2d 186; 271 NYS2d 698

Giles v Maryland, 386 US 66; 87 S Ct 793; 17 L Ed 2d 737 (20 Feb 1967) (c) SCB: 239 Md 458, 212 A2d 101; 231 Md 387, 190 A2d 627; 372 US 767, 83 S Ct 1102, 10 L Ed 2d 137; 229 Md 370, 183 A2d 359 (rape-by-smokers case)

State v Hunt, 198 Kansas 222; 424 P2d 571 (4 March 1967) (stolen cigarettes)

State v Aspell, 10 Ohio St 2d 1; 39 Ohio Ops 2d 1; 225 NE2d 226 (29 March 1967). SCB: 5 Ohio App 2d 44, 34 Ohio Ops 2d 131, 213 NE2d 748; 5 Ohio App 2d 230, 34 Ohio Ops 2d 371, 214 NE2d 834 (cigarette machine theft case)

Quarles v Philip Morris, 271 F Supp 842 (ED VA, Richmond, 11 April 1967) (civil rights violations case)

Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co v Pritchard, 386 US 1009; 87 S Ct 1350; 18 L Ed 2d 436 (17 April 1967). SCB: 370 F2d 95

American Tobacco Co v Sallee, 419 SW2d 160 (Ky App, 5 May 1967) (worker compensation case)

In re Complaint Concerning Fairness Doctrine Directed to Station WCBS-TV, New York, N.Y., 8 FCC2d 381 (2 June 1967) (request for equal time to answer cigarette ads)

Henry v Gardner, Secretary, HEW, 381 F2d 191 (CA 6, Tenn, 19 July 1967) (smoker Social Security disability case)

U.S. Powder Co, Division of Commercial Solvents Corp v International Union of District 50, United Mine Workers of America, 67-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8454 (Ill, 26 July 1967) (smoker discharge case)

Wirta v Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District, 61 Cal Rptr 430 (11 Aug 1967)

The Columbus Showcase Co v Sheet Metal Workers Int'l Ass'n, 67-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8577 (Ohio, 23 Aug 1967) (smoker suspended five weeks for smoking-on-job)

In re Matter of Television Station WCBS-TV, New York, NY, Applicability of the Fairness Doctrine to Cigarette Advertising, 9 FCC2d 921 (8 Sep 1967)

Lordi v Epstein dba Stratford International Tobacco Co, 389 US 29; 88 S Ct 106; 19 L Ed 2d 29 (NJ, 16 Oct 1967). SCB: 261 F Supp 921

McGee v Adams Paper & Twine Co, 20 NY2d 921; 286 NYS2d 274; 233 NE2d 289 (29 Nov 1967). SCB: 26 App Div 2d 186; 271 NYS2d 698; 19 NY2d 673; 278 NYS2d 864; 225 NE2d 555

The Pantasote Co v United Rubber, Cork, Linoleum and Plastic Workers of America, 68-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8136 (W Va, 4 Dec 1967) (smoker suspended two months for on-job smoking)

Virginia Surety Co v Schlegel, 200 Kan 64; 434 P2d 772 (9 Dec 1967) (damages from smoking caused fire)

Weather-Proof Co v Int'l Ass'n of Machinists, Local Union 878, 50 Lab Arb (BNA) 199 (Ill, 11 Dec 1967)

Wirta v Alameda-Contra Costa Transit District, 68 Cal 2d 51; 64 Cal Rptr 430; 434 P2d 982 (21 Dec 1967). SCB: 61 Cal Rep 419 (striking down a law with the effect of allowing pro-cigarette but not anti-cigarette advertising)

Quarles v Philip Morris, 279 F Supp 505 (ED Va, Richmond, 4 Jan 1968) (civil rights violations case). SCB: 271 F Supp 842

Green v American Tobacco Co, 391 F2d 97 (CA 5, Fla, 24 Jan 1968). SCB: 304 F2d 70; 154 So 2d 169; 325 F2d 673

United Fuel Gas Co v Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers Intl Union, 68-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8450 (W Va, 18 March 1968) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Ward Furniture Mfg Co v United Furniture Workers of America, 68-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8702 (Ark, 24 May 1968) (smoker discharge case)

State v Giles, 183 Neb 296; 159 NW2d 826 (21 June 1968) (criminal assault case due to bodily injury to child caused by lighted cigarette)

Olin Mathieson Chemical Corp, Indiana Army Ammunition Plant v Int'l Chemical Workers Union, 68-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8630; 51 Lab Arb (BNA) 97 (3 July 1968) (smoker suspended eleven months for smoking-on-job)

U.S. ex rel Chiarello v Mancusi, 288 F Supp 178 (SD NY, 21 Aug 1968) (cigarette machine theft case)

McAlister v Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board, 69 Cal 408; 71 Cal Rptr 697; 445 P2d 313 (4 Oct 1968) (worker compensation case)

Banzhaf v Federal Communications Commission, 132 US App DC 14; 405 F2d 1082; 78 P.U.R.3d 87, 1 Media L. Rep. 2037 (21 Nov 1968). SCB: 9 FCC2d 921 (equal time issue re cigarette advertising; citing cigarette dangerousness)

People v Richard Speck, 41 Ill 2d 177; 242 NE2d 208 (22 Nov 1968) (mentally ill killer of eight women)

Hurley Pickett Lake Farms, Inc v Sullivan and Jones, 245 Ark 709; 434 SW2d 88 (25 Nov 1968)

State v Sedacca, 252 Md 207; 249 A2d 456 (21 Jan 1969) (licensing aspects case)

Russell v U.S., 133 App DC 77; 408 F2d 1280 (24 Jan 1969) (cigarette machine theft case)

Minamayer Corp v Paper Mill Suppliers, Inc, 297 F Supp 524 (D Pa, 14 Feb 1969)

Guss v Jack Tar Management Co, 407 F2d 859 (CA 5, Louisiana, 25 Feb 1969) (issue of hotel guest setting fire to mattress, dying in resultant fire)

Cornish v State, 6 Md App 167; 251 A2d 23 (4 March 1969) (licensing aspects case)

In the Matter of Petition to Revoke the License of NBC, Inc, for Station WNBC-TV, New York, NY, 16 FCC2d 947 (19 March 1969)

Green v American Tobacco Co, 409 F2d 1166 (CA 5, Fla, 8 April 1969). SCB: 304 F2d 70; 154 So 2d 169; 325 F2d 673; 391 F2d 70

Russell v U.S., 395 US 928; 89 S Ct 1786; 23 L Ed 2d 245 (26 May 1969). SCB: 133 App DC 77; 408 F2d 1280 (24 Jan 1969) (cigarette machine theft case)

Bucci v R. J. Peynolds Tobacco Co, 57 Del Co 122 (Pa Com Pl, 7 Aug 1969) (employee case)

Royce Chemical Co v Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers International Union, 70-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8138 (NJ, 10 Oct 1969) (smoker discharge case)

Tobacco Institute, Inc, National Association of Broadcasters, and American Broadcasting Co v Federal Communications Commission, 396 US 842; 90 S Ct 50; 24 L Ed 2d 93 (13 Oct 1969). SCB: 132 US App DC 14; 405 F2d 1082 (upholding the equal time rule, applying it to tobacco, allowing rebuttals of its claims)

National Broadcasting Co v Federal Communications Commission, 396 US 842; 90 S Ct 51; 24 L Ed 2d 93 (13 Oct 1969). SCB: 132 US App DC 14; 405 F2d 1082 (upholding the equal time rule, applying it to tobacco, allowing rebuttals of its claims)

Duke Laboratories v International Union, United Mine Workers of America, 70-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8382 (Conn, 20 Jan 1970)

U.S. Plywood-Champion Papers, Inc, Del-Mar Industries Division v International Woodworkers of Am, 70-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8340 (Georgia, 22 Jan 1970) (smoker discharge case)

Green v American Tobacco Co, 397 US 911; 90 S Ct 912; 25 L Ed 2d 93 (24 Feb 1970). SCB: 304 F2d 70; 154 So 2d 169; 325 F2d 673; 391 F2d 70, 409 F2d 1166

Parker v City School Superintendent, 451 SW2d 10 (Mo, 9 March 1970)

Robinson v Lorillard Corp, 319 F Supp 835 (D MD NC, 12 March 1970) (employee discrimination case)

United States v Big Z Warehouse, (DC Ga, 3 April 1970) (identification issue)

Robinson v American Broadcasting Cos, 328 F Supp 421 (D ED Ky, 1 June 1970) (freedom of speech case, resisting tobacco lobby censorship effort)

Hudson v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 427 F2d 541 (CA 5, La, 3 June 1970) (product liability case)

Bucci v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 439 Pa 302; 268 A2d 88 (13 July 1970). SCB: 57 Del Co 122

Programmer v Bank, Decision 71-109, CCH EEOC Decisions § 6165 (29 July 1970)

Levan v Philip Morris Tobacco Co, 459 SW2d 73 (Ky App, 16 Oct 1970) (worker compensation case)

Tritt v Richardson, Secretary, HEW, 320 F Supp 871 (D W Va, 30 Oct 1970) (smoker Social Security disability case)

Bolger v Chris Anderson Roofing Co, 112 NJ Super 383; 271 A2d 451 (23 Nov 1970)

Evans v Newark-Wayne Community Hospital, Inc, 35 App Div 2d 1071; 316 NYS2d 447 (10 Dec 1970)

State v Shore, 10 NC App 75; 178 SE2d 22 (16 Dec 1970) (cigarette machine theft case)

O'Connor v Bd of Educ'n, 65 Misc 2d 40; 316 NYS2d 799 (18 Dec 1970) (school smoking-drinking ban)

State of New Jersey v Gillman, 119 NJ Super 302; 273 A2d 617; 46 ALR3d 1337 (9 Feb 1971) (licensing aspects case)

A. E. Staley Mfg Co v International Union, Allied Industrial Workers of Am, 71-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8203 (Ill, 27 Feb 1971) (smoker discharge case)

State v Shore, 278 NC 105; 179 SE2d 453 (3 March 1971). SCB: 10 NC App 75; 178 SE2d 22 (cigarette machine theft case)

Nader v Federal Aviation Administration, 142 US App DC 264; 440 F2d 292 (4 March 1971) (smoke-free flights case)

Calvert v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 465 SW2d 75 (Ky, 19 March 1971) (business case, resisting worker compensation claim)

Robinson v American Broadcasting Cos, 441 F2d 1396 (CA 6, Ky, 30 April 1971). SCB: 328 F Supp 421 (tobacco taboo case, affirming freedom of speech decision, resisting tobacco lobby censorship effort)

Board of Education of Carroll County v Carroll County Teachers Association, 71-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8400 (Md, 16 June 1971)

Lemon v Kurtzman, 403 US 602; 91 S Ct 2105, 2125, 2135; 29 L Ed 2d 745 (28 June 1971) (c) (Pennsylvania school subsidy from cigarette tax)

Speck v Illinois, 403 US 946; 91 S Ct 2279; 29 L Ed 2d 855 (28 June 1971). SCB: 41 Ill 2d 177; 242 NE2d 208 (smoker criminal)

Robinson v Lorillard Corp, 444 F2d 791 (CA 4, NC, 1 July 1971). SCB: 319 F Supp 835

Stauffer v Bank of America, No. 68 ANA 23916, 36 Cal Comp Cases 732 (WC Refereee, 3 Aug 1971)

Larus & Brother Co v Federal Communications Commission, 447 F2d 876 (CA 4, 20 Aug 1971) (cigarette hazards are well-established so no controversy exists re them)

Tonasket v State, 79 Wash 2d 607; 488 P2d 281 (2 Sep 1971) (licensing aspects case)

Stauffer v Bank of America, No. 68 ANA 23916, 36 Cal Comp Cases 732 (WCAB, 14 Oct 1971)

Capital Broadcasting Co v Mitchell, US Attorney General, 333 F Supp 582 (DDC, 14 Oct 1971)

McCrary v Philip Morris, Inc, 472 SW2d 882 (Ky App, 5 Nov 1971) (worker compensation case)

Stauffer v Workmens Compensation Appeals Board, Civil No. 11834 (Ct App, 6 Dec 1971). SCB: 36 Cal Comp Cases 732

Bolger v Chris Anderson Roofing Co, 112 NJ Super 497; 285 A2d 228 (27 Dec 1971). SCB: 112 NJ Super 383; 271 A2d 451

Federal Trade Commission v Sperry & Hutchinson Co, 405 US 233; 92 S Ct 898; 31 L Ed 2d 170 (1 March 1972) (unfair trade practices case, citing FTC criteria used on tobacco)

Capital Broadcasting Co v Kleindienst, US Attorney General, 405 US 1000; 92 S Ct 1289; 31 L Ed 2d 472 (27 March 1972). SCB: 333 F Supp 582

Stauffer v Bank of America, No. 68 ANA 23916, 37 Cal Comp Cases 687 (App Bd, 7 June 1972). SCB: 36 Cal Comp Cases 732

Bailey v American Tobacco Co, 462 F2d 160 (CA 6, Ky, 16 June 1972) (employment discrimination case)

Cooper v Philip Morris, Inc, 464 F2d 9; 20 ALR Fed 957 (CA 6, Ky, 29 June 1972) (employment discrimination case)

Stauffer v Workmen's Compensation Appeal Board, Civil No. 12157, 37 Cal Comp Cases 687 (Ct App, 13 Oct 1972). SCB: 36 Cal Comp Cases 732

Stauffer v Workmen's Compensation Appeal Board, Cal (Sup Ct, 22 Nov 1972). SCB: 37 Cal Comp Cases 687; 36 Cal Comp Cases 732

Albright v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 350 F Supp 341 (D WD Pa, 23 Oct 1972) (product liability case)

Central Merchandise Co v NLRB, 471 F2d 809 (CA 8, Mo, 20 Dec 1972)

Roe v Wade, 410 US 113; 93 S Ct 705; 35 L Ed 2d 147 (Texas, 22 Jan 1973) (the famous abortion decision)

Jim Clay Tobacco Co, Inc, 355 F Supp 274 (D ND Ga, 26 Feb 1973)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v United States, 369 F Supp 1283 (WD Ky, 9 March 1973) (tax case)

Preiser v Rodriguez, 411 US 475; 93 S Ct 1827; 36 L Ed 2d 439 (NY, 7 May 1973). SCB: 456 F2d 79 (issue of specific v general law, in the "cigar-smoking S. O. B." case)

Long Island Tobacco Co, Inc v Linday, Mayor, NYC, 74 Misc 2d 455; 343 NYS2d 759 (9 May 1973)

Columbia Broadcasting v Democratic Comm, 412 US 94; 93 S Ct 2080; 36 L Ed 2d 772 (29 May 1973) (citing ubiquitous nature of broadcast ads, and referencing Banzhaf precedent on cigarette advertising)

Sloan v Lemon, 413 US 825; 93 S Ct 2982; 37 L Ed 2d 939 (25 June 1973) (Pennsylvania school subsidy from cigarette tax)

The Bunting Co, Inc v Upholsterers' Int'l Union of North America, 73-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8503 (21 Sep 1973) (smoker suspended ninety days for on-job smoking)

Long Island Tobacco Co, Inc v Linday, Mayor, NYC, 42 App Div 2d 1056; 348 NYS2d 122 (4 Oct 1973). SCB: 74 Misc 2d 455; 343 NYS2d 759

Albright v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 485 F2d 678 (CA 3, Pa, 25 Oct 1973). SCB: 350 F Supp 341

U.S. v Robinson, 414 US 218; 94 S Ct 467, 494; 38 L Ed 2d 427 (DC, 11 Dec 1973) SCB: 145 US App DC 46; 447 F2d 1215 (search and seizure case, finding heroin in cigarette package)

Albright v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 463 F Supp 1220 (D WD Pa, 22 Jan 1974)

National Ass'n of Motor Bus Owners v United States, 370 F Supp 408 (D DC, 31 Jan 1974) (company opposition to obeying the right to pure air, to protect nonsmokers from second hand TTS)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v United States, 491 F2d 1258 (CA 6, Ky, 28 Feb 1974). SCB: 369 F Supp 1283

Consolidated Cigar Corp v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 491 F2d 1265 (Court of Customs and Patent Appeals, 28 Feb 1974)

Albright v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 416 US 951; 94 S Ct 961; 40 L Ed 2d 301 (15 April 1974). SCB: 350 F Supp 341; 485 F2d 678

People v Cook, 34 NY2d 100; 356 NYS2d 259; 312 NE2d 452 (1 May 1974)

Long Island Tobacco Co, Inc v Linday, Mayor, NYC, 34 NY2d 748; 357 NYS2d 504; 313 NE2d 794 (9 May 1974). SCB: 42 App Div 2d 1056; 348 NYS2d 122

Motschenbacher v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 498 F2d 821 (CA 9, Cal, 6 June 1974)

Lehman v City of Shaker Heights, 418 US 298; 94 S Ct 2714; 41 L Ed 2d 770 (Ohio, 25 June 1974) SCB: 34 Ohio St 2d 143; 296 NE2d 683 (issue of law allowing pro-cigarette advertising but not political candidate advertising)

Hammond v Hitching Post Inn, 523 P2d 482 (Wyoming, 25 June 1974)

In Interest of Helman, 230 Pa Super 484; 327 A2d 163 (23 Sep 1974) (smoking boys set fire to building)

Hercules Inc v International Chemical Workers, 74-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8487 (11 Oct 1974) (smoker discharge case)

Foster v City of Detroit, 56 Mich App 644; 224 NW2d 714 (26 Nov 1974, lv app den 19 Feb 1975)

Riley v Avondale Shipyards, 305 So 2d 742 (La App, 14 Dec 1974) (worker's compensation case)

Buchanan v Allen Hay Motor Co, 21 Or App 90; 553 P2d 824 (1975)

Fuentes v Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board, 40 Cal Comp Cases 40; 44 Cal App 3d 231; 18 Cal Rptr 530 (8 Jan 1975) (worker comp case)

American Public Health Association v Consumer Product Safety Commission, Cons Prod Safety Guide (CCH) § 75,074 (D DC, 1975)

Confederated Salish & Koetena Tribes of Flathead Reservation, Montana v Moe, In and For Missoula County, 392 F Supp 1297 (D Mont, 4 Feb 1975) (licensing aspects case)

Elkind v Liggett & Myers, Inc, 66 FRD 36 (D SD NY, 10 Feb 1975)

Langlais v Superior Plating, Inc, 303 Minn 213; 226 NW2d 891 (28 Feb 1975)

Vernon C. Duncan v U. S. Postal Service, Civ Action No. 75-0091-R (D ED Va, 5 March 1975) (seeking injunction for safe, smoke-free workplace)

Saxer v Philip Morris Inc, 54 Cal App 3d 7; 126 Cal Rptr 327 (23 March 1975) (trade case, allegations of conspiracy, restraint of trade, etc.)

Nelson v Industrial Commission, 24 Arizona App 94; 536 P2d 215 (5 June 1975)

Nelson Schwartz v Los Angeles County United School District, Civ Action No. LA-18711 (8 Oct 1975)

Nardella v Campbell Machine, Inc, 525 F2d 46 (CA 9, Cal, 22 Oct 1975)

O'Leary v Allphin, 35 Ill App 3d 223; 341 NE2d 143 (6 Nov 1975) (licensing aspects case)

People v Richman, 35 Ill App 3d 231; 341 NE2d 149 (6 Nov 1975)

Randol v Newberg Public School Board, 23 Or App 425; 542 P2d 938 (24 Nov 1975) (school smoking ban)

Virginia Stage Lines, Inc v Division 1544, Amalgamated Transit Union, 76-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8116 (Va, 25 Nov 1975)

Nelson Schwartz v Los Angeles County United School District, Civ Action No. 75-9796 (17 Dec 1975)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v Engman, 527 F2d 1115 (CA 2, NY, 22 Dec 1975)

U. S. v Frumento, 409 F Supp 136 (ED Pa, 1976), affd 563 F2d 1083 (CA 3, Pa, 1977) cert den 434 US 1072; 98 S Ct 1256; 55 L Ed 2d 775 cert den 434 US 1072; 98 S Ct 1258; 55 L Ed 2d 776 (State agency charged with responsibility of enforcing tax laws on interstate industry engaged in importing cigarettes from points outside state is an "enterprise" within this chapter; and indictment charged employee of Bureau with acceptance of bribes as part of cigarette-smuggling conspiracy.)

Lila Braun v Social Service (Calif Superior Ct, 2 Jan 1976)

Pons v Lorillard, 69 FRD 576 (D NC, 21 Jan 1976) (age discrimination case, jury trial issue)

U.S. v Watson, 423 US 411; 96 S Ct 820; 46 L Ed 2d 598 (CA 9, 26 Jan 1976) SCB: 504 F2d 849 (cigarette signal of stolen property, with narrative on common law arrest process)

Illinois Fruit & Produce Corp v International Bro of Teamsters, Chauffeurs, Warehousemen and Helpers of America, 66 Lab Arb (BNA) 498 (29 Jan 1976) (smoker discharge case)

Fuentes v Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board, 16 Cal 3d 1; 128 Cal Rptr 673; 547 P2d 449 (2 Feb 1976). SCB: 40 Cal Comp Cases 40; 44 Cal App 3d 231; 18 Cal Rptr 530

Albright v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 531 F2d 132 (CA 3, Pa, 13 Feb 1976). SCB: 463 F Supp 1220

Wisconsin Steel Coal Mines of International Harvester Co v Progressive Mine Workers of America, 76-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8348 (17 April 1976) (smoker discharge case)

Moe v Salish & Kootenai Tribes, 425 US 463; 96 S Ct 1634; 48 L Ed 2d 96 (27 April 1976). SCB: 392 F Supp 1297

Robert Hochman v F. A. Russo, Inc, Unemployment Claim No. 76-32983 (NY St Dep't of Labor, 27 April 1976)

Matter of Melvin Draper, J371536 (Wash, 7 May 1976)

United States v R J Reynolds Tobacco Co, 416 F Supp 313 (D NJ, 11 May 1976) (issue of paying witness fee)

Briggs v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 414 F Supp 371 (D ED Va, 19 May 1976)

Patterson v American Tobacco Co, 535 F2d 257 (CA 4, Va, 23 May 1976)

Albright v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 426 US 907; 96 S Ct 2229; 48 L Ed 2d 832 (1 June 1976). SCB: 463 F Supp 1220; 531 F2d 132; 485 F2d 678

United States v R J Reynolds Tobacco Co, 416 F Supp 316 (D NJ, 22 June 1976)

Robert Hochman v F. A. Russo, Inc, No. 76-32983 (NY St Dep't of Labor Unemployment Ins Referee Sec, 19 Aug 1976)

Nelson Schwartz v Unemployment Ins Appeals Board, C153955, 75-9796-A (31 Aug 1976)

Porter v County of Cook, 42 Ill App 3d 287; 355 NE2d 561 (7 Sep 1976) (cigarette-fire injury case by mentally ill, hallucinating smoker in jail)

Gasper v Louisiana Stadium & Exposition District, 418 F Supp 716 (D ED La, 8 Sep 1976) (request for smoke-free site)

American Synthetic Rubber Corp v United Cork, Rubber, Linoleum and Plastic Workers of America, 67 Lab Arb (BNA) 603 (Ky, 5 Oct 1976) (smoker suspended 10 days for on-job smoking)

Commonwealth v Hughes, 468 Pa 502; 364 A2d 306 (8 Oct 1976) (fire case; smoker employee was criminally prosecuted for causing on-job fire killing two firemen)

Robert Hochman v F. A. Russo, Inc, Appeal No. 233,526 (NY St Dep't of Labor Unemployment Ins App Board, 24 Nov 1976). SCB: Claim No. 76-32983

Shimp v New Jersey Bell Telephone Co, 145 N J Super 516; 368 A2d 408 (20 Dec 1976) (injunction for smoke-free workplace)

Harriet Brooks v Trans World Airlines and Liberty Mutual Ins Co, 76 SF 257-975 (Cal Workmen's Compensation Appeals Board, 5 Jan 1977) (second-hand smoke injury case)

U.S. Industrial Chemicals Co v Int'l Union of Operating Engineers, 77-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8084 (Tuscola, 15 Jan 1977) (smoker suspended 4.5 months for smoking on job)

Pons v Lorillard, 549 F2d 950 (CA 4, NC, 2 Feb 1977) (employee age discrimination case, jury trial issue). SCB: 69 FRD 576

Hartke v Pioneer Engineering, 251 NW2d 113 (Minn, 10 Feb 1977)

Wilhelm v Globe Solvent Co, 373 A2d 218 (Delaware, 17 March 1977) (smoking by coworker caused fire and resultant injury)

Converters Ink v Chicago Ink Workers, 68 Lab Arb (BNA) 593 (Ill, 17 March 1977) (smoker suspended six months for on-job smoking; discussion of not hiring smokers)

Stokely-Van Camp, Inc v United Steelworkers of America, 77-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8277 (Ind, 29 April 1977)

Matter of Werner Peterke, ECAB Worker Comp Case (Baltimore, June 1977)

Carson v American Brands, Inc, 446 F Supp 780 (D ED Va, Richmond Div, 2 June 1977)

Lithography Services, Inc v Theodore Urbansky, Theodore Skeba, 1977-78 CCH NLRB § 18,223; 95 LRRM 1240; 229 NLRB 1157 (Ill, 2 June 1977)

Davis v Licari, 434 F Supp 23 (DC, 10 June 1977) (smoker in elevator retaliated against nonsmoker for enforcing local ordinance instiutionalizing the right to pure air with respect to TTS!)

Olson v Federal American Partners, 567 P2d 710 (Wyoming, 2 Aug 1977)

Olympic Stain, Inc (Division of Comerco, Inc) v General Drivers and Dockhands, 77-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8383 (Ky, 15 Aug 1977) (smoker suspended six months for on-job smoking)

Tari Way v Area Agency on Aging, Wisc EOC # 2393 (1 Nov 1977)

Schien Body & Equipment Co, Inc v United Steelworkers of America, 77-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8565; 69 Lab Arb (BNA) 930 (Ill, 16 Nov 1977)

Brown & Williamson, Etc. v Daniel International Corp, 563 F2d 671 (CA 5, Ga, 18 Nov 1977)

Appeal of Melvin Draper, J371536 (Wash, 7 Dec 1977)

Elkind v Liggett & Myers, Inc, 77 FRD 708 (D SD NY, 14 Dec 1977). SCB: 66 FRD 36

Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock v Director, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs, 6 BRBS 133 (1977)

Liggett & Myers, Inc v Federal Trade Commission, 567 F2d 1273 (CA 4, 29 Dec 1977)

Matter of Evelyn Bertram, Workers' Comp Case A9-190131 (Mich, 29 Dec 1977)

Appeal of Melvin Draper, J371536 (Wash, 16 Jan 1978)

Pons v Lorillard, 434 US 575; 98 S Ct 866; 55 L Ed 2d 40 (22 Feb 1978). SCB: 69 FRD 576; 549 F2d 950 (employee age discrimination case, right to jury trial upheld)

Confederated Tribes of Colville Indian Reservation v State of Washington, 446 F Supp 1339 (ED Wash, 22 Feb 1978) (tax case)

Gladieux Food Services, Inc v International Ass'n of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, 70 Lab Arb (BNA) 544 (Pa, 1 March 1978) (smoker discharge case, posing fire hazard, endangering travelers, etc.)

Federal Employees for Nonsmokers' Rights v United States, 446 F Supp 181 (D DC, 1 March 1978) (hostile decision by Judge Richey, a judge with a documented record of misconduct such as ex parte communications to aid government in case)

Mueller v State Accident Insurance Fund, 33 Or App 31; 575 P2d 673 (1 March 1978)

Chemtronics, Inc, 236 NLRB #21 (18 May 1978)

Harrison v Industrial Commission of Utah, 578 P2d 510 (Utah, 10 July 1978)

Gasper v Louisiana Stadium & Exposition District, 577 F2d 897 (CA 5, La, 1 Aug 1978). SCB: 418 F Supp 716 (Details, Smoking Ban Constitutionality)

Lewis v Tobacco Workers Int'l Union, 577 F2d 1135 (CA 4, 1978)

Gasper v Louisiana Stadium & Exposition District, 581 F2d 267 (CA 5, La, 14 Sep 1978). SCB: 418 F Supp 716

Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock v Director, OWCP, 583 F2d 1273 (CA 4, 21 Sep 1978). SCB: 6 BRBS 133

Patterson v American Tobacco Co, 586 F2d 300 (CA 4, Va, 23 Oct 1978). SCB: 535 F2d 257

Schober v Mountain Bell Telephone, 93 NM 337; 600 P2d 283 (NM App, 31 Oct 1978)

Bostik West, Division of USM Corp v Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers International Union, 78-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8545; 71 Lab Arb (BNA) 954 (Calif, 1 Nov 1978) (smoker discharge case)

Emler v Califano, Secretary, HEW, 462 F Supp 109 (D Kans, 8 Nov 1978) (smoker Social Security disability case)

Ellen L. Meyer v C. P. Clare & Co. and State of Idaho Dep't of Employment, DoE 615-78 (Idaho Industrial Comm'n, 17 Nov 1978)

Elkind v Liggett & Myers, Inc, 472 F Supp 123 (D SD NY, 17 Nov 1978). SCB: 66 FRD 36; 77 FRD 708

Nicolet Industries, Incv Amalgamated Clothing & Textile Workers Union, 79-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8398 (Pa, 1 Dec 1978)

Garrett v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 81 FRD 25 (D MD NC, 27 Dec 1978)

Rhode Island v Innis, 120 RI; 391 A2d 1158 (1979) (smoker kidnapping, robbery, murder case)

Ybarra v Illinois, 58 Ill App 3d 57; 373 NE2d 1013 (1979) (cigarette pack containing heroin)

Michigan v DeFillippo, 80 Mich App 197; 262 NW2d 921 (1979) (marijuana in cigarette package)

Thornton Chevrolet, Inc v Morgan, 148 Ga App 711; 252 SE2d 178 (5 Jan 1979)

Gasper v Louisiana Stadium & Exposition District, 439 US 1073; 99 S Ct 946; 59 L Ed 2d 40 (8 Jan 1979). SCB: 418 F Supp 716; 577 F2d 897

Dan River Mills v Foshee, 365 So 2d 1232 (Ala Civ App, 10 Jan 1979) (worker's compensation case)

Federal Trade Commission v Carter, 464 F Supp 633 (D DC, 25 Jan 1979)

Edgewater Motels, Inc v Gatzke, 277 NW 2d 11 (Minn, 26 Jan 1979) (issue of hotel guest smoking in room causing fire leading to damage to hotel)

Dep't of Health, Educ and Welfare, Soc Sec Admin v American Federation of Government Employees, 79-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8547 (Cal, 30 Jan 1979) (on-job smoking ban)

Rotenberg v Industrial Commission, 42 Colo App 161; 590 P2d 521 (1 Feb 1979) (unemployment comp case)

Jacobs v Michigan State Mental Health Dep't, 88 Mich App 503; 276 NW2d 627 (6 Feb 1979) (mentally ill smoker case)

Spragg v Campbell, 466 F Supp 658 (D SD, 12 Feb 1979) (employee discharge case, an alcoholic)

Sherwood Medical Industries v Retail, Wholesale and Dept Store Union, Local 125, 72 Lab Arb (BNA) 258 (Mo, 16 Feb 1979) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Newport News Shipbuilding and Dry Dock v Director, OWCP, 440 US 915; 99 S Ct 1232; 59 L Ed 2d 465 (21 Feb 1979). SCB: 6 BRBS 133; 583 F2d 1273

United States v Sheriff Goins, 593 F2d 88 (CA 8, Mo, 26 Feb 1979) (bribery case to not enforce cigarette law) (Bribery is used by tobacco pushers, see article, "Traders Offer Bribe to Stop Anti-Smoking Campaign." See also "Ex-Pontiac fire chief convicted of taking a bribe" (Detroit Free Press, 25 April 2013).

McCracken v Sloan, 40 NC App 214; 252 SE2d 250 (6 March 1979)

Mountain Bell Telephone v Schober, 92 NM 621; 593 P2d 62 (15 March 1979). SCB: 93 NM 337; 600 P2d 283

Reid v Eckerds Drugs, Inc, 40 NC App 476; 252 SE2d 344 (3 April 1979)

Holden v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 82 FRD 157 (D MD NC, 9 April 1979)

Rivergate Restaurant Corp v Metropolitan Dade County, Florida, 369 So 2d 679 (17 April 1979)

Berardino v General Moulding, Inc, PD, 586 SW2d 365 (Mo App, 17 July 1979)

Federal Employees for Nonsmokers' Rights v United States, 194 US App DC 391; 598 F2d 310 (2 May 1979). SCB: 446 F Supp 181

Michigan v DeFillippo, 443 US 31; 99 S Ct 2627; 61 L Ed 2d 343 (25 June 1979) SCB: 80 Mich App 197; 262 NW2d 921 (marijuana in cigarette package)

Jeffers v Sterling Garrett Coal Co, 583 SW2d 594 (Tenn, 25 June 1979)

Group Against Smoking Pollution (GASP) v Mecklenberg County, North Carolina, 42 NC App 225; 256 SE2d 477 (3 July 1979)

Morgan v State, 281 NW2d 710 (Minn, 6 July 1979)

Rum River Lumber Co v State of Minnesota, 282 NW2d 882 (Minn, 27 July 1979) (mentally ill committed-smoker case, committing arson, causing damages: It is not necessary "that the specific conduct . . . must be foreseeable. It is sufficient . . . that the . . . risk of harm . . . be foreseeable.")

Carson v American Brands, Inc, 606 F2d 420 (CA 4, Va, 14 Sep 1979). SCB: 446 F Supp 780

Gray v Industrial Commission, 76 Ill 2d 552; 31 Ill Dec 776; 394 NE2d 1153 (19 Sep 1979)

Amoco Texas Refining Co, Texas City, Texas v Oil, Chemical and Atomic Workers Internat'l Union, 72 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8589 (1979)

Dickerson v Reeves, 588 SW 2d 854 (Tex Civ App, 11 Oct 1979) (issue of smoker setting fire to premises, though forbidden to smoke on the job)

Federal Employees for Nonsmokers' Rights v United States, 444 US 926; 100 S Ct 265; 62 L Ed 2d 182 (29 Oct 1979). SCB: 194 US App DC 391; 598 F2d 310; 446 F Supp 181

Alford v City of Newport News, 220 Va 584; 260 SE2d 241 (21 Nov 1979) (non-smoking areas are unconstitutional when checkerboard style as not in fact protecting the public)

Ybarra v Illinois, 444 US 85; 100 S Ct 338; 62 L Ed 238 (28 Nov 1979) SCB: 58 Ill App 3d 57; 373 NE2d 1013 (cigarette pack containing heroin)

Chemehuevi Indian Tribe v California State Bd of Equalization, 492 F Supp 55 (D ND Cal, 12 Dec 1979)

Schoenkopf v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 483 F Supp 1185 (D ED Pa, 18 Jan 1980)

Pullman Kellogg v Workmens' Compensation Appeals Board, 26 Cal 3d 450; 161 Cal Rptr 783; 605 P2d 422 (4 Feb 1980)

Matter of Eli Witt Co, Philip Morris, Inc v Eli Witt Co, 2 BR 492 (D MD Fla, 5 Feb 1980) (bankruptcy case)

Alexander v California Unemployment Insurance Appeals Board, 104 Cal App 3d 97; 163 Cal Rptr 411; 14 ALR4th 1229 (1 April 1980) (unemployment comp case)

Rhode Island v Innis, 446 US 291; 100 S Ct 1682; 64 L Ed 2d 297 (RI, 12 May 1980) SCB: 120 RI; 391 A2d 1158 (smoker kidnapping, robbery, murder case)

Morrison v Burlington Industries, 47 NC App 50; 266 SE2d 741 (3 June 1980) (worker comp case)

State of Washington v Confederated Tribes, 447 US 134; 100 S Ct 2069; 65 L Ed 2d 10 (10 June 1980) (tax case). SCB: 446 F Supp 1339

Ravreby v United Airlines, 293 NW2d 260 (Iowa, 18 June 1980)

Bank of Danville v Farmers Nat'l Bank, 602 SW2d 160; 29 UCCRS 1020 (Ky, 24 June 1980) (identification issue)

Mediterranean Diner, Inc, t/a Bay Diner v Local 54, Hotel and Restaurant Employees and Bartenders Internat'l Union, 1980 CCH NLRB § 17,294; 250 NLRB 187 (26 June 1980)

Johns Manville Sales Corp v International Ass'n of Machinists, 621 F2d 756 (CA 5, Tex, 16 July 1980)

Litton Industries, Litton Microwave Cooking Products Div v United Electrical, Radio and Machine Workers, Local 1139, 75 Lab Arb (BNA) 308 (Minn, 21 July 1980) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Loew's Theatres Inc dba Lorillard, 511 F Supp 855 (D NY, 26 July 1980)

Commonwealth v Pennsylvania Labor Board, 11 PPER § 11,223 (1980)

Moore v J. P. Stevens & Co, Inc, 47 NC App 744; 269 SE2d 159 (5 Aug 1980) (worker comp case)

Schober v Mountain Bell Telephone, 96 NM 376; 630 P2d 1231 (7 Aug 1980). SCB: 92 NM 621; 593 P2d 62; 93 NM 337; 600 P2d 283

State in the Interest of T.L.O., 178 NJ Super 329; 428 A2d 1327 (26 Sep 1980).

Clark v Burlington Industries, 49 NC App 269; 271 SE2d 101 (21 Oct 1980) (worker comp case)

Morrison v Burlington Industries, 301 NC 226; 271 SE2d 364 (23 Oct 1980). SCB: 47 NC App 50; 266 SE2d 741

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Loew's Theatres Inc dba Lorillard, 210 PQ 291; 511 F Supp 867 (D NY, 24 Oct 1980)

Moore v J. P. Stevens & Co, Inc, 301 NC 401; 274 SE2d 226 (4 Nov 1980). SCB: 47 NC App 744; 269 SE2d 159

Parker v Dep't of the Interior, 4 MSPB 184; 4 MSPR 97 (17 Nov 1980)

Patterson v American Tobacco Co, 634 F2d 744 (CA 4, Va, 19 Nov 1980). SCB: 586 F2d 300; 535 F2d 257

Federal Trade Commission v Carter, 205 US App DC 73; 636 F2d 781 (28 Nov 1980). SCB: 464 F Supp 633

Elkind v Liggett & Myers, Inc, 635 F2d 156 (CA 2, 4 Dec 1980). SCB: 66 FRD 36; 77 FRD 708; 472 F Supp 123

Action on Smoking and Health v Harris, Secy, HHS, 210 US App DC 123; 655 F2d 236 (19 Dec 1980).

Ehringhaus v Federal Trade Commission, 525 F Supp 21 (D DC, 23 Dec 1980)

Schoenkopf v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 637 F2d 205 (CA 3, Pa, 29 Dec 1980). SCB: 483 F Supp 1185

Maria M. Flanikan v Office of Personnel Management, MSPB No. DA831L10001, 24 Alta L Rep 403 (Tex, 29 Dec 1980)

Carson v American Brands, Inc, 450 US 79; 101 S Ct 993; 67 L Ed 2d 59 (25 Feb 1981). SCB: 606 F2d 420; 446 F Supp 780

People v Battles, 93 Ill App 3d 1093; 49 Ill Dec 378; 418 NE2d 22 (2 March 1981)

Ruckstiehl v Commonwealth, Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 57 Pa Cmnwlth 302; 426 A2d 719 (4 March 1981) (unemployment comp case)

Social Security Admin v American Federation of Government Employees, 5 FLRA No. 33 (9 March 1981)

Anderson v Employer Anoka County Welfare Board, Case No. 4-79 Civ 269 (D Minn, 24-26 March 1981)

Caprin v Harris, Secy, HHS, 511 F Supp 589 (D ND NY, 8 April 1981) (smoker Social Security disability case; recognition of smoking listing in the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders)

Chambersburg Area School District v Com of Pennsylvania PERC, 60 Pa Cmwlth 29; 430 A2d 740; 110 LRRM (BNA) 2251 (10 April 1981) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Island Tobacco Co v R. J. Reynolds Industries, 513 F Supp 726 (D Hawaii, 21 April 1981)

Shipley v City of Johnson City, 620 SW2d 500 (Tenn App, 24 April 1981) lv app den 3 August 1981 (addicted smoker lit up while working at a gas line excavation, the resultant explosion caused injury to third party)

Matter of L.M., 432 A2d 692 (DC App, 4 May 1981) (sustaining conviction for smoking on bus)

Crucible Steel v Workmen's Compensation, 59 Pa Cmnwlth 184; 429 A2d 123 (6 May 1981)

Page v Prestressed Concrete Co, 399 So 2d 657 (La App, 26 May 1981) (worker comp case)

Humphries v Cone Mills Corp, 279 SE2d 56 (NC App, 16 June 1981)

Linda A. Appell v Moorestown Board of Education, Unemployment Comp Claim No. AT C81-3036 (NJ Dep't of Labor and Industry, 25 June 1981)

O'Neal v R. J. Reynolds Industries, 517 F Supp 587 (D SD Ga, 1 July 1981)

Matter of Eli Witt Co, R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Eli Witt Co, 12 BR 757 (D MD Fla, 7 July 1981)

Carson v American Brands, Inc, 654 F2d 300 (CA 4, 17 July 1981). SCB: 450 US 79; 101 S Ct 993; 67 L Ed 2d 59; 606 F2d 420; 446 F Supp 780

DiNicola v Crucible Steel, Inc, 83 App Div 2d 735; 442 NYS2d 582 (23 July 1981)

Hurley v Miller Transporters, Inc and Teamsters Local No 891, 113 LRRM (BNA) 2686 (SD Miss, 25 Aug 1981)

Hummer v Dalton, 657 F2d 621 (CA 4, Virginia, 26 Aug 1981) (smoke-free prison case)

Matter of High, 638 P2d 818 (Colo App, 3 Sep 1981)

Swanson v City of Tulsa, 633 P2d 1256 (Okla Crim App, 3 Sep 1981) (conviction for smoking in elevator)

Morrison v Burlington Industries, 304 NC 1; 282 SE2d 458 (6 Oct 1981). SCB: 47 NC App 50; 266 SE2d 741; 301 NC 226; 271 SE2d 364

DiNicola v Crucible Steel, Inc, 54 NY2d 609; 445 NYS2d 1027; 429 NE2d 835 (20 Oct 1981). SCB: 83 App Div 2d 735; 442 NYS2d 582

Ierardi v Lorillard, Inc., 777 F Supp 420 (ED Pa, 28 Oct 1981)

In re Eli Witt Co, Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Eli Witt Co, 16 BR 197 (D MD Fla, 16 Nov, 28 Dec 1981)

Matter of High, 638 P2d 818 (Col, 21 Dec 1981)

Crucible Steel Co v Workmen's Compensation Appeal Bd, 63 Pa Cmnwlth 374; 437 A2d 1324 (23 Dec 1981)

Dept of Health, Educ and Welfare, Social Security Admin v AFGE Local 1923, 82-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8206 (DC, 22 Jan 1982) ("checker-boarding" (a partial ban) found ineffective; management is not to overrule nonsmoker personal determination; on-job smoking ban is not negotiable; smoking ban ordered to provide safe job site for nonsmoker) (See .pdf Full Text.)

Lofton v Louisiana Pac Corp, 410 So 2d 1171 (La App, 3 Feb 1982)

Frady v Groves Thread/General Accident Ins Co, 56 NC App 61; 286 SE2d 844 (16 Feb 1982)

Falstaff Brewing Corp v Philip Morris Inc, 89 FRD 133 (ND Cal, 28 Jan 1981 amended 10 March 1981) (missing documents, contempt of court)

Rutledge v Tultex Corp, 56 NC App 345; 289 SE2d 72 (16 March 1982)

Matter of Hembree, 33 ECAB 696 (16 March 1982)

Lofton v Louisiana Pac Corp, 412 So 2d 1094 (19 March 1982). SCB: 410 So 2d 1171

United Telephone Co of Florida v IBEW Local 199, 78 Lab Arb (BNA) 866 (Fla, 31 March 1982) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Patterson v American Tobacco Co, 456 US 63; 102 S Ct 1534; 71 L Ed 2d 748 (5 April 1982). SCB: 634 F2d 744; 586 F2d 300; 535 F2d 257

Kingery v Ford Motor Co, 116 Mich App 606; 323 NW2d 318 (16 April 1982)

General Dynamics Corp v Sachetti, 681 F2d 37 (CA 1, 24 May 1982)

Anderson v State Accident Fund Insurance Fund, 57 Or App 770; 646 P2d 1352 (16 June 1982)

Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board v Chambersburg Area School District, 498 Pa 366; 446 A2d 603 (17 June 1982). SCB: 60 Pa Cmnwlth 29; 430 A2d 740

State in Interest of T.L.O., 185 NJ Super 279; 448 A2d 493 (30 June 1982). SCB: 178 NJ Super 329; 428 A2d 1327

Bollin v Kingston, 89 App Div 2d 658; 453 NYS2d 113 (8 July 1982) (rule upheld, school bus driver suspended for smoking)

Union Sanitary District v United Public Employees, 82-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8420 (Calif, 9 July 1982)

Diefenthal v Civil Aeronautics Board, 681 F2d 1039 (CA 5, 6 Aug 1982) (smoke-free flight case; upholding smoking ban constitutionality)

Brown & Williamson, Ltd v United States, 688 F2d 747 (Ct Cl, 25 Aug 1982)

Vickers v Veterans Administration, 29 FEP Cases 1197; 30 E.P.D. § 27,352; 549 F Supp 85 (D Wash, 31 Aug 1982)

Home Insurance Co v Davis, 642 SW2d 268 (Tex Civ App, 7 Sep 1982)

Consolidation Coal Co, Robinson Run Mine, Jones Run Portal v United Mine Workers of Am, 82-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8600 (W Va, 9 Sep 1982) (smoker discharge case)

Smith v Fieldcrest Mills, Inc, 224 Va 24; 294 SE2d 805 (9 Sep 1982) (smoke free work place injunction case)

Smith v Western Electric Co, 643 SW2d 10; 37 ALR4th 473; 10 OSH Cas (BNA) 2001; 1982 OSHD (CCH) ¶ 26,256 (Mo App, 14 Sep 1982) (smoke free work place injunction case pursuant to the Shimp precedent; see also the appellate brief, and the supportive amicus brief, soon published in Suffolk University Law School Review, Vol. 13, No. 2, Spring 1982, pp. 25-31).

Matter of Internal Revenue Service, 61 Comp Gen 634 (24 Sep 1982)

Equal Employment Opportunity Commission v Liggett & Myers, Inc, 690 F2d 1072 (CA 4, NC, 28 Sep 1982) (discrimination case)

Howard v Johns-Manville Sales Corp, 420 So 2d 1190 (La App, 12 Oct 1982)

Parodi v Merit Systems Protection Board and Office of Personnel Management, 690 F2d 731; 702 F2d 743 (CA 9, Cal, 21 Oct 1982)

Monteer v Schweiker, Secretary, HHS, 551 F Supp 384 (D WD Mo, WD, 18 Nov 1982) (smoker Social Security disability case)

Parodi v Office of Personnel Management, 12 MSPB 274; 19 MSPR 99 (26 Nov 1982). SCB: 690 F2d 731

Paul Hentzel v Singer Co, 138 Cal App 3d 290; 188 Cal Rptr 159 (20 Dec 1982)

Diefenthal v Civil Aeronautics Board, 459 US 1107; 103 S Ct 732; 74 L Ed 2d 956 (10 Jan 1983). SCB: 681 F2d 1039

Action on Smoking and Health v Civil Aeronautics Board, 226 US App DC 57; 699 F2d 1209 (28 Jan 1983) (travelers' rights smoke-free flights case)

Falstaff Brewing Corp v Philip Morris Inc, 702 F2d 770 (CA 9, 28 March 1983). SCB: 89 FRD 133

Swink v Cone Mills, Inc, 61 NC App 475; 300 SE2d 848 (5 April 1983)

Rutledge v Tultex Corp./Kings Yarn, 308 NC 85; 301 SE2d 359 (5 April 1983)

United States v Bunney, 705 F2d 378 (CA 10, Wyoming, 12 April 1983) (issue of arsonist torching three buildings using gasoline ignited by cigarettes)

People v Hudgins, 125 Mich App 140; 336 NW2d 241 (20 April 1983)

Schnadig Corp v Upholsterers' Intl Union of No Am, Local 186, 83-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8267 (Ind, 23 April 1983) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Commonwealth v Commonwealth, Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board, 74 Pa Cmwlth Ct 1; 459 A2d 452; 113 LRRM (BNA) 3052 (28 April 1983) (authority to ban TTS)

Barrington v Dan River, Inc, 225 Va 240; 302 SE2d 505 (29 April 1983)

Caskey v Dan River Mills, Inc, 225 Va 405; 302 SE2d 507 (29 April 1983)

Gordon v Raven Systems & Research, Inc, 462 A2d 10 (DC App, 5 May 1983)

Cooper v Chrysler Corp, 125 Mich App 811; 336 NW2d 877 (18 May 1983)

Robin A. Ennis v Stoehmann Bros, Appeal No. B-83-2-R-24, 2-218601 (Pa Unemployment Comp Bd of Review, 27 May 1983)

Marie Lee v Dep't of Public Welfare, No 15385, 1.2 TPLR 2.82; 11 Mass Lawyers Weekly 1190 (31 May 1983) (job smoking ban case)

Sumner v Work Comp App Bd, 33 Cal 3d 965; 191 Cal Rptr 811; 663 P2d 534 (2 June 1983)

Director, Office of Workers' Comp Programs v Rowe, 710 F2d 251 (CA 6, Ky, 17 June 1983)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Federal Trade Commission, 710 F2d 1165 (CA 6, 24 June 1983)

Wyle v R. J. Reynolds Industries, Inc, 709 F2d 585 (CA 9, Cal, 30 June 1983) (anti-trust case, attorney accessory)

Action on Smoking and Health v Civil Aeronautics Board, 230 US App DC 1; 713 F2d 795 (30 June 1983)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Jacobson, 713 F2d 262 (CA 7, Ill, 14 July 1983) (censorship case)

State in the Interest of T.L.O., 94 NJ 331; 463 A2d 934 (8 Aug 1983). SCB: 178 NJ Super 329; 428 A2d 1327; 185 NJ Super 279; 448 A2d 493

Smith v Blue Cross & Blue Shield of New Jersey, No. C-3617-81E (N J Super Ct Ch Div, 18 Aug 1983) (employee request for smoke-free workplace)

Kensell v State of Oklahoma, 716 F2d 1350; 1983 US App LEXIS 16970 (CA 10, Okl, 13 Sep 1983) (employee request for smoke-free workplace)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Federal Trade Commission, 717 F2d 963 (CA 6, 19 Sep 1983). SCB: 710 F2d 1165

Olin Corp, McIntosh Plant v International Ass'n of Machinists, 83-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8521; 81 Lab Arb (BNA) 644 (Alabama, 29 Sep 1983) (smoker discharge case)

Federal Trade Commission v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 580 F Supp 981 (D DC, 14 Oct 1983)

Lauren Hall v Sisters of Mercy Health Corp, Deaconess Hospital, # 80-031-746 (Wayne County Circuit Court, Michigan, 2 Oct 1983) (employee request for smokefree workplace)

Philip Morris v Pittsburgh Penguins, Inc, 589 F Supp 912 (WD Pa, 31 Oct 1983) (business practices case, issue of tobacco advertising on scoreboard)

Palmer Coking Coal Co v Director, Office of Workers' Comp Programs, 720 F2d 1054 (CA 9, 17 Nov 1983)

Swink v Cone Mills, Inc, 65 NC App 397; 309 SE2d 271 (6 Dec 1983). SCB: 61 NC App 475; 300 SE2d 848

Matter of Equal Employment Opportunity Commission, 63 Comp Gen 115 (14 Dec 1983)

Shattuck v County of Orange, No. 73-30-0031-83 (Calif, 21 Dec 1983)

National Archives, 6 FLRA No. 91 (1984) (non-negotiability case)

Snap-On Tools Corp v IAMAW Lodge 1045, 86-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8409 (Iowa, 19 June 1986) (eliminating smoking was upheld as it is not a binding working condition, and elimination has a legitimate business goal, cleanliness)

Action on Smoking and Health v Civil Aeronautics Board, 233 US App DC 79; 724 F2d 211 (6 Jan 1984)

Gordon v Schweiker, Secretary, HHS, 725 F2d 231 (CA 4, NC, 11 Jan 1984) (smoker Social Security disability case)

Parodi v Office of Personnel Management, 19 MSPR 233 (27 Jan 1984). SCB: 12 MSPB 274; 19 MSPR 99

Palmer v Liggett Group, Inc, 635 F Supp 392 (D Mass, 1 Feb 1984)

Calloway v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 675 SW2d 389 (Ky, 13 Feb 1984) (worker compensation case)

Social Security Admin, Region II, F.L.R.A. Case No. 2-CA 30014 (27 Feb 1984) (negotiability issue case)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Federal Trade Commission, 465 US 1100; 104 S Ct 595; 80 L Ed 2d 127 (19 March 1984). SCB: 710 F2d 1165; 717 F2d 963

Social Security Admin, Baltimore v Am Federation of Gov't Employees, FMCS 82 K 12768 (Md, 15 May 1984)

People v John Wayne Gacy, 103 Ill 2d 1; 82 Ill Dec 391; 468 NE2d 1171 (6 June 1984) (smoker crime case; conviction of smoker murderer of 33 boys and men).

McCrocklin v Employer and Calif Dep't of Employment, 156 Cal App 3d 1067; 205 Cal Rptr 156 (7 June 1984) (smoking on the job case, and unemployment comp case)

Philip Morris v Pittsburgh Penguins, Inc, 738 F2d 424 (CA 3, Pa, 21 June 1984). SCB: 589 F Supp 912 (WD Pa, 31 Oct 1983) (issue of tobacco advertising on scoreboard)

Parodi v Office of Personnel Management, 22 MSPR 251 (17 July 1984). SCB: 19 MSPR 233; 12 MSPB 274; 19 MSPR 99

Dental Command, Department of the Army v Am Federation of Gov't Employees, 83 Lab Arb (BNA) 529 (Tex, 31 July 1984)

Eric A. Shrader v Veterans Administration (WD Ky, Louisville, Aug 1984)

Southwest Forest Industries, Inc v United Paperworkers Int'l Union, Local 765, 84-2 Lab Arb Wards (CCH) § 8432 (Mo, 16 Aug 1984) (smoker suspended four months for smoking-on-job)

Evans v Department of the Navy, 22 MSPR 651 (24 Aug 1984)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc I, 593 F Supp 1146 (D NJ, 20 Sep 1984)

Marlene W. Ritchie, WCB Case No. 84-07248, Claim No. D 69058, Van Natta (Oregon, 7 Oct 1984)

Frady v Groves Thread/General Accident Insurance Co, 312 NC 316; 321 SE2d 835 (6 Nov 1984). SCB: 56 NC App 61; 286 SE2d 844

Ring v R. J. Reynolds Industries, Inc, 597 F Supp 1277 (ND Ill, 27 Nov 1984) (employee discharge case)

Leaf Tobacco Exporters Ass'n v John Block, Sec'y of Agriculture, 749 F2d 1106 (CA 4, NC, 5 Dec 1984) (business practices case)

Iandorio v Kriss & Senko Enterprises, Inc, 329 Pa Super 624; 488 A2d 1169 (7 Dec 1984) (worker compensation case)

Philip Morris v American Shipping Co, Inc, 748 F2d 563 (CA 11, SD Fla, 10 Dec 1984) (trade case, tobacco cargo damage)

New Jersey v T.L.O., 469 US 325; 105 S Ct 733; 83 L Ed 2d 720 (15 Jan 1985). SCB: 94 NJ 331; 463 A2d 934; 178 NJ Super 329; 428 A2d 1327; 185 NJ Super 279; 448 A2d 493

Philip Morris v American Shipping Co, Inc, 753 F2d 1087 (CA 11, SD Fla, 21 Jan 1985). SCB: 748 F2d 563

Richard Rossie v State of Wisconsin/Dep't of Revenue, #84-CV-5567 (Dane Cty Cir Ct, 30 Jan 1985) (smoker vs smokefree job rule)

Golden v Communication Technology Corp, 36 E.P.D. § 35,095; 1985 WL 1102 (D ND Ga, 30 Jan 1985) (smoking on the job case, smoker fired)

Philip Morris v John Block, Sec'y of Agriculture, 755 F2d 368 (CA 4, 13 Feb 1985) (trade case, employees alleging job discrimination)

E-B Grain Co v Denton and Stephenson Tobacco Whse, Inc, 73 NC App 14; 325 SE2d 522; 40 UCCRS 1119 (19 Feb 1985) (identification issue)

Billman v Sumrall, 464 So 2d 382 (La App, 26 Feb 1985) (unemployment comp case)

Gacy v Illinois, 470 US 1037; 105 S Ct 1410; 84 L Ed 2d 799 (4 March 1985). SCB: 103 Ill 2d 1; 82 Ill Dec 391; 468 NE2d 1171 (smoker criminal)

Appeal of R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 73 NC App 475; 326 SE2d 911 (19 March 1985)

Moore v Inmont Corp, 608 F Supp 919; 39 FEP Cas (BNA) 1382; 38 EPD ¶ 35,699 (D WD NC, 4 April 1985) (smoker fired from job case)

Chemehuevi Indian Tribe v California State Bd of Equalization, 757 F2d 1047 (CA 9, Cal, 12 April 1985). SCB: 492 F Supp 55

Smith v A. T. & T. Technologies, Inc, 446121 (St. Louis Cty Cir Ct, 23 April 1985)

Matter of Compensation of Downey, 37 Van Natta 455 (23 April 1985)

E-B Grain Co v Denton and Stephenson Tobacco Whse, Inc, 313 NC 598; 330 SE2d 608 (7 May 1985). SCB: 73 NC App 14; 325 SE2d 522; 40 UCCRS 1119

Bundy v State of Florida, 471 So 2d 9 (9 May 1985) (smoker crime case)

Dep't of Labor v Am Federation of Gov't Employees, 17 FLRA # 125 (9 May 1985)

Lake v Futorian Corp, 709 P2d 684 (Okla, 4 June 1985)

American Express Travel Related Services v Marco, 611 F Supp 938 (D SD NY, 27 June 1985) (travelers' pure-air rights case)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 106 FRD 573 (D NJ, 17 July 1985) (product liability case)

In re Loew's Theatres, Inc, 769 F2d 764; 226 USPQ 865 (CA Fed, 9 Aug 1985) (trademark application case)

Crockett v Eckerd Drugs of North Carolina, Inc, 615 F Supp 528; 52 FEP Cas (BNA) 852 (WD NC, 16 Aug 1985) (smoker discharge case)

North Dakota Mill and Elevator Ass'n v American Federation of Grain Millers, 85-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8566 (1 Sep 1985) (smoker suspended 9 months for smoking-on-job)

State v Smith, 146 Ariz 491; 707 P2d 289; 64 ALR 4th 809 (10 Sep 1985)

Appeal of R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 314 NC 540; 335 SE2d 21 (19 Sep 1985). SCB: 73 NC App 475; 326 SE2d 911

Brisboy v Fibreboard Corp, 148 Mich App 298; 384 NW2d 39 (24 Oct 1985)

Chemehuevi Indian Tribe v California State Bd of Equalization, 474 US 9; 106 S Ct 289; 88 L Ed 2d9 (4 Nov 1985). SCB: 757 F2d 1047; 492 F Supp 55

Melancon v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 621 F Supp 567 (WD Ky, Louisville Div, 7 Nov 1985) (dangerous tobacco case)

1985 Opinion of Attorney General (Maryland, 10 Dec 1985)

Federal Trade Commission v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 250 US App DC 162; 778 F2d 35 (10 and 18 Dec 1985). SCB: 580 F Supp 981

Whitworth v Fast Fare Markets of South Carolina, Inc, 289 SC 418; 338 SE2d 155; 55 ALR4th 1235 (17 Dec 1985) (tobacco sales to youths issue)

Roysdon v RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co, 623 F Supp 1189 (D ED Tenn, ND, 18 Dec 1985)

Meir v OPM, MSPB DA831L8610324 (Dallas, 1986)

Chemehuevi Indian Tribe v California State Bd of Equalization, 474 US 1077; 106 S Ct 839; 88 L Ed 2d 810 (13 Jan 1986). SCB: 474 US 9; 106 S Ct 289; 88 L Ed 2d 9; 757 F2d 1047; 492 F Supp 55

County of Erie v Elizabeth A. Palmer, NY PERB No. U-7922 (NY PERB, 1986)

In re Carlquist, No. 406-48-0473-7 (Wash Employment Security Dep't, 31 Jan 1986)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 785 F2d 1108 (CA 3, 12 March 1986)

Jeffries v Reed, 631 F Supp 1212 (ED Wash, 27 March 1986) (prison smoke-free air case)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc II, 789 F2d 181 (CA 3, 7 and 18 April 1986)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Southern Railway Co, 110 FRD 95 (MD NC, 10 April 1986) (business practices case)

Bernard v Cameron & Colby Co, Inc, 397 Mass 320; 491 NE2d 604; 63 ALR 4th 1015; 2 IER Cases (BNA) CAS 678; 104 Lab Cas (CCH) § P55,584 (13 April 1986)

Palmer v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co I, 633 F Supp 1171 (D Mass, 25 April 1986)

Craig by Craig v Buncombe County Board of Education, 80 NC App 683; 343 SE2d 222 (20 May 1986) (tobacco addiction prevention case)

Kamen v AT&T, McDonald and Buckham, 40 EPD ¶ 36,163; 4 Fed P Serv 3d (Callaghan) 979; 791 F2d 1006 (CA 2, NY, 23 May 1986)

Ogg v Bill White Chevrolet Co, 720 P2d 324 (Oklahoma, 3 June 1986) (worker compensation case)

Snap-On Tools Corp v IAMAW Lodge 1045, 86-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8409 (Iowa, 19 June 1986) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Marsee v United States Tobacco Co, 639 F Supp 466; 20 Fed Rules Evid Serv 1245 (D WD Oklahoma, 25 June 1986) (dangerous tobacco, issue of tobacco-induced cancer, specifically snuff)

Harper v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 717 SW2d 502 (Ky App, 27 June 1986) (worker compensation case)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v Jacobson, 644 F Supp 1240 (ND Ill, 7 Aug 1986). SCB: 713 F2d 262

Deschler v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co., 797 F2d 695 (CA 8, Mo, 8 Aug 1986) (employee discharge case)

Checker Motors Co v Int'l Union, Allied Industrial Workers of America, Local No. 682, AFL-CIO, 86-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8612 (Mich, 11 Aug 1986)

Philip Morris v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 641 F Supp 1438 (MD Ga, 20 Aug 1986) (trade case, citing multiple violations asking triple damages)

Craig by Craig v Buncombe County Board of Education, 318 NC 281; 348 SE 2d 138 (28 Aug 1986). SCB: 80 NC App 683; 343 SE2d 222

Hall v Veterans Administration, EEOC No. 054-086-X0097 (Mich, 5 Sep 1986) (employee request for smoke-free workplace)

Rossie v State/Dep' of Revenue, 133 Wisc 2d 341; 395 NW2d 801; 1 IER Cases (BNA) Cas 1048; 105 Lab Cas (CCH) ¶ 55,658; 65 ALR 4th 1191 (Wis App, 12 Sep 1986) (smoker vs smokefree job rule, context upholding smoking ban constitutionality)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 644 F Supp 283 (D NJ, 25 Sep 1986)

Chemehuevi Indian Tribe v California State Bd of Equalization, 800 F2d 1446 (CA 9, 26 Sep 1986). SCB: 474 US 1077; 106 S Ct 839; 88 L Ed 2d 810; 474 US 9; 106 S Ct 289; 88 L Ed 2d9; 757 F2d 1047; 492 F Supp 55

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 802 F2d 658 (CA 3, 29 Sep 1986). SCB: 593 F Supp 1146; 789 F2d 181

Philip Morris v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 645 F Supp 174 (MD Ga, 7 Oct 1986). SCB: 641 F Supp 1438 (trade case)

Bundy v State of Florida, 479 US 894; 107 S Ct 295; 93 L Ed 2d 269 (14 Oct 1986). SCB: 471 So 2d 9 (smoker crime case)

Lee v Carlson, 645 F Supp 1430 (D SD NY, 14 Oct 1986) (smoke-free prison case)

Iacovelli v New York Times Co, 124 App Div 2d 324; 507 NYS2d 922 (16 Oct 1986)

National Pen & Pencil Co v United Food and Commercial Workers, Local 1557, 87 Lab Arb (BNA) 1081 (Tenn, 25 Oct 1986) (on-job smoking ban)

Arnold v Dept of the Army, No. 033-085-5003 (EEOC, 27 Oct 1986)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Corp, 116 FRD 205 (MD NC, 10 Nov 1986) (discovery case)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 113 FRD 86; 7 FR Serv 3d 982 (D NJ, 12 Nov 1986)

Coleman v Cycle Transformer Corp, 105 NJ 285; 520 A2d 1341 (14 Nov 1986) (on-job injury case)

H-N Advertising & Display Co, Inc v Sheet Metal Workers Intl Assn, Local 503, 87-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) 8242 (Ind, 14 Nov 1986) (on-job smoking ban case)

Iandorio v Kriss & Senko Enterprises, Inc, 512 Pa 392; 517 A2d 530 (17 Nov 1986). SCB: 329 Pa Super 624; 488 A2d 1169

Perkins v Ford Motor Co, et al., Civ No. 86-633018-CZ (Wayne Cty Cir Ct, Mich, 25 Nov 1986) (injunction for smoke-free workplace)

McCarthy v State of Washington Dep't of Social and Health Services, 46 Wash App 125; 730 P2d 681; 1 IER Cases (BNA) 1233 (8 Dec 1986)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 649 F Supp 664 (D NJ, 9 Dec 1986)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Durham County, North Carolina, 479 US 130; 107 S Ct 499; 93 L Ed 2d 449 (9 Dec 1986). SCB: 314 NC 540; 335 SE2d 21; 73 NC App 475; 326 SE2d 911

Dewey v RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co, 216 NJ Super 347; 523 A2d 712 (22 Dec 1986) (product liability case)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 479 US 1043; 107 S Ct 907; 93 L Ed 2d 857 (12 Jan 1987). SCB: 593 F Supp 1146; 106 FRD 573; 644 F Supp 283; 785 F2d 1108; 789 F2d 181; 802 F2d 658; 649 F Supp 664

Lapham v Commonwealth Unemployment Comp Bd of Review, 103 Pa Cmnwlth 144; 519 A2d 1101 (13 Jan 1987) (unemployment comp case)

Lee v Carlson, 812 F2d 712 (CA 2, NY, 26 Jan 1987). SCB: 645 F Supp 1430

Morelite Equipment Co v IBEW Local 56, 88 Lab Arb (BNA) 777 (Pennsylvania, 28 Jan 1987) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Mack v County of Rockland, 128 App Div 2d 922; 512 NYS 2d 732 (5 March 1987)

Harrell v Harrell, No. 1084, 1987 WL 6716 (Tenn App, 19 Feb 1987) (child custody case)

Bundy v Dugger, 816 F2d 564 (CA 11, Fla, 2 April 1987) (smoker crime case)

Board of Education v Cohalan, 135 Misc 2d 358; 515 NYS 2d 691 (9 April 1987) (TTS regulation case banning smoking in schools)

Grusendorf v City of Oklahoma City, 816 F2d 539; 1987 US App LEXIS 5133; 55 USLW 2588; 2 Indiv.Empl.Rts.Cas. (BNA) 51 (CA 10, Okla, 17 April 1987) (smoking on the job case, smokers discharged, context upholding smoking ban constitutionality, and citing the 15 USC § 1333 Surgeon General warning. See also the smokers' arguments.)

Ace Hardware Corp v General Teamsters, 87-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8531 (Georgia, 24 April 1987)

Boreali v Axelrod, Comm'r, NY St Dept of Health, 2 IER Cases (BNA) 668 (24 April 1987)

American Tobacco Co v Evans, 508 So 2d 1057; 2 USPQ2d 1866; 75 ALR4th 997 (Miss, 29 April 1987) (censorship issue arising in dangerous tobacco case pursuant to company policy of seeking secrecy)

H-N Advertising & Display Co, Inc v Sheet Metal Workers Intl Assn, Local 503, 88 Lab Arb (BNA) 1311 (1 May 1987) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 822 F2d 335; 7 FR Serv 3d 1438 (CA 3, 8 June 1987). SCB: 113 FRD 86; 7 FR Serv 3d 982

Dewey v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 108 NJ 198; 527 A2d 1391 (9 June 1987). SCB: 216 NJ Super 347; 523 A2d 712

In re Marriage of Stanley, 411 NW2d 698 (Iowa, 24 June 1987) (divorce case)

White v U.S. Postal Service, EEOC No. 01853426 (30 June 1987) (employee seeking smoke-free workplace)

Cruiess v Matty, 1987 WL 13348 (ED Pa, 1 July 1987) (prison smoking ban case)

Lapham v Commonwealth Unemployment Comp Bd of Review, Pa 611; 529 A2d 1084 (1 July 1987). SCB: 103 Pa Cmnwlth 144; 519 A2d 1101

In re R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 136 Misc 2d 282; 518 NYS2d 729 (10 July 1987) (quashing subpoena for California case)

Boreali v Axelrod, Comm'r, NY St Dept of Health, 130 App Div 2d 107; 518 NYS 2d 440; 2 IER Cases (BNA) 671; 107 LC (CCH) § 55802 (23 July 1987) (a TTS regulation case)

Beeson v Johnson, 668 F Supp 498 (D ED NC, 12 Aug 1987)

Stephen v American Brands, Inc, 825 F2d 312 (CA 11, 21 Aug 1987)

Palmer v Liggett & Myers Tobacco Co II, 825 F2d 620 (CA 1, 24 Aug 1987) SCB: 633 F Supp 1171

Opinions of Attorney General 1987-1988, No. 6460, pp 167-171; 1987 Michigan Register 366 (25 Aug 1987) (placing nonsmokers "checkerboard style" does not achieve law compliance, an Alford analysis, as the benefit of safety is intended)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v Jacobson 827 F2d 1119 (CA 7, Ill, 12 Aug 1987). SCB: 644 F Supp 1240; 713 F2d 262

Dep't of Fair Employment and Housing v City of Fresno Dep't of Social Services, Nos. FEP 82-83, C9-0084p, FEP 82-83 C9-0143re, FEP82083 C9-0085p, and FEP 82-83 C9-0199re (Cal Fair Empl and Housing Comm, 21 Sep 1987)

Bundy v Dugger, 484 US 870; 108 S Ct 198; 98 L Ed 2d 149 (5 Oct 1987). SCB: 816 F2d 564 (smoker crime case)

Thomas J. Kline, Inc v Lorillard, Inc, 674 F Supp 183 (D Md, 6 Oct 1987) (business practices case)

Worthington Foods, Inc v United Industrial Workers, 87-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8546; 89 Lab Arb (BNA) 1069 (Ohio, 16 Oct 1987) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Parker Pen USA, Ltd v Local No 663, United Rubber, Cork, Linoleum and Plastic Workers of America, 88-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8134 (Wisc, 18 Nov 1987)

Gunsalus v Celotex Corp, 674 F Supp 1149; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 11724; 5 UCCRS2d 1389 (D ED Pa, 23 Nov 1987)

Boreali v Axelrod, Comm'r, NY St Dept of Health, 71 NY 2d 1; 523 NYS2d 464; 517 NE2d 1350; 2 IER Cases (BNA) 1213; 108 LC (CCH) § 55850 (25 Nov 1987). SCB: 130 App Div 2d 107; 518 NYS 2d 440 (verifying, pp 6-8, that second-hand smoke is dangerous)

Lennox Industries, Inc v IUUAAAI Workers of America, Local 893, 88-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8083; 89 Lab Arb (BNA) 1065 (4 Dec 1987) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Liggett Group, Inc v Cipollone, 484 US 976; 108 S Ct 487; 98 L Ed 2d 485 (7 Dec 1987). SCB: 822 F2d 335; 479 US 1043; 107 S Ct 907; 93 L Ed 2d 857; 593 F Supp 1146; 106 FRD 573; 644 F Supp 283; 785 F2d 1108; 789 F2d 181; 802 F2d 658; 649 F Supp 664

Fitch v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 675 F Supp 132 (SD NY, 16 Dec 1987) (employee discharge case)

Keating v Philip Morris Inc, 417 NW2d 132 (Minn App, 22 Dec 1987) (business practices anti-trust case)

Herlihy v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 11852 (DC Mass, 1988) (dangerous tobacco case describing when it is "bad")

Brisboy v Fibreboard Corp, 429 Mich 540; 418 NW2d 650 (25 Jan 1988). SCB: 148 Mich App 298; 384 NW2d 39

Dewey v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 109 NJ 201; 536 A2d 243 (1 Feb 1988)

Roofeh v Roofeh, 138 Misc 2d 889; 525 NYS2d 765 (22 Feb 1988) (custody case)

Des Moines Register and Tribune Co v Des Moines Typographical Union No 118, 88-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8154; 90 Lab Arb (BNA) 777 (5 Feb 1988) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable)

Miller v Brown and Williamson Tobacco Co, 679 F Supp 485 (D ED Pa, 10 Feb 1988)

Carroll v Tennessee Valley Authority, 697 F Supp 508; 3 IER Cases (BNA) 149; 3.4 TPLR 2.89 (D DC, 3 March 1988) (one of a number of Tennessee cases)

Copeland v Philadelphia Police Dept, 840 F2d 1139 (7 March 1988) (for discharge purposes, drug use is not a qualifying handicap)

Pizzitola v Pizzitola, 748 SW2d 568 (Tex App, 31 March 1988) (custody case)

CBS, Inc and Jacobson v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 485 US 993; 108 S Ct 1302; 99 L Ed 2d 512 (4 April 1988). SCB: 644 F Supp 1240; 713 F2d 262; 644 F Supp 1240; 827 F2d 1119 (tobacco taboo case)

Gianitsis v American Brands, Inc, 685 F Supp 853 (D NH, 4 April 1988)

Matter of Mack v County of Rockland, 71 NY2d 1008; 530 NYS2d 98; 525 NE2d 744 (22 April 1988). SCB: 128 AD2d 922

Forster v RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co I, 423 NW2d 691 (Minn App, 3 May 1988)

Michigan Bell Telephone Co v Communications Workers of America, 90 Lab Arb (BNA) 1186 (3 May 1988)

Kotler v American Tobacco Co, 685 F Supp 15 (D Mass, 21 and 25 May 1988)

Dewey v RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co, 225 NJ Super 375; 542 A2d 919 (23 May 1988)

Mutual Benefit Life Insurance Co v JMR Electronics Corp, 848 F2d 30 (CA 2, 25 May 1988). SCB: Case No. 561/87 (SD NY, Sup Ct, Nassau County, 22 Feb 1988) ("key man" life insurance policy voided for having lied about smoking history)

Mack v County of Rockland, 71 NY2d 1008; 530 NYS2d 98; 525 NE2d 744 (26 May 1988). SCB: 128 App Div 2d 922; 512 NYS 2d 732

Opinions of Attorney General 1987-1988, No. 6519, pp 327-330; 1988 Mich Register 80 (31 May 1988) (racetrack grandstand case)

Reeves v Reeves, (Circuit Court, Ky, June 1988) (divorce case)

Roysdon v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 849 F2d 230 (CA 6, 14 June 1988). SCB: 623 F Supp 1189

Besser Co v United Steelworkers of America, Local 209, 89-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8150 (Mich, 23 June 1988)

McCarthy v State of Washington Dept of Social and Health Services, 110 Wash 2d 812; 759 P2d 351; 1988 OSH (CCH) ¶ 28,254; 3 IER Cases (BNA) Cas 710; 13 OSHC (BNA) 1811; (30 June 1988). SCB: 46 Wn App 125

Ricci v American Airlines, 226 NJ Super 377; 544 A2d 428 (14 July 1988)

Dayton Newspapers v News Employees Ass'n, 91 LA (BNA) 201 (Ohio, 20 July 1988) (on-job smoking ban case)

J. R. Simplot Co, Minerals and Chemicals Div v Oil, Chemical & Atomic Workers International, Local 2-632, 91 Lab Arb (BNA) 375 (20 July 1988)

Miller v Brown and Williamson Tobacco Corp, 856 F2d 184 (CA 3, 26 July 1988). SCB: 679 F Supp 485

Independent Association of Publisher's Employees, Inc v Dow Jones & Co, Inc, 89-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8192 (NY, 16 Aug 1988)

Semowich v RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co, 86-CV-118, US Dist LEXIS 9102 (D ND NY, 17 Aug 1988)

Avery v Powell, 695 F Supp 632 (D NH, 29 Aug 1988) (smoke-free prison case)

Gady v Dep't of Navy, 38 MSPR 118 (7 Sep 1988)

Public Citizen v Liggett Group, Inc, 858 F2d 775; 15 Media Law Rev 2129; 12 FR Serv 3d 1099 (CA 1, Mass, 28 Sep 1988) (anti-censorship case)

Organization of Vehicle Sales Counselors v Winner Ford, 89-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8234 (Penn, 28 Sep 1988)

Rogers v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 761 SW 2d 788; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12003 (Tex App, 6 Oct 1988) (dangerous tobacco case re death of mother)

O'Neill v Metropolitan Transit Authority, WL 111529, 143 App Div 2d 739; 533 NYS2d 450 (11 Oct 1988) (railroad passenger smoking ban case)

Citizens Bank v Gregory's Warehouse, Inc, 297 SC 151; 375 SE2d 316 (SC App, 24 Oct 1988) (identification issue)

Acorn Building Components, Inc v Local 2194, Int'l Union, UAW, 89-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8243 (Mich, 15 Nov 1988)

People v John Wayne Gacy, 125 Ill 2d 117; 125 Ill Dec 770; 530 NE2d 1340 (5 Dec 1988) (post-conviction issues re convicted smoker murderer of 33 boys and men). SCB: 103 Ill 2d 1; 82 Ill Dec 391; 468 NE2d 1171

McCoy v California State University Fullerton, 4.5 TPLR 2.75 (Cal App, 1989)

In re Honeywell Inc v Int'l Ass'n of Machinists and Aerospace Workers, 92 Lab Arb (BNA) 181 (3 Jan 1989) (employer smoking ban case)

Marsee v United States Tobacco Co, 866 F2d 319; CCF Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12023 (CA 10, Okla, 10 Jan 1989). SCB: 639 F Supp 466; 20 Fed Rules Evid Serv 1245 (re toxic tobacco, issue of tobacco-induced cancer, specifically snuff)

Liggett Group, Inc v Public Citizen, 488 US 1030; 109 S Ct 838; 102 L Ed 2d 970 (17 Jan 1989). SCB: 858 F2d 775; 12 FR Serv 3d 1099

Bundy v Dugger, 488 US 1036; 109 S Ct 887; 102 L Ed 2d 1009 (23 Jan 1989) (smoker crime case)

Mt. Sinai School of Medicine v American Tobacco Co, Philip Morris, and , 866 F2d 552 (CA 2, NY, 23 Jan 1989) (Med School objection to tobacco companies' action, subpoena of its data)

Central Telephone Co of Nevada v IBEW, Local 396, 89-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8235 (Calif, 21 Feb 1989)

American Tobacco Co v Superior Court, 208 Cal App 3d 480; 255 Cal Rptr 280; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12120 (6 Feb and 8 March 1989) (dangerous tobacco case revealing of company business practices)

Badeaux v Badeaux, 541 So 2d 301 (La App, 15 March 1989) (custody case)

Stove, Furnace and Allied Appliance Workers Int'l v Fedders Air Cponditioning USA, 90-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8089 (Mo, 22 March 1989)

Evans v United Life and Accident Insurance Co, 871 F2d 466 (CA 4, Va, 23 March 1989)

Gorman v Moody, 710 F Supp 1256 (D ND Ind, 13 April 1989)

Forster v RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co II, 437 NW2d 655 (Minn, 14 April 1989). SCB: 423 NW2d 691

Wyandot Inc, Jeffersonville Div v United Food and Commercial Workers Int'l Union, 92 Lab Arb (BNA) 457 (14 April 1989)

Reysack v State 440 NW2d 392 (Iowa, 17 May 1989) (smoke-free prison case)

Eskenazi v Merit Systems, Inc, No 87-338255 CK (MI, Oakland Cty Circ Ct, 18 May 1989)

Gacy v Illinois, 490 US 1085; 109 S Ct 2111; 74 L Ed 671 (22 May 1989). SCB: 125 Ill 2d 117; 125 Ill Dec 770; 530 NE2d 1340 (smoker criminal)

Pennington v RJ Reynolds & American Tobacco Co/Vistron Corp, 876 F2d 414 (CA 5, La, 28 June 1989)

Thomas J. Kline, Inc v Lorillard, Inc, 878 F2d 791 (CA 4, Md, 30 June 1989). SCB: 674 F Supp 183 (business practices case)

Potter v Potter, Lawyer's Weekly No. MA-2953, 3 Mich Law Weekly 1468 (1989) (TTS harm-to-child-custody case)

Booker v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co., Inc., 879 F2d 1304 (CA 6, Mich., 3 July 1989) (employee discrimination case)

Philip Morris v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 716 F Supp 1479 (CIT, 6 July 1989) (tax case, issue of import classification)

Wilson v Lynaugh, 878 F2d 846 (CA 5, 2 Aug 1989)

Morrow v Morrow, 1989 Ohio App LEXIS 3218; 18 OLA 235; 1989 WL 94805 (11 Aug 1989) (TTS harm-to-child case)

Dept of Health and Human Services, Indian Health Service, Oklahoma City v Fed. Labor Relations Authority, 280 US App DC 289; 885 F2d 911; 1990 CCH § 29,167 (15 Sep 1989)

Matter of Johannesen v New York City Dep't of Housing Preservation and Development, 154 App Div 2d 753; 546 NYS2d 40 (12 Oct 1989)

Oklahoma Tax Comm'n v Potawatomi Tribe, 888 F2d 1303 (3 Nov 1989) (tax case, states can't tax Indian cigarette sales)

O'Neill v Metropolitan Transit Authority, 74 NY2d 909; 549 NYS2d 957; 549 NE2d 148 (16 Nov 1989). SCB: WL 111529, 143 App Div 2d 739; 533 NYS2d 450

Wilk v Wilk, 781 SW2d 217 (Mo App, 5 Dec 1989) (custody case)

Doughty v Board of County Com'rs for County of Weld, State of Colorado, 731 F Supp 423, 424; 1989 WL 182545 (D Col, 5 June 1989) (criminals are disproportionately smokers)

Wilson v Lynaugh, 493 US 969; 110 S Ct 417; 107 L Ed 2d 382 (1989). SCB: 878 F2d 846

King v Bangor Federal Credit Union, 53 EPD (CCH) ¶ 39,813; 57 FEP (BNA) 1618; 568 A2d 507 (29 Dec 1989)

Beeson v Johnson, 894 F2d 401 (CA 4, 2 Jan 1990). SCB: 668 F Supp 498

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 893 F2d 541; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12329; 10 UCCRS2d 625 (CA 3, NJ, 5 Jan 1990). SCB: 693 F Supp 208

Fagan v Axelrod, Comm'r, NY St Dept of Health, 146 Misc 2d 286; 550 NYS 2d 552; 1990 OSHD (CCH) § 28924 (10 Jan 1990) (smoking ban case verifying, p 557, that second-hand smoke is dangerous. The decision is "rejecting the argument that a state statute regulating tobacco smoking in public areas discriminated against members of a subordinate class of smokers on the basis of nicotine addiction," says "There Is No Constitutional Right to Smoke" (Public Health Law & Policy Technical Assistance Legal Center, February 2004 revised April 2005).)

Kotler v American Tobacco Co, 731 F Supp 50 (D Mass, 12 Jan 1990). SCB: 685 F Supp 15

Dept of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Indian Health Service, Rapid City, South Dakota, 37 FLRA No. 972 (1990)

Flxible Corp v United Steelworkers of America, 93 LA (BNA) 255 (Ohio, 18 Jan 1990)

Caldwell v Quinlan, 729 F Supp 4 (D DC, 25 Jan 1990) (requesting pure air by regulation)

ATE Fixture Fab v Wagner, 559 So 2d 635; 5.3 TPLR 2.110 (Fla App, 25 Jan 1990) (worker compensation case)

Curwood Inc v Graphics Communication Union No. 418-C, 91-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8223 (Ill, 8 Feb 1990)

Medina-Munoz v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 896 F3d 5 (CA 1, PR, 15 Feb 1990) (employee age discrimination case)

Thomas J. Kline, Inc v Lorillard, Inc, 493 US 1073; 110 S Ct 1120; 107 L Ed 2d 1027 (20 Feb 1990). SCB: 674 F Supp 183; 878 F2d 791 SCB (business practices case)

Bishop v Philip Morris, USA, 771 F Supp 188 (WD Ky, 22 Feb 1990) (employee discharge case)

City Vending of Muskogee v Oklahoma Tax Commission, 898 F2d 122 (CA 10, Oklahoma, 14 March 1990)

American Tobacco Co v Wilson, 898 F2d 155 (CA 6, SD Ohio, 15 March 1990)

Philip Morris, Inc v Poynter, 786 SW2d 124 (Ky App, 23 March 1990) (worker compensation case)

Basler Electric Co v Local 840, Int'l Union of EESM and F Workers, AFL-CIO 90-2 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8354 (Ill, 20 April 1990)

Kufahl v Wisconsin Bell, Inc, Claim 88-000676; 6.2 TPLR 8.23 (Wis Dep't of Industry, Labor and Human Relations, 21 May 1990) (worker compensation case)

Grass v Sargent, 903 F2d 1206 (CA 8, 29 May 1990) (smoke-free prison case)

Philip Morris v Commissioner of Internal Revenue, 907 F2d 158 (CA Fed, 13 June 1990). SCB: 716 F Supp 1479 (tax case, issue of import classification)

Elliott v Board of Weld County Com'rs, 796 P2d 71 (Colo App, 5 July 1990) (smoke-free prison case)

De Beni Souza v Kallweit, 16 Fam L Rep (BNA) 1496 (Cal Super Ct, 12 July 1990) (one of a number of harm-to-child cases, re TTS violating right to pure air)

Lauren Hall v Veterans' Admin, Civ Action No. 88-71102 (D ED Mich, 12 July 1990) (employee request for smokefree workplace). SCB: EEOC No. 054-086-X0097

Hite v RJ Reynolds Tobacco Co, 396 Pa Super 82; 578 A2d 417 (12 July 1990)

Kyte v Philip Morris, Inc, 408 Mass 162; 556 NE2d 1025; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12607; 36 ALR5th 541, 570 (25 July 1990) (business practices case alleging pattern of unlawful sales to minors)

Dewey v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 121 NJ 69; 577 A2d 1239; CCF Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12548 (26 July 1990). SCB: 225 NJ Super 375; 542 A2d 919; 216 NJ Super 347; 523 A2d 712

Baker v Liggett Group, Inc, 132 FRD 123 (D Mass, 31 July 1990)

Rogers v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 557 NE2d 1045; CCF Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12572 (Ind App, 31 July 1990)

PPG Industries, Inc v Aluminum, Brick and Glass Workers Int'l Union, Local No. 112 91-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8086 (Penn, 15 Aug 1990)

MacDonald v Michigan State of Bureaucracy, 911 F2d 733 (CA 6, WD Mich, 23 Aug 1990) (mem, smoker-on-job case)

Brooke Group Ltd v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 748 F Supp 344 (MD NC, 27 Aug 1990) (allegation of business practices conspiracy to undercut prices reflecting predatory practices)

Comeaux v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co, 915 F2d 1264 (CA 9, Calif, 26 Sep 1990) (business practices case, by a job applicant, alleging wrongful failure to hire)

Lamb v Philip Morris, Inc, 915 F2d 1024 (CA 6, Ky, 28 Sep 1990) (domestic growers vs tobacco importers case)

West v Wright, 747 F Supp 329 (D ED Va, 28 Sep 1990)

City Vending of Muskogee v Oklahoma Tax Commission, 498 US 823; 111 S Ct 75; 112 L Ed 2d 48 (1 Oct 1990). SCB: 898 F2d 122

Bishop v Philip Morris, USA, 915 F2d 1570 (CA 6, Ky, 2 Oct 1990). SCB: 771 F Supp 188 (employee discharge case)

Clemmons v Bohannon, 918 F2d 858 (CA 10, 9 Oct 1990)

Landes, 92-1 Lab Arb Awards (CCH) § 8125 (24 Oct 1990)

Milhelm Attea & Bros v Dept of Taxation and Finance of New York, 164 App Div 2d 300, 564 NYS2d 491 (6 Dec 1990) (Indian reservation, cigarette tax case)

Gilboy v American Tobacco Co, 572 So 2d 289 (La App, 14 Nov 1990)

Dept of Health and Human Services Family Support Admin v Fed. Labor Relations Authority, 287 US App DC 114; 920 F2d 45 (30 Nov 1990)

Tokheim Corp v United Automobile Workers, Local 1539, 96 Lab Arb (BNA) 122 (4 Dec 1990)

Milhelm Attea & Bros v Dept of Taxation and Finance of New York, 164 App Div 2d 300; 564 NYS2d 491 (6 Dec 1990) (tax case)

Dept of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Indian Health Service, Indian Hospital, Rapid City, South Dakota, 38 FLRA No. 71 (7 Dec 1990)

Dept of Health and Human Services, Public Health Service, Indian Health Service, Indian Hospital, Rapid City, South Dakota, 38 FLRA No. 72 (7 Dec 1990)

Kufahl v Wisconsin Bell, Inc, Claim 88-000676 (Wis Dep't of Industry, Labor and Human Relations, 11 Dec 1990)

Avtar Ubhi v Marina's Bar and Grill WCAB No. SF 341-691 (WCAB, 15 Dec 1990) (worker comp case)

Kotler v American Tobacco Co, 926 F2d 1217 (CA 1, Mass, 19 Dec 1990). SCB: 685 F Supp 15; 731 F Supp 50

Andren v White-Rodgers Co, 465 NW2d 102 (Minn App, 22 Jan 1991) (a cigarette fire case, involving smoking around propane gas; as a matter of law, the smell of gas evidences obvious danger, obviating jury decision))

County of Fresno v Fair Employment and Housing Commission of the State of California, 226 Cal App 3d 1541; 277 Cal Rptr 557; 91 CDOS 754; 91 Daily Journal DAR 1112 (23 Jan 1991) reh den 91 CDOS 1365; 91 Daily Journal DAR 1112

Caldwell v Quinlan, US App DC; 923 F2d 200 (mem, 25 Jan 1991) (mem, re segregating smoking/nonsmoking inmates). SCB: 729 F Supp 4

Gilboy v American Tobacco Co, 573 So 2d 1128 (La, 31 Jan 1991). SCB: 572 So 2d 289

McKinney v Anderson, 924 F2d 1500, 1507 n 21 (CA 9, 1 Feb 1991) (criminals are 90% smokers)

Lamb v Philip Morris, Inc, 498 US 1086; 111 S Ct 961; 112 L Ed 2d 1048 (19 Feb 1991). SCB: 915 F2d 1024

McSorley v Philip Morris, Inc, 170 App Div 2d 440; 565 NYS2d 537 (4 Feb 1991) (allegation of practice of failure to warn of foreseeable harm to unborn fetus)

Carlisle v Philip Morris, Inc, 805 SW2d 498 (Tex App, 6 Feb 1991)

Kellogg v Mayfield, 72 Ohio App 3d 490; 595 NE2d 465 (11 Feb 1991)

Witco Corp v Oil, Chemical & Atomic Workers Intl Union, Local 6-662, 96 Lab Arb (BNA) 499 (25 Feb 1991) (on-job smoking ban is non-negotiable, as management has a right to promulgate reasonable work rules so as to "provide for maximum safety," and no-smoking rule is reasonably related to legitimate management objectives)

Oklahoma Tax Comm'n v Potawatomi Tribe, 498 US 505 (26 Feb 1991). SCB: 888 F2d 1303 (tax case)

Witte v Dep't of Rehabilitative Services, 88 WC 44629 (Illinois, 19 March 1991) (worker compensation case)

Cipollone v Liggett Group, Inc, 499 US 935; 111 S Ct 1386; 113 L Ed 2d 443 (25 March 1991). SCB: 893 F2d 541; 693 F Supp 208

Mitchell v Mitchell, Appeal No. 01-A-01-9012-CV-00442, Tenn App LEXIS 337; 1991 WL 63674 (26 April 1991) (custody case)

McSorley v Philip Morris, Inc, 77 NY2d 990; 571 NYS2d 915; 575 NE2d 401 (9 May 1991). SCB: 170 App Div 2d 440; 565 NYS2d 537 (allegation of practice of failure to warn of foreseeable harm to unborn fetus)

VME America, Inc v Auto Workers Local 70, 97 Lab Arb (BNA) 137 (22 May 1991)

Kotler v American Tobacco Co, 926 F2d 147 (CA 1, Mass, 1991). SCB: 685 F Supp 15; 731 F Supp 50

City of Hartford v AFSCME Council, Local 1716, 97 Lab Arb (BNA) 768 (3 June 1991)

Best Lock Corp v Review Bd of Indiana Dep't of Employment and Training Services, Ind App, 572 NE2d 520 (4 June 1991)

Bryant/Dept of Social Services v Wakely, Appeal No. 131708 (Mich App, 13 June 1991) (custody case)

Gilboy v American Tobacco Co, 582 So 2d 1263; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 12854; 36 ALR 5th 899 (La, 21 June 1991)

Kellogg v Mayfield, 61 Ohio St 3d 1421; 574 NE2d 1092 (24 July 1991). SCB: 72 Ohio App 3d 490; 595 NE2d 465

Steading v Thompson, 941 F2d 498 (CA 7, 19 Aug 1991)

US v Benson, 941 F2d 598 (CA 7, ND Illinois, 27 Aug 1991) (cigarette tax case and insurance allegations)

W-I Forest Products Co, 138 LRRM 1089; 199 NLRB Dec (CCH) ¶ 16,869; 304 NLRB 957 (30 Aug 1991)

Philip Morris Capital Corp v Bering Trader, Inc, 944 F2d 500 (CA 9, 10 Sep 1991)

Smith v Lorillard, Inc, 945 F2d 745 (CA 4, NC, 17 Sep 1991) (garnishment order case)

Sanchez v Philip Morris, Inc, 774 F Supp 626 (WD Okla, 24 Sep 1991) (Hispanic employee discrimination case; received award of 36 months front pay)

Helling v McKinney, 502 US 903; 112 S Ct 291; 116 L Ed 2d 236 (15 Oct 1991). SCB: 924 F2d 1500

Philip Morris Capital Corp v Century Power Corp, 778 F Supp 141 (SD NY, 25 Oct 1991) (trade case, re securities fraud)

Lauren Hall v Veterans' Administration, 946 F2d 895 (CA 6, Mich, 28 Oct 1991). SCB: Civ Action No. 88-71102; EEOC No. 054-086-X0097

Bradley v Philip Morris, Inc, 194 Mich App 44; 486 NW2d 48 (29 Oct 1991) (business practices case)

Ierardi v Lorillard, Inc, Case No. 91-7049 (D ED Penn, Nov 1991)

Bena v Massachusetts Turnpike Authority, No. 03922088, 7.1 TPLR 8.1 (Mass Dept of Industrial Accidents, 5 Dec 1991) (worker compensation case)

Dept of Taxation & Fin. v Milhelm Attea & Bros, 502 US 1053; 112 S Ct 926; 117 L Ed 2d 99 (21 Jan 1992) SCB: 164 App Div 2d 300, 564 NYS2d 491 (Indian reservation cigarette tax case)

Helling v McKinney, 502 US 1070; 112 S Ct 963; 117 L Ed 2d 129 (27 Jan 1992). SCB: 924 F2d 1500

US v Benson, 957 F2d 301 (CA 7, ND Illinois, 14 Feb 1992) (cigarette tax case and insurance allegations). SCB: 941 F2d 598

Eastern Airlines, Inc and GAB v Crittenden and Travelers Ins Co, 17 Fla W D 724; 596 So 2d 112 (11 March 1992) (worker compensation case)

Mangini v R J Reynolds Tobacco Co, 793 F Supp 925 (ND Cal, 12 March 1992) (injunction case concerning "Joe Camel" advertising re children; a "private attorney general" case on advertising as an unfair/unlawful business practice; remand to state courts)

Riddle v Ampex Corp, 839 P2d 489; 7 IER Cases (BNA) 525 (19 March 1992) (worker compensation case)

Caron v Silvia, 32 Mass App Ct 271; 588 NE2d 711; 7 IER Cases (BNA) 522 (23 March 1992)

McKinney v Anderson, 959 F2d 853 (CA 9, Nev, 27 March 1992)

Vatore et al v Comm'r of Consumer Affairs of City of NY, et al, 154 Misc 2d 149; 584 NYS 2d 728 (30 March 1992) (denying pre-emption of cigarette vending machine ban)

Philip Morris Capital Corp v Century Power Corp, 788 F Supp 794 (SD NY, 6 April 1992). SCB: 778 F Supp 141 (trade case, re securities fraud)

Quinn, Gent, Buseck & Leemhuis, Inc v Unemployment Comp Bd of Review, 147 Pa Cmnwlth 141; 606 A2d 1300; 7.3 TPLR 2.89; 431 CD 1990 (8 April 1992)

Milhelm Attea & Bros v Dept of Taxation and Finance of New York, 181 App Div 2d 210, 585 NYS (1992). SCB: 164 App Div 2d 300, 564 NYS2d 491 (Indian reservation cigarette tax case)

Bean v BIC Corp, 597 So 2d 1350; CCH Prod Liab Rep 16 § 13163; 14 ALR 5th 984 (17 April 1992) (child-resistant cigarette lighter fire duty case)

Opinions of Attorney General 1991-1992, No. 6719; 1992 Michigan Register 177 (4 May 1992) (issue of nonsmoker only apartment complex)

Brooke Group Ltd v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 964 F2d 335 (CA 4, NC, 11 May 1992) (allegation of conspiracy to undercut prices reflecting predatory practices). SCB: 748 F Supp 344

In re Manguno, 961 F2d 533; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 13185; 22 FR Serv 3d 993 (CA 5, La, 26 May 1992) (dangerous tobacco case)

Hall v Turnage, 504 US 958; 112 S Ct 2310; 119 L Ed 2d 231 (1 June 1992). SCB: 946 F2d 895; Civ Action No. 88-71102; EEOC No. 054-086-X0097

Cipollone v Liggett Group, 505 US 504; 112 S Ct 2608; 120 L Ed 2d 407 (24 June 1992). SCB: 893 F2d 541; 693 F Supp 208

Operation Badlaw v Licking County Gen. Health Dist. Bd of Health, 866 F Supp 1059 (SD Ohio, 26 June 1992) (Context)

Kotler v American Tobacco Co, 505 US 1215; 112 S Ct 3019; 120 L Ed 2d 891 (29 June 1992). SCB: 685 F Supp 15; 731 F Supp 50; 926 F2d 147

Bradley v Philip Morris, Inc, 440 Mich 870; 486 NW2d 737 (15 July 1992). SCB: 194 Mich App 44; 486 NW2d 48

ADM/Growmark River Systems, Inc v Int'l Longshoremen's Ass'n, Local 1765, 99 Lab Arb (BNA) 1033 (21 Aug 1992) (smoker discharge case)

Stanfield v Hay, 849 SW2d 551 (Ky App, 28 Aug and 13 Nov 1992) (smoke-free prison case)

Koch Refining Co v Oil, Chemical & Atomic Workers Intl Union, Local 6-662, 99 Lab Arb (BNA) 733 (31 Aug 1992) (on-job smoking ban is not negotiable as it promotes a healthier workforce and protects against fires; the matter is one of rules, not a negotiable working condition)

In re Marriage of Cynthia K. Black, 837 P2d 407 (Montana, 1 Sep 1992) (custody case; order no smoking around child)

Palmer v Del Webb's High Sierra, 108 Nev 673; 838 P2d 435; 8.1 TPLR 2.174 (1 Sep 1992) (worker comp case, nonsmoker got lung cancer from disproportionate number of smokers gambling pursuant to their acalculia)

Bakery, Confectionary and Tobacco Workers Local Union No. 362-T, AFL-CIO v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 971 F2d 652 (CA 11, Georgia, 3 Sep 1992) (employee arbitration case, re health plan issues)

Hunt v Reynolds, 974 F2d 734 (CA 6, 10 Sep 1992) (8th amendment case)

Peck v Dept of Human Rights, et al., 234 Ill App 3d 334; 175 Ill Dec 456; 600 NE2d 79 (10 Sep 1992)

Charles Kueper v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, Tobacco Institute, et al. (DFP C1, 19 Nov 1992)

Kotler v American Tobacco Co, 981 F2d 7, 141 ALR Fed 737 (CA 1, Mass, 4 Dec 1992). SCB: 685 F Supp 15; 731 F Supp 50; 926 F2d 1217; 506 US 1215; 112 S Ct 3019; 120 LEd2d 891

Tatum v Philip Morris, Inc, 809 F Supp 1452 (WD Oklahoma, 10 Dec 1992) (employee gender discrimination case)

Bravo Vending v City of Rancho Mirage, 11 Cal App 4th 585; 14 Cal Rep 2d 209 (7 December 1992)

Washington v Tinsley, 809 F Supp 504 (SD Texas, 16 December 1992) (Details, Smoking Ban Constitutionality)

Brooke Group Ltd. v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 506 US 984; 113 S Ct 490; 121 L Ed 2d 428 (1993)

Tamara Helm v Mark Helm, 1993 Tennessee App LEXIS 109; 1993 WL 21983 (3 Feb 1993) (custody case)

Marie Kuhn v Philip Morris U.S.A., Inc, 814 F Supp 450 (ED, Penn, 2 March 1993) (employee sex discrimination case)

Butler v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 815 F Supp 982 (SD Miss, 18 March 1993)

Vatore et al v Comm'r of Consumer Affairs of City of NY, et al, 192 App Div 2d 520; 596 NYS 2d 113 (5 April 1993). SCB: 154 Misc 2d 149; 584 NYS 2d 728 (upholding pre-emption of cigarette vending machine ban)

Bradley v Philip Morris, Inc, 199 Mich App 194; 501 NW2d 246 (5 April 1993). SCB: 440 Mich 870; 486 NW2d 737

Gacy v Welborn, 1992 WL 211018 aff'd 994 F2d 305 (CA 7, Ill, 12 April 1993) (habeas corpus issues re convicted smoker murderer)

Operation Badlaw v Licking County Gen. Health Dist. Bd of Health, 991 F2d 796; US App LEXIS 8685, § 3[b] (CA 6, 13 April 1993). SCB: 866 F Supp 1059 (Context)

Century Products Co v Internat'l Ass'n of Machinists, District No. 28, 101 LA (BNA) 1 (16 April 1993) (smoker discharge case)

Hinman v Yakima School District No. 7, 3 AD 1465; 69 Wash App 445; 850 P2d 536 (20 April 1993)

Sanchez v Philip Morris, Inc, 992 F2d 244 (CA 10, Oklahoma, 20 April 1993) (Hispanic employee discrimination case). SCB: 774 F Supp 626

Shaw v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 818 F Supp 1539 (MD Fla, 20 April 1993) (employee allegations including of defamation)

Cowgill v Cowgill, 1993 Delaware Family Ct LEXIS 40; 1993 WL 331912 (Del Family Ct, 19 May 1993) (custody case)

Bravo Vending v City of Rancho Mirage, 16 Cal App 4th 383; 20 Cal Rptr 2d 164 (8 June 1993). SCB: 11 Cal App 4th 585; 14 Cal Rep 2d 209 (cigarette vending machine ban upheld, observing "sale of cigarettes to minors has been a criminal offense in this state since at least 1892")

McKinney v Anderson, 509 US 25; 113 S Ct 2475; 125 L Ed 2d 22 (18 June 1993). SCB: 924 F2d 1500

Brooke Group Ltd v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 509 US 209; 113 S Ct 2578; 125 L Ed 2d 168; 1994 US LEXIS 4245 (21 June 1993) (allegation of conspiracy to undercut prices reflecting predatory practices). SCB: 964 F2d 335

Akron Brass Co v Machinists Lodge 1581, 101 LA (BNA) 289 (23 June 1993) (on-job smoking ban case)

Vango Media v City of New York, 829 F Supp 572 (SD NY, 1 July 1993)

C.I.C. Corp v. Township of East Brunswick, 266 N J Super 1; 628 A2d 753 (2 July 1993) (cigarette vending machine ban upheld)

Take Five Vending, Ltd., et al v Town of Provincetown, 415 Mass 741; 615 NE2d 576 (8 July 1993) (cigarette vending machine ban upheld, as there are no property rights in a license)

Mangini v R J Reynolds Tobacco Co, 21 Cal Rptr 2d 232 (Cal App 1st, 14 July 1993) (injunction case concerning "Joe Camel" advertising re children). SCB: 793 F Supp 925

Richardson v Hennly, 209 Ga App 868; 434 SE2d 772 (15 July 1993) (Context)

Brooke Group Ltd. v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 509 US 940; 114 S Ct 13; 125 L Ed 2d 765; 1994 US LEXIS 4692 (9 Aug 1993). SCB: 509 US 209; 113 S Ct 2578; 125 L Ed 2d 168

Smith v R. J. Reynolds & American Tobacco Co, 267 NJ Super 62; 630 A2d 820 (9 Aug 1993)

YHA, Inc v NLRB, 2 F3d 168; 143 LRRM 3057; 125 Lab Cas (CCH) ¶ 10,802 (11 Aug 1993)

Roos v Ally and Gargano, Inc, 1993 Conn Super LEXIS 2142 (Stamford Super Ct, 19 Aug 1993)

Helling v McKinney, 5 F3d 365 (CA 9, Nevada, 16 September 1993) (remanding Supreme Court decision to District Court)

Allied Vending, Inc v City of Bowie, 332 Md 279; 631 A2d 77 (17 September 1993) (pre-emption of ban of cigarette vending machines accessible to minors)

Paugh v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 834 F Supp 228 (ND Ohio, 29 Sep 1993) (widow product liability case alleging company fraud)

Milhelm Attea & Bros v Dept of Taxation and Finance of New York, 81 NY2d 417; 599 NYS2d 510 ; 615 NE2d 994(10 June 1993). SCB: 164 App Div 2d 300, 564 NYS2d 491; 181 App Div 2d 210, 585 NYS (Indian reservation cigarette tax case)

Anderson v Newman, 190 W Va 577; 439 SE2d 442, 445 (21 Sep 1993) (child harmed-by-parent-smoker case)

Reynolds v Bucks, 833 F Supp 518 (ED Pa, 1 Oct 1993) (smoke-free prison case)

Gacy v Welborn, 510 US 899; 114 S Ct 269; 126 L Ed 2d 220 (3 Oct 1993). SCB: 994 F2d 305 (smoker criminal)

Moore v Philip Morris Companies, Inc, 8 F3d 335 (CA 6, Ky, 13 Oct 1993) (employee's widow pension case)

Pechan v DynaPro Inc, 251 Ill App 3d 1072; 190 Ill Dec 698; 622 NE2d 108; 8 IER Cases (BNA) Cas 1793; 127 CCH LC § 57582; 1993 WL 418073; 8.4 TPLR 2.339 (19 Oct 1993)

Brooke Group Ltd. v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 509 US 940; 114 S Ct 13; 125 L Ed 2d 765 (1993)

Goodman v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 891 F Supp 505 (Arizona, 7 Dec 1993) (employee discharge case)

In re Marriage of Brian T. Diddens, 255 Ill App 3d 850; 192 Ill Dec 878; 625 NE2d 1033 (22 Dec 1993) custody case)

Gupton v Commonwealth of Virginia et al., 14 F3d 203; 63 EPD (CCH) ¶ 42,768 (CA 4, Va, 13 Jan 1994) (on-job pure air case)

Leichtman v WLJ Jacor Communications, 92 Ohio App 3d 232; 634 NE2d 697; 46 ALR5th 939; 9.1 TPLR 2.17 (26 Jan 1994)

Bompane v Enzolabs, Inc, 160 Misc 2d 315; 608 NYS2d 989; 10 IER Cases (BNA) 601 (2 Feb 1994)

Bradley v Philip Morris, Inc, 444 Mich App 644; 513 NW2d 797 (1 March 1994). SCB: 199 Mich App 194; 501 NW2d 246

Crumpton v Philip Morris, U.S.A., 845 F Supp 1421 (D Colo, 4 March 1994) (employee race discrimination case)

Broin v Philip Morris Cos, Inc, 19 Fla L Weekly D588; 641 So 2d 888 (Fla App, 15 March 1994) (class action case re Toxic Tobacco Smoke injury to workers (stewardesses))

Beauchamp v Sullivan, 21 F3d 789 (CA 7, 21 March 1994) (smoke-free prison-housing case)

Dworkin v Paley, 93 Ohio App 3d 383; 638 NE2d 636 (21 March 1994) (smoke-free rental housing case)

Anheuser Busch Inc v Schmoke, Mayor of Baltimore, 855 F Supp 811 (D Md, 28 March 1994) (billboard ban case)

Unger v Unger, 274 N J Super 532; 644 A2d 691 (29 March 1994) (well-reasoned custody case; banned smoking; cited the Shimp precedent as showing the hazard is to those all around)

C.I.C. Corp v. Township of East Brunswick, 135 NJ 121; 638 A2d 812 (31 March 1994). SCB: 266 N J Super 1; 628 A2d 753 (2 July 1993) (cigarette vending machine ban upheld)

Brown v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 852 F Supp 8 (ED La, 13 April 1994) (no alternative design)

Vatore et al v Comm'r of Consumer Affairs of City of NY, et al, 612 NYS 2d 357; 83 NY 2d 645; 634 NE2d 958 (5 May 1994). SCB: 154 Misc 2d 149; 584 NYS 2d 728; 192 App Div 2d 520; 596 NYS 2d 113 (denying pre-emption of cigarette vending machine ban)

Wiggins v Philip Morris, Inc, 853 F Supp 457 (DDC, 13 May 1994) (employee case with issues including alleging boss used drugs)

Wiggins v Philip Morris, Inc, 853 F Supp 458 (DDC, 13 May 1994) (employee case)

Wiggins v Philip Morris, Inc, 853 F Supp 470 (DDC, 13 May 1994) employee case)

Dept of Taxation & Fin. v Milhelm Attea & Bros, 512 US 61; 114 S Ct 2028; 129 L Ed 2d 52 (13 June 1994). SCB: 164 App Div 2d 300, 564 NYS2d 491; 181 App Div 2d 210, 585 NYS; 81 NY2d 417, 615 NE2d 994 (Indian reservation cigarette tax case)

Hennly v Richardson 262 Ga 355; 444 SE2d 317; 1994 Ga LEXIS 463, 94 Fulton County DR 2140; 3 AD Cas 617; 10 BNA EIR Cas 1780 (27 June 1994) recon den 14 July 1994. SCB: 209 Ga App 868; 434 SE2d 772

Mangini v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 7 Cal 4th 1057; 31 Cal Rptr 2d 358; 875 P2d 73 (30 June 1994). SCB: 20 Cal Rptr 2d 232; 793 F Supp 925

Smith v Fruin, et al, 28 F3d 646; 9 IER (BNA) Cases 1202 (CA 7, Ill, 30 June 1994)

Flue-Cured Tobacco Coop. Stabilization Corp v United States EPA, 857 F Supp 1137 (MD NC, 1994)

Lizzio v Lizzio, 162 Misc 2d 701; 618 NYS2d 934 (1 July 1994) (custody case)

Action on Smoking and Health v Dep't of Labor, 307 US App DC 295; 28 F3d 162, 165 (CA DC, 12 July 1994) (due to cigarette hazards, seeking OSHA action to enforce regulation 29 CFR § 1910.1000 re cigarettes' toxic chemicals)

State ex rel Kincaid v Parsons, 191 W Va 608; 447 SE2d 543 (14 July 1994) (smoke-free prison case)

Cookie's Diner v Columbus Bd. of Health, 65 Ohio Misc 2d 65; 640 NE2d 1231 (9 Aug 1994) (Context)

Browne v Russell, 27 Cal App 4th 1116; 33 Cal Rep 2d 29 (25 August 1994) (restaurant smoking ban)

Vango Media v City of New York, 34 F3d 68 (CA 2, NY, 26 Aug 1994). SCB: 829 F Supp 572

Allman v Philip Morris, Inc, 865 F Supp 665 (SD Cal, 22 Sep 1994)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 870 F Supp 1425 (ED La, 22 Sep and 15 Nov 1994) (citing denial of opportunity to respond)

Grinnell v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 883 SW2d 791 (Tex App, 29 Sep 1994) (product liability case)

Gupton v Commonwealth of Virginia et al., 513 US 810; 115 S Ct 59; 130 L Ed 2d 17 (3 Oct 1994). SCB: 14 F3d 203; 63 EPD (CCH) ¶ 42,768 (job smoking case)

Cooley v Cooley, 643 So 2d 408 (La App, 5 Oct 1994) (custody case, change in circumstances needed)

Mary Davies v Philip Morris, U.S.A., 863 F Supp 1430 (D Colo, 17 Oct 1994) (employee sex discrimination case)

Mannell v American Tobacco Co, 871 F Supp 854 (ED Va, 12 Oct 1994)

Shockey v Winfield, 97 Ohio App 3d 409; 646 NE2d 911 (16 Nov 1994) (smoke-free prison case)

RJR Nabisco Corp, et al v Dunn and Wiley, 642 NE2d 538 (Ind App, 17 Nov 1994) (second hand TTS injury case)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Mangini, 513 US 1016; 115 S Ct 577; 130 L Ed 2d 493; 1994 US LEXIS 8361 (28 Nov 1994). SCB: 793 F Supp 925; 21 Cal Rptr 2d 232; 7 Cal 4th 1057; 31 Cal Rptr 2d 358; 875 P2d 73 (injunction case concerning "Joe Camel" advertising re children)

Women Prisoners of District of Columbia Dep't of Corrections v District of Columbia, 877 F Supp 634; 98 Ed Law Rep 681 (D DC, 13 Dec 1994) (smoke-free prison case)

City of North Miami v Kurtz, 625 So 2d 899; 18 FLW D 2210; 8 IER Cases (BNA) 1611 (Fla App, 1995) (regulation on not hiring smokers)

Smith v Fruin, et al, 513 US 1083; 115 S Ct 735; 130 L Ed 2d 638 (9 Jan 1995). SCB: 28 F3d 646; 9 IER (BNA) Cases 1202

In Re Philip Morris Securities Litigation, 872 F Supp 97 (SD NY, 9 Jan 1995)

Jenkins v Secretary of the Army West, 1995 WL 43711 (U.S. E.E.O.C., 20 January 1995) (affirmed Army decision removing Sheranne Jenkins for instances of misconduct which included permitting smoking at week night bingo events in violation of a smoking ban)

Quillen v American Tobacco Co, 874 F Supp 1285 (MD Ala, 25 Jan 1995)

Emery et al v Dream Spirits, Inc, 879 F Supp 640 (D ND Tex, 1 Feb 1995)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 160 FRD 544 (ED La, 17 Feb 1995)

Jarrett v Westchester County Dep't of Health, 166 Misc 2d 777; 638 NYS2d 269 (27 Feb 1995) (smoke-free prison case)

Heck v Reed, 529 NW2d 155; 36 ALR 5th 849 (North Dakota, 28 Feb 1995) (custody case)

Burton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 884 F Supp 1515 (D Kans, 10 March 1995) (a product liability case by a smoker with vascular disease)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 879 F Supp 594 (ED La, 14 March 1995)

Philip Morris, Inc v Star Tobacco Corp, 879 F Supp 379 (SD NY, 21 March 1995) (trade case; trademark infringement case, re trade "dress")

Broin v Philip Morris Cos, Inc, 654 So 2d 919 (Fla, 3 April 1995) (class action case re second-hand smoke injury to workers (stewardesses)) . SCB: 641 So 2d 888

Staron, et al. v McDonald's Corp, et al, 51 F 3d 353 (CA 2, 4 April 1995). SCB: 872 F Supp 1092

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co v CSX Transport, 882 F Supp 511 (ED NC, 5 April 1995) (fire case)

Laura B. v Jeffrey B., 1995 Del Family Ct Lexis 40; 1995 WL 783009 (11 April 1995) (TTS harm-to-child case, condition precedent, no smoking)

Consumers of Ohio v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 52 F3d 325; 1995 WL 234620 (CA 6, 19 April 1995)

City of North Miami v Kurtz, 653 So 2d 1025; ; 66 EPD ¶ 43,537; 63 USLW 2675; 1995 WL 231185; 20 Fla L Weekly S 170; 10 IER Cases (BNA) 865; 10.3 TPLR 2.73 (Fla, 20 April 1995). SCB: 625 So 2d 899; 18 FLW D 2210; 8 IER Cases (BNA) 1611 (on not hiring smokers)

Brown v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 52 F3d 524 (CA 5, La, 5 May 1995)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 162 FRD 112 (ED La, 15 May 1995) (stay pending appeal)

Doss v Dir, Office of Workers' Compensation Programs (OWCP), Case 94-1399 (CA 4, 18 May 1995)

Blakley v Amax Coal Co and Dir, OWCP, 54 F3d 1313 (CA 7, 25 May 1995) (black lung case, smoker 45 years, miner 21 years, claim denied)

Crawford County v Pennsylvania Labor Relations Board, 659 A2d 1078 (26 May 1995) (smoke-free prison case)

United States v Fonseca-Machado, 53 F3d 1242 (CA 11, SD Florida, 7 June 1995) cert den 516 US 925; 116 S Ct 326; 133 L Ed 2d 227 (crime case; air piracy; flight to Cuba using gas and cigarette lighters, deemed flight to avoid prosecution)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 889 F Supp 904 (ED La, 23 June 1995). SCB: 162 FRD 112

Goffman v Gross, Case 94-1738, 59 F3d 668 (CA 7, SD Illinois, 6 July 1995) (smoke-free prison case)

Austin v Lehman, 893 F Supp 448 (ED Pa, 6 July 1995) (smoke-free prison case)

Griesenbeck v American Tobacco Co, 897 F Supp 815 (D NJ, 13 July 1995)

Byrnes v Shalala, Sec'y, HHS, 60 F3d 639 (CA 9, 1995)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 896 F Supp 590 (ED La, 27 July 1995) (tobacco taboo case, censorship request denied)

Warth v Southern Ohio Coal Co and Dir, OWCP, Case 94-2635pv2 (CA 4, Ohio, 31 July 1995) (courts give medical opinion of Congress and rule writers greater weight than examining physician's) (commentary)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Merrell Williams, Henry Waxman, et al, Case No. 94-5171, 314 US App DC 85; 62 F3d 408 (15 Aug 1995) (lawsuit re whistleblower-provided documents to Congress, causing chink in tobacco taboo eventually the coumarin exposé)

Women Prisoners of District of Columbia Dep't of Corrections v District of Columbia, 899 F Supp 634 (D DC, 14 Aug 1995) (smoke-free prison case)

Robertson v Fiore and Hudson County Improvement Authority, 62 F3d 596; 1995 WL 486415 (CA 3, NJ, 16 Aug 1995) (smoker discharge case)

Anheuser Busch Inc v Schmoke, Mayor of Baltimore, 63 F3d 1305 (CA 4, 31 August 1995). SCB: 855 F Supp 811

Collins v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 901 F Supp 1038 (D SC, 14 Sep 1995)

Harmer v Virginia Electric & Power Co, 63 EPD (CCH) ¶ 42,653; 831 F Supp 1300 (D ED Va, 20 Sep 1995)

Dehue Coal Co v Ballard, Case 94-2369 (CA 4, 25 Sep 1995)

U.S. v Baker and Hale, 63 F3d 1478 (CA 9, D Montana, 6 Oct 1995) (contraband cigarettes, smuggling, racketeering (RICO) and money laundering)

United States of America v Benson, 67 F3d 641 (CA 7, ND Illinois, 6 Oct 1995) (cigarette tax case and insurance allegations). SCB: 941 F2d 598; 957 F2d 301

Adams v Philip Morris, Inc, 67 F3d 580 (CA 6, WD Kentucky, 18 Oct 1995) (white male discrimination case, alleging black hired in his stead lacked experience with high speed cigarette machines)

Jones v Owens-Corning Fiberglass, 69 F3d 712 (CA 4, ED NC, 3 Nov 1995) (smoker claim re asbestosis and lung cancer)

Mrs. Binh Chiglo v City of Preston and Mike Sveen, 909 F Supp 675 (D Minn, 13 Nov 1995) (business practices case involving advertising)

Homeyer v Stanley Tulchin Associates, Inc et al., 1995 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 17114 (D ND Ill, ED, 17 Nov 1995)

RJR Nabisco Corp, et al v Dunn and Wiley, 657 NE2d 1220; 1995 Ind LEXIS 172 (5 Dec 1995). SCB: 642 NE2d 538 (second hand TTS injury case)

Philip Morris, Inc v CIR, 71 F3d 1040 (CA 2, 8 Dec 1995) (tax case). SCB: 104 TC 61; 1995 WL 23338

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 908 F Supp 378 (ED La, 18 Dec 1995). SCB: 889 F Supp 904; 162 FRD 112

Robinson v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 909 F Supp 824 (Colorado, 29 Dec 1995)

Penn Advertising v Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, 63 F3d 1318 (CA 4, Md, 31 Dec 1995) (cigarette billboard ban case)

Kurtz v City of North Miami, 516 US 1043; 116 S Ct 701; 133 L Ed 2d 658 (8 Jan 1996). SCB: 625 So 2d 899; 653 So 2d 1025; 10 IER Cases (BNA) 865; 10.3 TPLR 2.73 (smoker job application case)

Edward A. Loetel v James A. Gannon, Case 95-2290 (CA 8, ED Missouri, 10 Jan 1996) (smoke-free prison case, second-hand smoke cruel and unusual punishment case)

Gardner v Hercules, Inc and Standard Industrial Maintenance, Inc, 1996 Va.App. LEXIS 22 (16 Jan 1996)

US v Benson, 74 F3d 152 (CA 7, ND Illinois, 18 Jan 1996) (cigarette tax case and insurance allegations). SCB: 941 F2d 598; 957 F2d 301; 67 F3d 641

Jarrett v Westchester County Dep't of Health, 169 Misc 2d 320; 646 NYS2d 2239 (24 Jan 1996) (smoke-free prison case)

San Leandro Emergency Medical Group v Philip Morris Co, Case 95-7156, 75 F3d 801 (CA 2, SD New York, 25 Jan 1996) (class action, securities fraud, insider trading allegations, related to prime cigarette sales decline due to discount cigarettes, and alleging stockholder rights violation, and citing prior precedent, In Re Philip Morris Securities Litigation, 872 F Supp 97

San Leandro Emergency Medical Group Profit Sharing Plan v Philip Morris Companies, Inc, 75 F3d 801 (CA 2, NY, 25 Jan 1996) (securities fraud allegations). SCB: 872 F Supp 97

Warner-Lambert Co v A&A Candy & Tobacco Co, No. WMN-95-256 (D Md, 29 Jan 1996)

R J Reynolds Tobacco Co v Engle, 672 So 2d 39 (Fla App, 31 Jan 1996 corr 11 June 1996) (smokers' rights class action case)

King v Hofer, 42 Cal App 4th 678; 49 Cal Rptr 2d 719 (8 Feb 1996) (retaliation issue)

Burton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 916 F Supp 1102 (D Kans, 12 Feb 1996) (issue of manufacturer fraud, knowing but concealing tobacco's role in cancer and vascular disease)

Kearney v Philip Morris, Inc, 916 F Supp 61; 277; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 14636 (Mass, 16 Feb 1996) (cigarette-caused house-fire case, court said the danger is obvious)

Rosen v Ciba-Geigy Corp, Case 95-3064, 78 F3d 316 (CA 7, ND Illinois, 11 March 1996) (smoker case against nicotine patch maker re tobacco-caused heart heart attack, poorly reasoned on cause and effect)

Bell v Elmhurst Chicago Stone Co, 919 F Supp 308 (D ND Ill, 13 March 1996)

Braun v Lorillard Inc, Case 95-4094, 84 F3d 230 (CA 7, ND Illinois, 17 March 1996) (product liability case)

Wivell v Unemployment Compensation Board of Review, 673 A2d 439 (Penn, 19 March 1996). SCB: UCBR No. B-339019 (unemployment compensation case)

Sackman v Liggett Group, Inc, 920 F Supp 357 (19 March 1996) (re crime-fraud exception, release tobacco-taboo-type secret tobacco documents)

In the Matter of the Marriage of Lesa L. Aubuchon, 913 P2d 221 (Kans, 22 March 1996) (custody case, well defined issue as harm is enough to act on, without awaiting causing disease, at 223)

Michael Jenner v Warden Joe Class, Case 95-1941, 79 F3d 736 (CA 8, D South Dakota, 1 April 1996) (smoke-free prison case)

Lizzio v Lizzio, 226 App Div 2d 760; 640 NYS2d 330 (4 April 1996) (custody case) SCB: 162 Misc 2d 701; 618 NYS2d 934

Allgood v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 80 F3d 168; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 14656; 29 UCCRS 2d 496 (CA 5, Tex, 16 April 1996) (product liability dangerous tobacco case)

Richard Layton v Jolley, Case No. NS004483 (Superior Ct. of Calif., Los Angeles County, April 1996) (See details and context.)

Muller v Costello, et al., 1996 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 5239 (D ND NY, 16 April 1996)

Burton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 167 FRD 134 (D Kans, 1 May 1996) (discovery issue, court would do in camera review to determine whether the crime-fraud exception applies to documents allegedly covered by attorney-client privilege)

Todd v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 924 F Supp 59 (WD La, 9 May 1996) (tobacco dangerousness is obvious)

United States v Adams, Case 95-16510 (CA 2, ED New York, 15 May 1996) (robbery of a cigarette wholesaler case) (commentary)

Fortunoff Fine Jewelry & Silverware, Inc v New York State Division of Human Rights, 227 App Div 2d 557; 642 NYS2d 710; 8 NDLR ¶ 74; 11.5 TPLR 2.176 (20 May 1996) (on not hiring smokers)

Commonwealth of Massachusetts v Philip Morris, Inc, 942 F Supp 690 (Mass, 20 May 1996) (remand to state court)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 84 F3d 734 (CA 5, La, 23 May 1996). SCB: 160 FRD 544 (refusing class action status)

Sackman v Liggett Group, Inc, 167 FRD 9 (ED NY, 25 May 1996) (re crime-fraud exception, release secret tobacco documents)

Philip Morris, Inc v CIR, 517 US 1220; 116 S Ct 1849; 134 L Ed 2d 949 (28 May 1996). SCB: 71 F3d 1040

Sonnenreich v Philip Morris, Inc, 929 F Supp 416; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 14647; 9 FLW Fed D 814 (SD Fla, 29 May 1996)

Stitltner v Island Creek Coal Co and Dir, OWCP, 86 F3d 337 (CA 4, 7 June 1996)

Jackson v Burns, 89 F3d 850 (CA 10, 28 June 1996) (smoke-free prison case)

Cleoria Thompson v Carthage School, Case 95-2276 (CA 8, ED Arkansas, 28 June 1996) (contraband cigarettes at school, no Fourth Amendment protection) (commentary)

State of Minnesota v Philip Morris, Inc, 551 NW2d 490 (Minn, 25 July 1996) (cost recovery case)

Homeyer v Stanley Tulchin Assoc, Case No. 95-3977, 91 F3d 959 (CA 7, ND Ill, 31 July 1996) (s) (nonsmoker fired for seeking smoke-free workplace) http://laws.findlaw.com/uscircs/7th/953977.html . SCB: 1995 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 17114

State of Maryland v Philip Morris, Inc, 934 F Supp 173 (D Md, 1 Aug 1996) (remand cost recovery case to state court)

Figler v Figler, 1996 Conn Super LEXIS 2787; 1996 WL 636479 (2 Aug 1996) (TTS harm-to-child case)

Harvey v Foote, 92 F3d 1192; 1996 WL 441776 (CA 9, Oreg, 5 August 1996) (prison case)

Broward County Aviation Dept v Ind. Grievant, 106 LA (BNA) 1153 (6 Aug 1996)

Goodrum, et al v Greater Cleveland RTA, 1996 Ohio App LEXIS 3322 (8 Aug 1996)

Gilbert v Gilbert, 1996 Conn Super LEXIS 2153 (16 Aug 1996) (custody case)

Fuller v Allison Gas Turbine Division, GM Corp, 670 NE2d 64 (Ind App, 26 Aug 1996)

Women Prisoners of District of Columbia Dep't of Corrections v District of Columbia, 320 US App DC 247; 93 F3d 910 (30 Aug 1996) (smoke-free prison case). SCB: 877 F Supp 634; 899 F Supp 659

Wilks v American Tobacco Co, 680 So 2d 839, CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 14743 (Miss, 12 Sep 1996) (lung cancer, dangerous tobacco case, no assumption of risk by smoker, when tobacco companies deny it). SCB: 1993 WL 325136

R J Reynolds Tobacco Co v Engle, 682 So 2d 1000 (Fla, 2 Oct 1996) (smokers' rights class action case). SCB: 672 So 2d 39

Rosen v Ciba-Geigy Corp, 519 US 819; 117 S Ct 73; 136 L Ed 2d 33 (7 Oct 1996). SCB: 78 F3d 316

Michael Jenner v Warden Joe Class, 519 US 874; 117 S Ct 194; 136 L Ed 2d 131 (7 Oct 1996). SCB: 79 F3d 736

Allgood v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 519 US 930; 117 S Ct 300; 136 L Ed 2d 218 (15 Oct 1996). SCB: 80 F3d 168; CCH Prod Liab Rep ¶ 14656; 29 UCCRS 2d 496 (product liability dangerous tobacco case)

Matter of Becker, 144 Oregon App 237; 925 P2d 162 (23 Oct 1996) (parent smoking vs. child)

Caruso v Philip Morris Inc, 959 F Supp 340 (ED La, 31 Oct 1996)

Gauthier v Philip Morris, Inc, 959 F Supp 340 (ED La, 31 Oct 1996)

Pappion v Philip Morris, Inc, 959 F Supp 340 (ED La, 31 Oct 1996)

Perret v Philip Morris, Inc, 959 F Supp 340 (ED La, 31 Oct 1996)

Porteous v Philip Morris, Inc, 959 F Supp 340 (ED La, 31 Oct 1996)

Vagianos v Philip Morris, Inc, 959 F Supp 340 (ED La, 31 Oct 1996)

Scott v American Tobacco Co, 959 F Supp 340 (ED La, 31 Oct 1996)

Anheuser-Busch v Baltimore Mayor Schmoke, 101 F3d 325 (CA 4, Maryland, 13 Nov 1996) (cigarette advertising ban case) (commentary). SCB: 855 F Supp 811; 63 F3d 1305

Penn Advertising v Mayor and City Council of Baltimore, 101 F3d 332 (CA 4, Md, 13 Nov 1996) (on remand)

Braun v Lorillard Inc, 519 US 992; 117 S Ct 480; 136 L Ed 2d 375 (18 Nov 1996). SCB: 84 F3d 230 (product liability case)

Philip Morris, Inc et al v Scott Harshbarger, Attorney General of Massachusetts, Civil Action No. 95-12574-GAO (D Mass, 22 Nov 1996) (advertising case)

Stevens v Inland Waters, Inc, 220 Mich App 212; 559 NW2d 61 (22 Nov 1996) (on firing smokers)

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Wigand, 913 F Supp 530 (WD Ky, 24 Nov 1996) (litigation concerning Dr. Wigand, the famous exposer of coumarin in tobacco, long kept secret due to the tobacco taboo)

Chustz v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 961 F Supp 143 (MD La, 25 Nov 1996)

Ryder v Philip Morris, Inc, 946 F Supp 422 (ED Virginia, 27 Nov 1996)

City of Roanoke Rapids v Peedin, 124 NC App 578; 478 SE2d 528 (3 Dec 1996) (institutionalizing pure air re TTS)

State ex rel White v Parsons, 199 W Va 1; 483 SE2d 1; 66 ALR5th 737 (9 Dec 1996) (smokefree prison case)

Timkin Co v Steelworkers Local 1123, 108 LA (BNA) 422 (Canton, Ohio, 26 Dec 1996) (on-job smoking ban case)

Mrs. Binh Chiglo v City of Preston and Mike Sveen, Case 96-1066, 104 F3d 185 (CA 8, D Minnesota, 6 Jan 1997) (cigarette advertising case) (commentary). SCB: 909 F Supp 675

Anheuser Busch Inc v Schmoke, Mayor of Baltimore, 520 US 1204; 117 S Ct 1569; 137 L Ed 2d 714 (28 January 1997). SCB: 855 F Supp 811; 63 F3d 1305; 101 F3d 325

Penn Advertising v Mayor & City Council of Baltimore, 520 US 1204; 117 S Ct 1569; 137 L Ed 2d 715 (_______ 1997). SCB: 862 F Supp 1402; 63 F3d 1318; 101 F3d 332; 518 US 1030; 116 S Ct 2575 (approving amicus brief)

Philip Morris/Kraft Foods, Inc v WCAB (Levan), 689 A2d 986 (Pa Cmnwlth, 29 Jan 1997). SCB: WCAB A95-0209 (Pennsylvania worker compensation case)

Lacey v Lorillard Tob Co, Inc, 956 F Supp 956 (ND Ala, 31 Jan 1997) (smokers' rights case)

Burton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 170 FRD 481 (D Kans, 3 Feb 1997)

Marks v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 965 F Supp 857 (WD La, 4 Feb 1997)

Castano v American Tobacco Co, 961 F Supp 953 (ED La, 21 Feb 1997)

Rhoads v Federal Deposit Insurance Corp, et al., 3 Wage & Hour Cas 2d (BNA) 1381; 956 F Supp 1239 (D MD, 22 Feb 1997)

Arnold v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 956 F Supp 110 (D RI, 26 Feb 1997)

City and County of San Francisco v Philip Morris, Inc, 957 F Supp 1130 (ND Cal, 26 Feb 1997)

Crowder v District of Columbia, 959 F Supp 6 (D DC, 18 March 1997) (prison pure air rights case)

Wooster County Bd of Education v Wooster School Employees' Ass'n, 108 LA 502 (Ohio, 10 April 1997)

Kulbabinski v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Linton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

McCleary v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Yost v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Zakas v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Derzekos v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Kranz v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Lawrence v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Owens v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Rodriguez v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

White v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 172 FRD 474 (MD Fla, 10 April 1997)

Coyne Beahm, Inc v FDA, 966 F Supp 1374 (MD NC, 25 April 1997) (Text of Lawsuit)

Witherspoon v Philip Morris, Inc, 964 F Supp 455 (DDC, 2 May 1997) (widower product liability dangerous tobacco case)

Williams v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 964 F Supp 2d 257 (ND Ohio, 9 May 1997) (misrepresentation allegations)

Clark County School District v Education Support Employees' Ass'n, 108 LA (BNA) 1125 (13 May 1997) (smoker discharge case)

Barreras-Ruiz v American Tobacco Co, 964 F Supp 613 (D PR, 19 May 1997)

Smith v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 174 FRD 90 (WD Missouri, 22 May 1997) (rejecting class action status)

Wm. P. Todd, et al. v Rush County Schools, et al, 983 F Supp 799 (SD Indiana, 2 June 1997) (drug testing scam case)

Arch v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 175 FRD 469 (ED Pa, 3 June 1997) (refusing class action status)

Perez v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 967 F Supp 920 (SD Texas, 4 June 1997) (tobacco is inherently dangerous and so known)

Patricia Effinger v Philip Morris, USA, 984 F Supp 1043 (WD Ky, 4 June 1997) (employee sexual harassment case)

Sackman v Liggett Group, Inc, 965 F Supp 391 (ED NY, 9 June 1997) (dangerous tobacco case due to lung cancer, and citing alleged unlawful tobacco company business practices). SCB: 920 F Supp 357; 167 FRD 9

Arch v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 984 F Supp 830 (ED Pa, 17 June 1997)

Thomas v American Tobacco Co, 173 FRD 546 (MD Ga, 20 June 1997) (prisoner case)

Wilson v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 968 F Supp 296 (SD W Va, 27 June 1997)

International Paper Co v Carpenters Local 3130, 109 LA (BNA) 472 (SC, 6 July 1997)

USS v Steelworkers Local 9155, 109 LA (BNA) 36 (Minn, 14 July 1997) (on-job smoking ban case)

Mutual Mfg & Supply Co v Teamsters Local 100, 109 LA (BNA) 570 (Cincinnati, Ohio, 1 Aug 1997) (on-job smoking ban case)

Walker v Liggett Group, 175 FRD 226 (ED W Va, 5 Aug 1997) (smokers' rights class action case)

Masepohl v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 974 F Supp 1245 (D Minn, 8 Aug 1997)

Burton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 175 FRD 321 (D Kans, 14 Aug 1997) (a number of tobacco company documents not protected by attorney-client privilege)

De La Rosa v Philip Morris Products, Inc, 975 F Supp 161 (D PR, 14 Aug 1997)

Shaw v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 973 F Supp 539 (D Md, 15 Aug 1997) (issue of duty of warning nonsmokers of the danger of involuntary smoking)

Philip Morris, Inc v Mass. Attorney General Harshberger, Case 97-8022 (18 Aug 1997) (tobacco ingredients case) (commentary)

Wolpin v Philip Morris, Inc, 974 F Supp 1465; 1997 US Dist LEXIS 12915; 1997 WL 535218 (D SD Fla, 18 Aug 1997) (issue of duty of warning nonsmokers of the danger of involuntary smoking)

Barnes v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 176 FRD 479 (ED Pa, 22 Aug 1997)

Beatie v City of New York and Mayor Rudolph Giuliani, Case 96-9131 (CA 2, New York, 2 Sep 1997) (smoker vs clean air law) (commentary)

State of Texas v American Tobacco Co, 14 F Supp 2d 956 (ED Tex, 8 Sep 1997)

Barreras-Ruiz v American Tobacco Co, 977 F Supp 545 (D PR, 9 Sep 1997). SCB: 964 F Supp 613 (product liability dangerous tobacco case)

Scott v Steelman, 953 SW2d 147 (Mo App, 25 Sep 1997) (divorce case)

Crooke v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 978 F Supp 1482 (ND Ga, 6 Oct 1997)

Toole v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 980 F Supp 419 (ND Ala, 8 Oct 1997) (re loose cigarettes)

Barnes v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 989 F Supp 661 (ED Pa, 10 Oct 1997)

Alley v State, 1997 WL 695590 (D Kansas, 15 Oct 1997) (prison case, upholding smoking ban)

Barnes v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 984 F Supp 842 (ED Pa, 17 Oct 1997)

Small v Lorillard Tobacco Co, 175 Misc 2d 294, 668 NYS 2d 307 (28 Oct 1997) (class action smokers rights case alleging fraud, etc.)

Small v Lorillard Tobacco Co, 176 Misc 2d 413, 672 NYS2d 601 (28 Oct 1997) (smokers rights case, tobacco company opposition rejected)

Taylor v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 983 F Supp 686 (ED Mich, 3 Nov 1997) (dangerous tobacco case).

Lindsey v Tacoma-Pierce County Health Dep't, 8 F Supp 2d 1213 (WD Wash, 6 Nov 1997) (cigarette advertising ban case)

Western Sugar Co v Teamsters Local 300, 109 LA (BNA) 944 (Nebraska, 24 Nov 1997)

Women Prisoners of District of Columbia Dep't of Corrections v District of Columbia, 520 US 1196; 117 S Ct 1552; 137 L Ed 2d 701; 1997 US LEXIS 2686 (28 April 1997). SCB: 877 F Supp 634, 98 Ed Law Rep 681; 899 F Supp 659, 104 Ed Law Rep 213; 93 F3d 910, 113 Ed Law Rep 30

General Electric Co, et al. v Joiner, 522 US 136; 118 S Ct 512; 139 L Ed 2d 508 (15 Dec 1997) (smoker lung cancer case with expert witness issue). SCB: 864 F Supp 1310; 78 F3d 524

Town of Plymouth v Civil Service Commission and Rossborough, 426 Mass 1; 686 NE2d 188; 1997 Mass LEXIS 373 (20 Dec 1997) (smoker discharge case)

County of Los Angeles v R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, No. 707651 (Cal Super Ct, 23 Dec 1997) (dismissing breach of warranty, fraud, strict liability, and negligence claims with leave to amend)

Burton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 177 FRD 491 (D Kans, 23 Dec 1997)

Naval-Torres v Northwest Airlines Inc., 159 D. L.R. (4th) 67 (1998) (TTS-caused passenger injury case)

Wm. P. Todd, et al. v Rush County Schools, et al, Case 97-2548, 133 F3d 984 (CA 7, 12 Jan 1998). SCB: 983 F Supp 799 (drug testing scam case) (commentary)

Noonan v The Winston Co, et al., 135 F3d 85 (CA 1, D Massachusetts, 2 Feb 1998) (cigarette ads use of anti-cigarette activist's photo) (commentary)

USA v Doe (R.S.W.), Case 97-30042 (CA 9, D Montana, 12 Feb 1998) (a juvenile delinquent case of arson, the student started a fire in school, proof of knowledge of effect of fire-starting is not necessary for conviction, it's known cigarettes are useable for arson, lighting a cigarette has no legal basis when banned)

USA v Jane Doe (R.S.W.), Case 97-30042 (CA 9, D Montana, 12 Feb 1998) (fire case) (commentary)

Haskin v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 995 F Supp 1437 (MD Fla, 26 Feb 1998)

Wakeland v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 996 F Supp 1213 (SD Ala, 5 March 1998)

Milburn Colliery Co v Hicks and Dir, OWCP, Case 96-2438 (CA 4, 6 March 1998)

City of Birmingham, Ala v American Tobacco Co, 10 F Supp 2d 1257 (ND Ala, 9 March 1998)

Lindsey v Tacoma-Pierce County Health Dep't, 8 F Supp 2d 1225 (WD Wash, 16 March 1998) (cigarette advertising ban case)

Central Illinois Carpenters Health & Welfare Trust Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 28 F Supp 2d 514 (SD Ill, 16 March 1998)

Barreras-Ruiz v American Tobacco Co, 180 FRD 194 (D PR, 17 March 1998) (refusing class action status)

West Virginia-Ohio Valley Area I.B.E.W. Welfare Fund v American Tobacco Co, 29 F Supp 2d 733 (SD W Va, 19 March 1998)

Laborers Local 17 Health & Benefit Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 7 F Supp 2d 277; RICO Bus Disp Guide (CCH) ¶ 9463 (SD NY, 25 March 1998)

United States v US Shoe Corp, 523 US 360; 118 S Ct 1290; 140 L Ed 2d 453 (31 March 1998) (tax case saying Pace v Burgess (1875), supra, is still a current good precedent). SCB: 907 F Supp 408; 114 F3d 1564

Philip Morris, Inc v Minnesota, 523 US 1056; 118 S Ct 1384; 140 L 643 (6 April 1998)

Laborers Local 17 Health & Benefit Fund, et al v Philip Morris, Inc, et al, 179 FRD 417; RICO Bus Disp Guide (CCH) ¶ 9479 (SD NY, 7 April 1998)

County of Los Angeles v R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, No. S068747, 1998 Cal. LEXIS 2475 (Cal, 22 April 1998) SCB: Cal Super Ct No. 707651 (granting petition for review)

Iowa ex rel. Miller v Philip Morris, Inc, 577 NW2d 401 (Iowa, 22 April 1998) (smoker health care cost reimbursement case)

Jones v American Tobacco Co, 17 F Supp 2d 706 (ND Ohio, 23 April 1998) (dangerous tobacco case)

Williams v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 17 F Supp 2d 706 (ND Ohio, 23 April 1998) (dangerous tobacco case)

Laborers Local 17 Health & Benefit Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 7 F Supp 2d 294 (SD NY, 28 April 1998)

Ciarlante v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp and American Tobacco Co, Case No. 98-1850; 143 F3d 139 (CA 3, ED Penn, 30 April 1998) (class action by sales reps of whom large numbers were fired without notice on corp merger, citing Chevron argument and alleging violation of the law requiring notice when over 50 are fired by the same office). SCB: 1996 WL 656448 (judgment for employees); 1996 WL 741973 (reconsideration denial); 1997 WL 611679 (damages order)

House of Corrections Block Representatives Comm v Creamer, 1998 WL 242663; 1998 US Dist LEXIS 6056 (ED Pa, 30 April 1998) (prison smoking ban case)

Philip Morris, Inc v Glendening, 349 Md 660; 709 A2d 1230 (19 May 1998) (taxpayer funds recovery case)

Smith v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 3 F Supp 2d 1473 (D DC, 19 May 1998)

Kiowa Tribe of Oklahoma v Manufacturing Technologies, Inc, 523 US 751; 118 S Ct 1700; 140 L Ed 2d 981 (26 May 1998) (Indian rights case, essentially immune to state control, like any foreign country)

Bayer Corp v Chemical Workers Local 566, 110 LA (BNA) 924 (W Va, 29 May 1998) (on-job smoking ban case)

Buckingham v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 713 A2d 381 (New Hampshire, 29 May 1998) (involuntary smoking lung cancer case concerning dangerous tobacco; issue of negligence by supplying others a product not made safe)

Oregon Laborers-Employers Health & Welfare Trust Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 188 FRD 369 (1 June 1998)

Thomas v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 11 F Supp 2d 850 (SD Miss, 1 June 1998)

Lamirande v Lamirande, 251 App Div 1071, 674 NYS2d 224 (10 June 1998) (divorce case)

Grady Carter v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 723 So 2d 833 (Fla 1st DCA, 22 June 1998 reh den 31 Dec 1998) (smoker's rights lung cancer case)

Faragher v City of Boca Raton, 1998 WL 336322; 524 US 775; 118 S Ct 2275; 141 L Ed 2d 662 (CA 11, Fla, 26 June 1998) (on-job sexual harassment case, employer vicariously liable, comparable to smoking-on-job as courts develop more understanding). SCB: 864 F Supp 1552; 76 F3d 1155; 111 F3d 1530

Day Care Council, Local 205, DC 1707 Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Eastern States Health & Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

IBEW Local 25 Health & Benefit Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

IBEW Local 363 Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Local 1199 Home Care Industry Benefit Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Local 1199 National Benefit Fund for Health & Human Services Employees v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Local 138, 138A, and 138B International Union of Operating Engineers Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Local 840, Internat'l Broth of Teamsters Health & Ins Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Long Island Regional Council of Carpenters Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Puerto Rican ILGWU Health & Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 11 F Supp 2d 384 (SD NY, 29 June 1998)

Hollar v Philip Morris, Inc, 43 F Supp 2d 794 (ND Ohio, 7 July 1998)

Seafarers' Welfare Plan v Philip Morris, 27 F Supp 2d 623 (Md, 13 July 1998)

Talkington v Atria, 97-1386p and 97-1386pv2 (CA 4, D SC, 15 July 1998) (a fire-safe cigarette case)

Flue-Cured Tobacco Coop. Stabilization Corp. v United States EPA, 4 F Supp 2d 435 (M.D NC, 17 July 1998)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Federal Trade Commission, 14 F Supp 2d 757 (17 July 1998) (trade practices and advertising case)

Matter of Marriage of Heuberger, 155 Oregon App 310; 963 P2d 153 (5 Aug 1998) (divorce case)

Daniels v Philip Morris Companies, Inc, 18 F Supp 2d 1110 (SD Cal, 7 Aug 1998)

Brown & Williamson v Food and Drug Admin, Case 97-1604p, 153 F3d 155 (CA 4, MD NC, 14 Aug 1998). SCB: 966 F Supp 1374 (on FDA authority to regulate cigarettes)

City of San Jose v Department of Health Services, 66 Cal App 4th 35; 77 Cal Rptr 2d 609 (18 Aug 1998) rev den 18 Nov 1998 (local smoking control regulation)

Oregon Laborers-Employers Health & Welfare Trust Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 17 F Supp 2d 1170; 22 Employee Benefits Cas (BNA) 1697 (D Oregon, 24 Aug 1998). SCB: 188 FRD 369

Montgomery & Lamoyeux by Montgomery v Philip Morris, Inc, 19 F Supp 2d 321 (SD Fla, 25 Aug 1998) (successful attorneys fee re prior remand)

New Jersey Carpenters Health Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 17 F Supp 2d 324 (D NJ, 26 Aug 1998)

Laborers Local 17 Health & Benefit Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 26 F Supp 2d 593 (SD NY, 27 Aug 1998)

United Federation of Teachers Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 26 F Supp 2d 593 (SD NY, 27 Aug 1998)

Sayville Inn v County of Suffolk, 98-CV-4527; ___ F Supp ___ (ED NY, 3 Aug 1998) ("It is beyond dispute that second-hand smoke is a carcinogen. . . . The risk to the health of non-smoking patrons of restaurants and its employees, when exposed to second-hand smoke, is obvious.")

Lamirande v Lamirande, 92 NY2d 809; 678 NYS2d 595; 700 NE2d 1231 (31 Aug 1998). SCB: 251 App Div 1071, 674 NYS2d 224 (divorce case)

Texas Carpenters Health Benefit Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 21 F Supp 2d 664 (ED Texas, 31 Aug 1998)

Hernandez v Tokai Corp, Case 97-50862 (CA 5, WD Texas, 4 Sep 1998) (a fire safe cigarette case)

Iron Workers Local Union No. 17 Ins Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 23 F Supp 2d 771 (10 and 21 Sep 1998)

Iron Workers Local Union No. 17 Ins Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 23 F Supp 2d 796 (14 Sep 1998)

Holt v Olmstead Township Board of Trustees, 43 F Supp 2d 812; 51 Fed R Evid Serv 968 (ND Ohio, 18 Sep 1998) (Context)

Iron Workers Local Union No. 17 Ins Fund and Its Trustees v Philip Morris, Inc, 182 FRD 512 (23 and 29 Sep 1998)

Small v Lorillard Tobacco Co, 175 Misc 2d 294; 668 NYS 2d 307 (addicted smokers class action)

Brown v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 26 F Supp 2d 74 (D DC, 28 Sep 1998) (product liability case)

Kentucky Laborers Dist. Council Health & Welfare Trust Fund v Hill & Knowlton, Inc, 24 F Supp 2d 755 (WD Ky, 30 Sep 1998) (smoker health care cost reimbursement case)

Webber v Crabtree, 158 F3d 460 (CA 9, 8 Oct 1998) (smoke-free prison case)

Johnson v Saffle, Case No. 98-6225; 166 F3d 1221; 1998 WL 792071; 98 CJAR 5315 (CA 10, Oklahoma, 15 Oct 1998) (s) (prisoner lawsuit opposing smoking ban, dismissed as frivolous, evading the smoking-crime link. SCB: D.C. No. 98-CV-379, 12 May 1998) http://laws.findlaw.com/uscircs/10th/986225.html

National Asbestos Workers Medical Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 23 F Supp 2d 321 (ED NY, 19 Oct 1998)

Small v Lorillard Tobacco Co, 176 Misc 2d 413, 672 NYS2d 601 (addicted smokers class action). SCB: 175 Misc 2d 294; 668 NYS 2d 307

Iron Workers Local Union No. 17 Ins Fund and Its Trustees v Philip Morris, Inc, 182 FRD 523 (20 Oct 1998)

Hollister v Hollister, 254 App Div 580, 678 NYS 2d 820 (22 Oct 1998) (custody case)

Small v Lorillard Tobacco Co, 252 App Div 2d 1; 679 NYS2d 593 (29 Oct 1998) (addicted smokers class action smokers' rights case, lost due to tobacco company opposition). SCB: 175 Misc 2d 294, 668 NYS 2d 307; 176 Misc 2d 413, 672 NYS2d 601

Philip Morris, Inc v Mass. Attorney General Harshberger (CA 1, D Massachusetts, 6 Nov 1998) (tobacco ingredients case) (commentary)

Daniel v Daniel, 235 Ga App 184; 509 SE2d 117 (10 Nov 1998) cert den 1990572 (14 April 2000) (smoking mother lost (custody)

Brown & Williamson v Food and Drug Admin, Case No. 97-1604, 161 F3d 764 (CA 4, 10 Nov 1998). SCB: 966 F Supp 1374; 153 F3d 155

Barnes v American Tobacco Co, 161 F3d 127; Case 98-1999p (CA 3, ED Pa, 12 Nov 1998). SCB: 176 FRD 479; 984 F Supp 842; 989 F Supp 661 (class action dangerous tobacco case)

Iron Workers Local Union No. 17 Ins Fund and Its Trustees v Philip Morris, Inc, 29 F Supp 2d 801 (23 Nov 1998)

Iron Workers Local Union No. 17 Ins Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 29 F Supp 2d 825 (2 Dec 1998)

Insolia v Philip Morris, Inc, 31 F Supp 3d 660 (WD Wisconsin, 14 Dec 1998)

Emig v American Tobacco Co, Inc, 184 FRD 379 (D Kansas, 21 Dec 1998)

Warfield Tobacco, Inc v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 34 F Supp 2d 1050 (ED Ky, 6 Jan 1999) (trade case with unfairness issues)

Regence Blue Shield v Philip Morris, Inc, 40 F Supp 2d 1179 (WD Washington, 6 Jan 1999)

Laborers and Operating Engineers Utility Agreement Health & Welfare Trust Fund for Arizona v Philip Morris, Inc, 42 F Supp 2d 943 (Ariz, 19 Jan 1999)

Iron Workers Local Union No. 17 Ins Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 35 F Supp 2d 582 (ND Ohio, 3 Feb 1999)

University of Alabama v American Tobacco Co, et al, 168 F3d 405; Case No. 97-6680 (CA 11, SD Alabama, 22 Feb 1999) (cigarette-disease reimbursement case for medical care provided to ill students; jurisdictional issue; courts must verify their own, and subordinates)

Wolpin v Philip Morris, Inc, 189 FRD 418 (CD Cal, 23 Feb 1999) SCB: 974 F Supp 1465 (subpoena data issue)

Kirksey v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 168 F3d 1039 (CA 7, Ill, 25 Feb 1999). SCB: 1998 WL 381972

Republic of Bolivia v Philip Morris Companies, Inc, 39 F Supp 2d 1008 (SD Texas, 1 March 1999)

Steamfitters Local Union No. 420 Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 171 F3d 912 (CA 3, Penn, 29 March 1999). SCB: 1998 WL 212846

Blue Cross and Blue Shield of New Jersey, Inc v Philip Morris, Inc, 36 F Supp 2d 560 (ED NY, 30 March 1999)

Hill v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 44 F Supp 2d 837 (WD Ky, 2 April 1999) (product liability case by widow)

Philip Morris Inc v Superior Court, 71 Cal App 4th 116; 83 Cal Rptr 2d 671 (5 April 1999) (smoker's rights case, challenging the judge issue)

Hise v Philip Morris, Inc, 46 F Supp 2d 1201 (ND Okla, 29 April 1999) (smokers challenging the states' case settlement under anti-trust law)

Nicolo v Philip Morris, Inc, 37 F Supp 2d 121 (D RI, 2 May 1999)

Philip Morris, Inc v Allen Distributors, Inc, 48 F Supp 2d 844 (SD Ind, 4 May 1999) (mfr vs distributor trade case)

Rosabach v Lorillard, Inc., 71 F Supp 2d 221 (SD NY, 13 May 1999) (smokers' rights case, diversity issue)

Barnes v American Tobacco Co, 526 US 1114; 119 S Ct 1760; 143 L Ed 2d 791; 1999 US LEXIS 3264 (17 May 1999). SCB: 176 FRD 479, 984 F Supp 842, 989 F Supp 661, 161 F3d 127

Magaw v Middletown Bd of Education, 323 N J Super 1; 731 A2d 1196 (2 July 1999) (worker compensation case, nonsmoker cancer from TTS from smoker coworker)

Phillip Keller v City of Grand Rapids (WD Mich, 1 July 1999) (jury verdict $420,878, smoke-free job discipline and harassment case)

Aviation West Corporation v Washington State Dep't of Labor and Industries, 138 Wash 2d 413; 980 P2d 701 (8 July 1999) (a no-smoking rule on the job case)

Thaxton v Norfolk Southern Ry Co, 239 Ga App 18; 520 SE2d 735 (8 July 1999) (Context)

Coyne and Taxpayers v American Tobacco Co, 183 F3d 488, 1999 Fed App 252P (CA 6, Ohio, 12 July 1999) (tobacco-caused health care costs recovery case)

Jennings v BIC Corp, et al, 181 F3d 1250 (CA 11, MD Fla, 22 July 1999) (lighter fire, child's pajamas caught on fire)

Muller v Costello, Case No. 98-7491 (CA 2, ND NY, 11 Aug 1999)

Owen v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 187 F3d 637; 1999 WL 617968 (CA 6, 12 August 1999)

Laborers Local 17 Health & Benefit Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 191 F3d 229 (CA 2, NY, 18 Aug 1999) (cost recovery case)

Federation of Advertising Indus. Representatives, Inc v City of Chicago, 189 F3d 633 (CA 7, 1 Sep 1999)

Guidey v U. S. Tobacco Co, Inc, 188 F3d 619 (CA 5, 14 Sep 1999) (on addictive, carcinogenic effects)

Arkansas Carpenters' Health & Welfare Fund v Philip Morris, Inc, 75 F Supp 2d 936 (ED Ark, 28 Sep 1999) (cost recovery case)

Skidmore-Shafer v Shafer, 770 So 2d 1097 (Alabama App, 8 Oct 1999, cert den 1990572 14 April 2000) (custody case, smoking mother lost)

Hills v Stewart, 199 F3d 1332; 1999 WL 970804 (CA 9, Ariz, 22 Oct 1999) (prison case; no constitutional right to smoke)

Greater New York Metro. Food Council, Inc v Giuliani, No 99-7006, 195 F3d 100; 1999 WL 965691 (CA 2, 25 Oct 1999). SCB: 1998 WL 879721 (cigarette advertising ban case)

Small v Lorillard Tobacco Co, No. 154, 94 NY2d 43; 698 NYS 2d 615; 720 NE2d 892 (NY, 26 Oct 1999) (addicted smokers class action, affirming tobacco company win against smokers' rights). SCB: 252 App Div 2d 1, 679 NYS2d 593; 175 Misc 2d 294, 668 NYS 2d 307; 176 Misc 2d 413, 672 NYS2d 601

State of California v Philip Morris, et al (Cal Sup Ct, 2 Nov 1999) (re warning injunction)

Magaw v Middletown Bd of Education, 1999 NJ LEXIS 1522 (5 Nov 1999). SCB: 323 N J Super 1; 731 A2d 1196 (worker compensation case, nonsmoker cancer from TTS from smoker coworker)

In Re Tobacco/Governmental Health Care Costs Litigation, 76 F Supp 2d 5 (DDC, 17 Nov 1999) (cost recovery case)

Nineteen Indian Tribes v Philip Morris et al (Judge Marilyn Hall Patel, 17 Nov 1999)

Lindsey v Tacoma-Pierce County Health Dep't, 195 F3d 1065 (CA 9, 19 Nov 1999) (cigarette advertising case). SCB: 8 F Supp 2d 1225

Thompson, et al v American Tobacco Company, Inc. et al, 189 FRD 544 (D Minn, 22 Nov 1999) (class action dangerous tobacco case)

Amendola v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 198 F3d 244; 1999 WL 1111515 (CA 6, 24 November 1999)

Lorillard Tobacco Co v Thomas Reilly, Attorney General, State of Massachusetts, 76 F Supp 2d 124 (Mass, 2 Dec 1999) (advertising case)

Sklaroff v Com of Pennsylvania by D. Michael Fisher, Pa,736 A2d 693; 736 A2d 705 (17 Dec 1999) (Sklaroff intervention denied)

Laborers Local 17 Health & Benefit Fund, et al v Philip Morris, Inc, et al, 528 US 1080; 120 S Ct 799; 145 L Ed 2d 673; 2000 US LEXIS 185 (10 Jan 2000). SCB: 7 F Supp 2d 277; 191 F3d 229 (cost recovery case)

Taylor v American Tobacco Co, et al, Civil No. 97 715975 NP (CA 3, Mich, Judge William J. Giovan, 11 Jan 2000) (dangerous tobacco case filed by persons illegally sold cigarettes in violation of Michigan law). SCB: 983 F Supp 686

Yakama Indian Nation v Washington Dept of Revenue, 528 US 1116; 120 S Ct 935; 145 L Ed 2d 813 (18 Jan 2000). SCB: 873 F Supp 404; 78 F3d 1400; 955 F Supp 1229; 176 F3d 1241 (cigarette tax exemption allegation case)

Lorillard Tobacco Co, et al v Thomas Reilly, Attorney General of Massachusetts, Civ Action No. 99-11118-WGY, 84 F Supp 2d 180 (D Mass, 24 Jan 2000) (upholding Mass. tobacco law)

Group Health Plan Inc v Philip Morris Inc, 86 F Supp 2d 912 (25 Jan 2000) (cost recovery case)

Hise v Philip Morris, Inc, 208 F3d 226 (CA 10, Okla, 17 Feb 2000). SCB: 46 F Supp 2d 1201 (smokers challenging the states' case settlement under anti-trust law)

State of Minnesota ex rel. Attorney General Humphrey v Philip Morris Inc, 606 NW2d 676 (Minn App, 22 Feb 2000 rev den 25 April 2000) (cost recovery case; upheld public access to tobacco lobby's secret documents)

FDA v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, Case 98-1152; 529 US 120; 120 S Ct 1291; 146 L Ed 2d 121 (21 March 2000). SCB: 966 F Supp 1374; 153 F3d 155 (decision by the world's worst court, aiding/abetting tobacco farmer activity, in the modern holocaust of tens of millions of killings)

Duncan v Northwest Airlines, Case No. 98-35617; 208 F3d 1112 (CA 9, Wash, 6 April 2000) (flight attendant second-hand smoke injury case)

Thomas, Albert v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, Case No. 99-8229, 529 US 1073; 120 S Ct 1686, 146 L Ed 2d 493 (CA 11, 17 April 2000)

Buchanan v John Doe of Buglar and Brown & Williamson Cigarette Tobacco Corp, 529 US 1126; 120 S Ct 2025; 146 L Ed 2d 953 (22 May 2000). SCB: 198 F3d 244

Philip Morris Inc, et al. v Engle, 529 US 1144; 120 S Ct 2025; 146 L Ed 2d 975 (22 May 2000). SCB: 746 So 2d 457; 672 So 2d 39; 682 So 2d 1000 (smokers' rights class action case)

Naegele v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 81 Cal App 4th 503; 96 Cal Rptr 2d 666 (9 June 2000) (smoker's rights lung cancer case alleging fraud)

Californians for Scientific Integrity v Regents of University of California, 81 Cal App 4th 1270; 97 Cal Rptr 2d 501 (6 July 2000) (a tobacco taboo censorship case objecting to research exposing tobacco effects and processes)

Naegele v R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 81 Cal App 4th 1204f (7 July 2000). SCB: 81 Cal App 4th 503; 96 Cal Rptr 2d 666

Engle v R J Reynolds Tobacco Co, Fla Ct (14 July 2000) (Florida smokers' rights class action case jury verdict for $145 billion). SCB: 672 So 2d 39; 682 So 2d 1000

Consolidated Cigar Corp v Thomas Reilly, Attorney General of Massachusetts, 218 F3d 30 (CA 1, 17 July 2000). SCB: 76 F Supp 3d 124; 84 F Supp 2d 180 (upholding Mass. tobacco law)

Estate of White v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 109 F Supp 2d 424 (D Md, 25 July 2000) (smoker's rights case)

LDM Inc v. Princeton Regional Health Com'n, 336 N J Super 277; 764 A2d 507 (29 August 2000) (indoor smoking ban pre-emption)

Abid M. Husain Estate v Olympic Airways, 110 F Supp 2d 1234 (DC ND Cal, 29 Aug 2000) replaced by 2000 WL 1483203 (travelers' rights case)

United States v. Philip Morris Inc, et al., Civil Action No. 99-2496 (GK) (28 Sep 2000) (TPLP Analysis)

Sklaroff v Com of Pennsylvania by D. Michael Fisher, 531 US 917; 121 S Ct 276; 148 LEd 2d 201; 2000 US LEXIS 6515 (Pennsylvania certiorari denial, 2 Oct 2000). SCB: Pa, 736 A2d 693; 736 A2d 705 (Sklaroff intervention)

Californians for Scientific Integrity v Regents of Univ of California, cert den (3 Oct 2000). SCB: 81 Cal App 4th 1270; 97 Cal Rep 2d 501 (a tobacco taboo censorship case objecting to research exposing tobacco effects and processes)

Hise v Philip Morris, Inc, 531 US 959; 121 S Ct 384; 148 L Ed 2d 96 (30 Oct 2000). SCB: 46 F Supp 2d 1201; 208 F3d 226 (smokers challenging the states' case settlement under anti-trust law)

Grady Carter v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp, 778 So 2d 932 (Fla, 22 Nov 2000) (smoker's rights lung cancer case). SCB: Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Carter, 723 So 2d 833 (Fla 1st DCA 1998)

Northwest Airlines v Duncan, 531 US 1058; 121 S Ct 650; 148 L Ed 2d 571; #00-404 (10 Dec 2000) (6-3: Rehnquist, Scalia, O'Connor) (flight attendant second hand smoke pulmonary injury case). SCB: 208 F3d 1112

Lorillard Tobacco Co, et al v Thomas Reilly, Attorney General of Massachusetts, 531 US 1068; 121 S Ct 755; 148 L Ed 2d 659; 2001 US LEXIS 42 (8 Jan 2001) SCB: 84 F Supp 2d 180; 218 F3d 30 (upholding Mass. tobacco law, certiorari granted)

Group Health Plan Inc v Philip Morris Inc, 621 NW2d 2 (Minn, 11 Jan 2001). SCB: 86 F Supp 2d 912 (tobacco cost recovery case)

Atkinson v Taylor, et al., 316 F3d 257 (CA 3, Delaware, 21 January 2001) (smoke-free right in prisons is clear as of 1993, p 263; the right has existed for over 4000 years)

King Faisal Cancer Specialist Hospital v Tobacco Companies (5 Feb 2001)

Mich. Restaurant Ass'n v City of Marquette, 245 Mich App 63; 626 NW2d 418 (13 March 2001) [Link to Detroit News Article; to Grand Rapids Press Editorial]

Star Scientific, Inc, ___ F Supp 2d ___ (Va, March 2001) (challenge to Atty Gen cost-cases settlement)

Oregon Restaurant Ass'n v City of Corvallis, 166 Ore App 506; 999 P2d 518 (12 April 2000) (smoking ban within ten feet of entrance)

Daniel Brashear v Simms, 138 F Supp 2d 693 (D M., F. Smallkin, 12 April 2001) (prison case; no ADA or constitutional right to smoke)

Cigarette Vending Machine Ban Case (Connecticut Supreme Ct, 30 April 2001)

Rev. Jesse Brown et al v Philip Morris et al, Case No 99-1931, ___ F3d ___ (CA 3, 17 May 2001). SCB: ED Pa, 23 Sep 1999 (issue of targeting minorities)

Joe Battaglia v Imperial Tobacco Canada Ltd. (Toronto, 5 June 2001) (case by a 59-year-old Toronto tobacco company salesman, re heart disease)

Richard Boeken v Philip Morris (6 June 2001) (three billion dollar verdict)

Santa Fe Natural Tobacco Co, Inc v Spitzer, Nos. 00-7274, 00-7750, 2001 WL 636441 (SD NY, 8 June 2001)

Reilly v Grayson, 157 F Supp 2d 762 (ED MI, 22 June 2001) (smoke free air, prison case)

Bond v Sheahan, 152 F Supp 2d 1055 (D ND Ill., 19 July 2001) (provide smoke-free air for officer in prison)

Table Bluff Reservation, et al v Philip Morris, et al (CA 9)

Alabama Coushatta Tribe Lawsuit v Philip Morris, et al (D Tex)

Acoma Pueblo, et al v Philip Morris, et al (D NM)

Lorillard Tobacco Co v Thomas Reilly, Attorney General of Massachusetts, Case #596; 533 US 525; 121 S Ct 2404; 150 L Ed 2d 532 (28 June 2001) SCB: 218 F3d 30; 84 F Supp 2d 180; 76 F Supp 3d 124 (advertising regulation case; decision by the world's worst court).

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Grady Carter, 533 US 950; 121 S Ct 2593; 150 L Ed 2d 751 (29 June 2001). (smoker's rights lung cancer case). SCB: 778 So 2d 932; 723 So 2d 833

Selcer v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, ___ F Supp ___ (D Nev, 29 June 2001)

Action on Smoking and Health (ASH) v Secretary of the Department of Labor (CADC, 9 July 2001) (Case)

Rauen v U. S. Tobacco Mfg. Ltd. Partnership, 161 F Supp 2d 899 (ND Ill, 19 Sep 2001) and 2001 WL 1223529 (business case; allegations of handicap discrimination against employee; refusing her a home office as accommodation)

Alvarado v Litscher, 267 F3d 648 (CA 7, Wisconsin, 28 Sep 2001) (threat to future health, prison case)

R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co v Star Scientific, Inc, 169 F Supp 2d 452 (MD NC, 3 Oct 2001) (business case, alleging patent infringement)

Airspace Action, Physicians for Smoke-Free Canada, et al. v Premier of British Columbia, et al, Case # 16958 (BC Human Rights Commission, 15 Oct 2001) (a pure air rights injunction case in process)

Philip Morris, et al v Reilly, Atty Gen, Massachusetts, ___ F3d ___ (CA 1, 16 Oct 2001) (upholding Massachusetts Tobacco Ingredients and Nicotine Yield Act; opposition to disclosure dates back a century)

In re Tobacco Cases II, __ Cal App 4th ___; 113 Cal Rptr 2d 120 (25 Oct 2001) (union health and welfare trust fund cost recovery case)

Patricia Henley v Philip Morris Co, 93 Cal App 4th 824; 113 Cal Rptr 2d 494 (7 Nov 2001) (lung cancer case; $26.5 million award upheld)

Star Scientific, Inc v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 174 F Supp 2d 388 (D Md, 19 Nov 2001) (patent infringement case)

Booth v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, et al., 2001 WL 1837830; Prod Liab Rep (CCH) P 16,265 (WD Mich, 20 Nov 1981) (lung cancer case)

Floyd R. Kenyon v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co (Tampa, Fla., 12 Dec 2001) (lung cancer and emphysema case, defectively designed product, $165,000)

Star Scientific, Inc, ___ F3d ___ (CA 4, Va, 22 Jan 2002) (challenge to Atty Gen cost-cases settlement). SCB

Zimmerman v Dept of Corrections, 2002 Mich App LEXIS 1419; 2002 Mich App LEXIS 31310162 (Mich App, 15 Oct 2002) (smoke-free air rights case)

United States v Reynaldo Miravalles, 280 F3d 1328 (CA 11, Fla, 29 Jan 2002) (counterfeit cigar labels case)

Group Health Plan Inc v Philip Morris Inc, 188 F Supp 2d 1122 (D Minn, 31 Jan 2002) (loss recovery attempt): SCB 86 F Supp 912; 621 NW2d 2

Wayne County v Philip Morris Inc, et al., 465 Mich 537; 638 NW2d 409 (31 Jan 2002) (News Article; taxpayer health-care cost recovery case)

Amico's Inc v Thomas Mattos, 01-118, _ RI _; 789 A2d 899 (15 Feb 2002) (pure air case; upholding city restaurant smoking ban as per cities' and towns' broad powers to protect the "health, safety and welfare" of restaurant patrons). SCB: Sup Ct, Mar 2001.

David Burton v R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. and Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp (Kansas City, 22 Feb 2002) (peripheral vascular disease case, $198,400)

Prosecutor of Italy v Paribas Bank Executives (Italy, 5 March 2002) (manslaughter charges upheld against supervisors, for allowing smoking by woman's co-workers, killing her) (Details at ASH and at La Stampa) (confirms wisdom of not hiring smokers, and applies the 'taking victims as come' precedents)

McCabe v British American Tobacco Australia Services Ltd, 2002 VSC 73 (Sup Ct of Victoria, Common Law Div, Melbourne, Australia (22 March 2002) (product liability case) [PDF Version]

Schwarz v Philip Morris (Multnomah County Circ. Ct., Oregon, Docket No. 0002-01376, 22 March 2002)

John Lukacs v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, 3rd District Court of Appeal (Florida, April 2002) (product liability case)

McCabe v British American Tobacco Australia Services Ltd (Sup Ct of Victoria, Common Law Div, Melbourne, Australia (11 April 2002) (smoker lung cancer case, award $375,000) [NEU Analysis; DNSA Analysis]

State of Kansas v Audra Corinna Watson (Kansas Supreme Court, 19 April 2002) (cigarette smuggling case, re cigarettes smuggled into jail, in violation of no tobacco rule)

Mayola Williams v Philip Morris, Inc., R J Reynolds Tobacco Co., et al., Case Nos. 9705-03957; A106791; 182 Oregon App 44; 48 P3d 824 (5 June 2002) (product liability case)

Lukacs v Philip Morris, Inc., et al. (Fla. Jury Award, 11 June 2002) (dangerous tobacco case)

Burton v R. J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, Case No. 94-2202-JWL (Kansas, 5 July 2002) (TPLP background analysis)

Betty Jean Myers v Philip Morris Companies, Inc., et al., Case No. S095213; 28 Cal 4th 828; 123 Cal Rptr 2d 40; 50 P3d 751 (5 Aug 2002). SCB: 239 F3d 1029 (decision ending tobacco pusher immunity from litigation) (TPLP Analysis)

Philip Morris v Williams, 183 Or App 192; 51 P3d 670 (7 August 2002) (widow's case, verdict for $800,000 (econ) $79.5 million (punitive)).

In re Julie Anne, 121 Ohio Misc 2d 20; 780 NE2d 635; 2002 WL 2022117 rev 2002 WL 31387441; 2002 Ohio 4489 (Common Pleas, 27 August 2002) (pure air rights case, child protection, thorough court analysis of pertinent facts, one of the best reasoned decisions ever)

Betty Bullock v Philip Morris, Inc (Los Angeles County, Case No. BC 249171, 26 Sep 2002) (lung cancer case, $850,000 award) (context and TPLP analysis)

DeMatteo v DeMatteo, Case No. D-37432, 194 Misc 2d 640; 749 NYS2d 671; 2002 N Y Slip Op 22689 (Utica, NY, 9 Oct 2002) (pure air rights case in parental smoking context)

Jamie Reilly v [State of Michigan] Henry Grayson, Chris Daniels, and Joseph Cross, 2002 FED App 0397P; 310 F3d 519 (CA 6, 18 Nov 2002). SCB: 157 F Supp 2d 762 (smoke free air, prison case)

Flue-Cured Tobacco Coop. Stabilization Corp v United States EPA, 313 F3d 852 (CA 4, 11 Dec 2002). SCB: 857 F Supp 1137; 4 F Supp 2d 435 (See also Monique E. Muggli, Richard D. Hurt and James Repace, “The tobacco industry's political efforts to derail the EPA report on ETS,” 26 Am J Prev Med (#2) 167-177 [Feb 2004]).

Abid M. Husain Estate v Olympic Airways, ___ F3d ___ (CA 9, 12 Dec 2002) (context)

Irene Cruz-Vargas v JTI Japan Tobacco INT, No. 00-2334 (D.P.R.) aff'd by Irene Cruz-Vargas v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., 348 F3d 271 (CA 1, 2003)

U.S. v Akhdar, et al, Indictment (ED Mich, 4 Feb 2003) (See cigarette smuggling details, allegedly aiding terrorism)

Rauen v U. S. Tobacco Mfg. Ltd. Partnership, 319 F3d 891 (CA 7, 10 Feb 2003). SCB: 161 F Supp 2d 899 and 2001 WL 1223529

Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp v Pataki, ___ F3d ____ (CA 2, 13 Feb 2003). SCB: 2001 WL 636441 (upholding New York law banning direct (e.g., Internet) sale of cigarettes to New Yorkers by out-of-state merchants)

Abid M. Husain Estate v Olympic Airways, ___ US ___; ___ S Ct ___; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (12 March 2003) (stay issued). SCB: 110 F Supp 2d 1234 (context)

Sharon Price and Michael Fruth, et al v Philip Morris Co (Case No. 00-L-112, J. Nicholas Byron, Madison County Ct, Ill, 21 March 2003) (fraud case, misleading smokers to believe 'light' cigarettes are less harmful than regualar cigarettes; $7.1 billion awarded in compensation, and $3 billion to State) (PDF Text) (TPLP Analysis)

John Eastman v Philip Morris and Brown and Williamson Tobacco Corps (Fla. Jury, 3 April 2003) (re tobacco-caused lung disease, $3,255,000 verdict)

Darlene Robinson v Montana, 315 Mont 353; 68 P3d 750; 2003 MT 110 (25 April 2003) (one of a number of cigarette cost recovery cases)

Montgomery County, Maryland, et al. v. Anchor Inn Seafood Restaurant, 374 Md 327; 822 A2d 429 (2 May 2003)

James Enterprises, Inc. dba Cyclone Truck v City of Ames, __ IA __; 661 NW2d 150 (7 May 2003) (pre-emption state law)

Victoria Gallegos v Elite Model Management (14 May 2003) (jury award of $5.27 million re employer retaliation against employee for her freedom of expression seeking right to pure air)

R J Reynolds Tobacco Co v Engle, ___ So 2d ___ (Fla App, 21 May 2003). SCB: 672 So 2d 39 (smokers' rights class action case)

Gallegos v Elite Model Management, 1 Misc 3d 200; 768 NYS 2d 134; 2003 NY LEXIS 1009 (13 Aug 2003) (post-trial asset discovery and injunction affirmed)

STR Colebrook, Inc v Town of Colebrook, 200 NH LEXIS 74; 829 A2d 1089 (19 August 2003) (state pre-emption law)

Philip Morris v Williams, 02-1553; ___ US ___; 124 S Ct 56; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (Oregon, 7 Oct 2003) (widow's case, verdict for $800,000 (econ) $79.5 million (punitive)). SCB: 183 Or App 192; 51 P3d 670

West Virginia, W Va, SE 2d (4 December 2003) (West Virginia smoke-free air case, upholding smoking bans by Boards of Health in Cabell and Kanawha Counties).

Rhode Island v Narragansett Indian tribe's tax-free smoke shop, ___ F Supp ___ (D RI, Judge William Smith, 29 December 2003) (rejecting the claim that as a sovereign nation, it has a right to sell tobacco free of state taxes)

Victoria Gallegos v Elite Model Management, 2004 NY Misc LEXIS 1009 (6 Jan 2004) SCB: 1 Misc 3d 200; 768 NYS 2d 134; 2003 NY LEXIS 1009

Olympic Airways v Abid M. Husain Estate, ___ US ___; 124 S Ct 1221; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (24 Feb 2004) (travelers' rights case on pure air rights)

Tompkin v Philip Morris USA, Inc, 2004 Fed App 0091P (CA 6, ND Ohio, 30 March 2004)

U.S. v Philip Morris, Inc, 312 F Supp 2d 27 (D DC, 6 April 2004) (granting U.S. DOJ motions pursuant to D.C. Rule of Professional Conduct to disqualify former U.S. DOJ lawyer for 'side-switching' to an 'intervenor')

NYC C.L.A.S.H., Inc. v. City of New York, et al., Case 03 Civ. 5463 (VM); 315 F Supp 2d 461; 2004 U.S. Dist. LEXIS 5946 (SD NY, 21 April 2004) (upholding constitutionality of pure air rights smoking restrictions)

Lexington-Lafayette Cty Food and Beverage Ass'n v Urban County Government, No. 2003-SC-0978-TG; 131 SW3d 745; 2004 Ky LEXIS 94 (Kentucky, 22 April 2004) (upholding smoke-free pure air rights law, government has right and duty to protect safety and health)

RAMW v DC Board of Elections, CA No. 04-1783 (21 May 2004)

U.S. v Philip Morris, Inc, 300 F Supp 2d 61 (D DC, 23 June 2004) (doctrine of "unclean hands" does not apply in public interest cases; waiver means intentional relinquishment or abandonment of a known right)

Patricia Henley v Philip Morris Tobacco, of Altria Group Inc., ___ Cal ___; ___ Cal Rep ___; ___ P3d ___ (Cal., 17 September 2004) ($10.5 million damages award approved, after reduction from $26.5 million)

Zangrando v Kuder (Akron Ohio Trial, 20 September 2004) (condominium smoking nuisance case)

American Cancer Society v State of Montana, 325 Mont 70; 103 P3d 1085; 2004 Mont LEXIS 655; 2004 MT 376 (28 Dec 2004) (Details)

Virginia Prado Alvarez v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., No. 04-1695 (CA 1, 21 April 2005)

Robin Haines Merrill v Jim Bosser (Case No. 05-4239 COCE 53 (17th Judicial Circuit, Broward County, Florida, 29 June 2005) (Statement by ASH) (verdict to nonsmoker re condominium neighbor's tobacco smoke)

Tamara Silvius v Steve Silvius, Caroline Circuit Court, Virginia (23 February 2005) affirmed Va App No. 1466-04-2 (26 July 2005)

U.S. v Ahmed (D NY, Lackawanna, 27 July 2005) (News Article, multimillion-dollar cigarette smuggling case, from New York to Michigan)

Richard Boeken v Philip Morris (Calif Supreme Court, 8/10/2005) ($50 million award to killed smoker's family)

Lisa L. Day-Carter v Billy G. Day (Case No. 04 COA 74, 5th App Dist, Grafton, Ohio), ___ Ohio App ___; ___ NE2d ___ (22 August 2005) (News Article, ASH Analysis, parent case, smoker parent ordered to not smoke around child)

Philip Morris v Williams, ___ Ore ___; ___ P3d ___ (2 February 2006) (upheld a $79.5 million punitive damages award)

Philip Morris v Boeken, ___ US ___; ___ S Ct ___; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (20 March 2006) (leaving intact $50 million punitive damages award). SCB

Betty Bullock v Philip Morris USA, Inc., ___ Cal App ___; ___ Cal Rptr ___ (Friday, 21 April 2006) (upheld $28 million punitive damages award)

Panama and Sao Paulo v Altria Group Inc.'s Philip Morris USA, et al. ( New Castle County, J Richard Cooch, June 2006)

R J Reynolds Tobacco Co v Engle, ____ So 2d ___ (Florida Supreme Court (6 July 2006) (TPLP Analysis)

U. S. v Philip Morris USA Inc, f/k/a Philip Morris Inc, et al, __ F Supp 2d ___ (D DC, 17 Aug 2006) (TPLP Analysis)

People v Paul E. Renwick (Macomb Cnty Circ. Ct., Michigan, 28 September 2006) (conviction for causing fatal fire)

Coalition for Equal Rights Inc. and Shari Warren, Tavern Owner v State of Colorado, ___ F Supp 2d ___ (J. Lewis T. Babcock, D. Colorado, 19 October 2006) (Article on Federal Judge Upholding Constitutionality of Smoke-free Colorado Law)

Tobacco Companies v Kentucky , ___ F3d ___ (CA Ky, 29 October 2006)

Price, et al. v Philip Morris, 06-465, ___ US ___; ___ S Ct ___; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (27 November 2006) (Article). SCB

Germany v Parliament and Council (Case C-380/03, 12 December 2006) upholding banning most forms of cigarette advertising (Background Article)

Mitchell's Bar and Restaurant, Inc., et al. v Allegheny County, et al. (Ct of Common Pleas, 22 Dec 2006) (upholding smokefree ordinance going into effect 2 January 2007) (See Smokefree Pennsylvania's amicus brief and exhibits and "Preemption" by RWJF/AMA SmokeLess States.)

Philip Morris and R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co, ___ US ___; ___ S Ct ___; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (Florida, 1 Oct 2007) SCB (Article)

New Hampshire Motor Transport Ass’n v Rowe, 301 F Supp 2d 38 (Maine, _____ 2004)

New Hampshire Motor Transport Ass’n v Rowe, ___ F Supp 2d ___ (Maine, 27 May 2005)

G. Steven Rowe, Attorney General of Maine v New Hampshire Motor Transport Association, 448 F3d 66 (CA __, ______)

Dennis Steffes d/b/a Last Call and Coyotes v City of Lawrence (Kansas Supreme Court, 22 June 2007) (decision upholding smoking ban)

G. Steven Rowe, Attorney General of Maine v New Hampshire Motor Transport Association, ___ US ___; ___ S Ct ___; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (20 February 2008). SCB: 448 F3d 66.

Smith v Brown & Williamson Tobacco Corp., 275 S.W.3d 748, 810 (Mo. App. W.D. 2008) (citing Missouri Law Section 537.090, RSMo 2000 which "provides that in wrongful death cases 'the mitigating and aggravating circumstances attending the death may be considered by the trier of facts' in assessing damages.")

California vs Philip Morris, ___ US ___; ___ S Ct ___; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (17 March 2008) SCB: ___ Cal Rptr ___; ___ P3d ___

Iowa Bar Association Owners v. Iowa (Polk County Court, 4 August 2008) (Iowa smoke-free law not blocked, rejecting bar owners plea)

In the Matter of the Claim of Karen M. Kridel and Commissioner of Labor ex rel. Dibble & Miller, PC, 54 App Div 3d 465; 863 NYS2d 208 (Albany, 7 August 2008) (discharge for taking unauthorized breaks, unemployment compensation denied as "knowingly violating an employer's established policies and procedures has been held to constitute disqualifying misconduct")

People v Beydoun, 283 Mich App 314 (Michigan, 14 April 2009) (cigarette tax evasion case)

The Whitesell-Finnel Post No. 971 Veterans of Foreign Wars and Wayne G. Austin American Legion Post No. 2 v Newton, Kansas (Kansas Supreme Court, 5 March 2010) (decision declaring no right to smoke, background in news and anti-drug site)

United States v Philip Morris USA, Inc., 130 S. Ct. 3501 (2010). SCB: 449 F.Supp.2d 1, (D.D.C. 2006), aff'd 556 F.3d 1095 (CA DC, 2010)

Foucault-Funke American Legion Post 444 v Guy St. Germain, Exec Dir of the Western Upper Peninsula Health Dept and the Western Upper Peninsula Health Dept (File No. 10-6062-CZ, Circ. Ct., Baraga County, Michigan, filed 6 August 2010) (See rebuttal; and preliminary injunction issued ordering immediate compliance pending final adjudication of the smoke-free law, 15 October 2010) For the Michigan Department of Community Health Motion that had given rise to this Court Order, click here. The Final Order issued 27 December 2010, upheld the MI smoke-free law. See, e.g., "UP tavern loses bid to defy state's public smoking ban" (Detroit Free Press, 28 Dec 2010), and "Ruling on American Legion Smoking Ban" (Upper Michigan Source, 28 Dec 2010).

Casino Employees v Wynn Resorts, Ltd. d/b/a Wynn Las Vegas (Nevada, October 2010) (on case saying that "the casino failed to reasonably safeguard its workers from dangerous conditions caused by secondhand cigarette smoke. . . 'Worker safety is critical and well-recognized under the law. This is a tremendous decision for not only Wynn's employees, but also for workers at other casinos who for years have been unreasonably subjected to secondhand smoke,' said Jay Edelson, whose law firm, Edelson McGuire LLC is pursuing the case."

D.A.B.E., Inc. v. Toledo-Lucas Cty. Bd.of Health, 96 Ohio St.3d 250, 2002-Ohio-4172, 773 N.E.2d 536 ("the General Assembly [Legislature] has the authority to enact a public-smoking ban. D.A.B.E., Inc. v. Toledo-Lucas Cty. Bd. of Health, 96 Ohio St.3d 250, 2002-Ohio-4172, 773 N.E.2d 536 (¶ 54 says “Within its constitutional grant of powers, the General Assembly possesses both the authority to enact smoking legislation such as the regulation at issue and the prerogative to delegate that authority to local boards of health”).

Deer Park Inn v. Ohio Dept. of Health, 185 Ohio App.3d 524, 2009-Ohio-6836, 924 N.E.2d 898 (upholding Ohio's smoke-free law)

Fraternal Order of Eagles v City and Borough of Juneau (Alaska, 1 July 2011) (upholding smoking ban in private clubs as “The City has a legitimate interest in protecting the public from the well-established dangers of second-hand tobacco smoke.”) (Article)

Wymsylo v. Bartec, Inc., Slip Opinion No. 2012-Ohio-2187 (Ohio Supreme Court, 23 May 2012) ("The Smoke Free Workplace Act . . . is a health and occupational safety law that restricts smoking inside most public places, such as bars and restaurants, as well as workplaces." Said the Court: "The voters of Ohio also have a legitimate purpose in protecting the general welfare and health of Ohio citizens and workforce from the dangers of secondhand smoke in enclosed public places.")

Smith v Brown and Williamson Tobacco Corp, Case No. WD71918 (Mo. Ct. App., West. Dist., 2 October 2012) (remanded for trial on punitive damages)

Gallagher v City of Clayton, 699 F. 3d 1013 (CA 8, 8 Nov 2012) (rejecting smoker arguments against outdoor smoking ban)

State of New York v Grand River Enterprises Six Nations, et. al. (1 March 2013) (cigarette smuggling case, lawsuit by New York Attorney General)

Kim and Kai Chauncey vs. Bella Palermo Homeowner Association and TSG Independent Management (Jury sides with nonsmoking neighbors in secondhand smoke case at condominium, 12 March 2013)

Gallagher v City of Clayton, Missouri, Docket 12-1122, ___ US ___; ___S Ct ___; ___ L Ed 2d ___ (14 May 2013). SCB: CA 8 (rejecting smoker claim that smoking is a right)

Judith Berger v Philip Morris USA, Inc (Florida Federal Court Jury, 19 September 2014) ("evidence was introduced showing that 90 percent of daily cigarette smokers start smoking as teenagers and that the tobacco industry targeted youth for this very reason. . . . earlier one takes up smoking, the more likely they are to become addicted and the stronger that addiction.")

Kenneth Kerrivan v. R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co., Philip Morris USA, Brown & Williamson Tobacco Co., Liggett Group LLC and Lorillard Inc. (Middle District of Florida, Jury, 20-22 October 2014) (awarded $14.5 million in compensatory and punitive damages, having targeted him as a child) (50-Year Conspiracy; Article)

RELATED INFORMATION SITES
The Tobacco.org Lawsuits List
Tobacco Litigation Resources (Findlaw)
TCRC Case List
Cigarettes' Chemicals
The Coumarin Issue
House Report on Cigarette Hazards - 1889
Iowa's 1897 Reaction - Banning Cigarettes
Tennessee's 1897 Reaction - Banning Cigarettes
Michigan's 1909 Reaction - Banning Cigarettes
Thomas Edison's 1914 Analysis of Cigarettes
Cigarette - Cancer Data 1925
Tobacco Addiction Data 1527 - Present
How Doctors Know Tobacco Effects
Dangerous Tobacco
Supreme Court Tobacco Cases
Federal Appeals Court Tobacco Cases
Tobacco Advertising Ban Cases
Tobacco Company Business Practices Cases
Smoking-on-the-Job Cases
Divorce and Custody Cases
Bribery Underlying Pro-Tobacco Decisions
Forms List
http://tobacco.contentgrid.com/tobaccolaw/
"All Academic Research: Enduring
Effects of Tobacco Litigation"
Excerpt 1920-1929
Referencing Mirror Site

For more information about specific cases, a law library is most useful, and, if more data about a specific case is currently available at this site, the search engine below. Re any errors, omissions, or suggestions, please advise the webmaster. Your input is welcome.

Index of Subjects Currently At This Site

For Return to Top of Page

Please Email@TCPG with suggested additions to this list, or other comments.

Copyright © 1999, 2003 TCPG