| Welcome to the book, The Tobacco Habit: Its History and Pathology: A Study in Birth-Rates: Smokers Compared With Non-Smokers, by Herbert H. Tidswell, M.D. (1912).
It includes data on what is now a modern concern, the issue of abortion, showing the tobacco role in 53% of overall abortions, Tobacco pushers and their accessories conceal the breadth of tobacco effects, the enormity of the tobacco holocaust, and the long record of documentation. The concealment process is called the "tobacco taboo." Other pertinent words are "disinformation" and "censorship." Here is the text by Herbert H. Tidswell, M.D. (who entered medical school in 1873), of an early exposé (1912) of tobacco dangers. It cites facts (including generational impact facts) you don't normally ever see, due to the "tobacco taboo." The phrase "tobacco taboo" is the term for the pro-tobacco censorship policy—to not report most effects of tobacco. As you will see, information about the tobacco danger was already being circulated in 1912, 52 years before the famous 1964 Surgeon General Report. Be prepared. For example, women were often being blamed for sterility. But this data shows that the real culprit was tobacco, causing In that era, the word "abortion" had not yet been politicized to exclude tobacco-caused fetal deaths to evade/obstruct counting and preventing them. Now tobacco-caused fetal deaths are pretended to be "spontaneous," a word to conceal the tobacco-causation! In that more honest 1912 era, the words "abortion and miscarriage were synonymous." As an overview, prior to reading this book, please read our sites on tobacco's ingredients and on tobacco-caused abortion. |
The Tobacco Habit:
Its History and Pathology:
A Study in Birth-Rates: Smokers
Compared With Non-Smokers,
by Herbert H. Tidswell, M.D.
(London: J. & A. Churchill, 1912)
An Appeal to Medical Students
And all Members of the Medical Professions who are
true Christians and zealous in promoting true
Hygiene and Temperance
In Loving Memory of
A GOOD FATHER AND A GOOD MOTHER.
TO WHOM I AM INDEBTED, UNDER DIVINE PROVIDENCE,
FOR ALL MY SPIRITUAL AND TEMPORAL BLESSINGS. TO
MY MOTHER'S WISDOM AND MORAL COURAGE I OWE MY
EMANCIPATION FROM THE SLAVERY OF THE TOBACCO
HABIT, WHICH I UNHAPPILY ACQUIRED IN THE MEDICAL
SCHOOL OF ST. GEORGE'S HOSPITAL, LONDON.
"Is there no physician there? Why then is not the
health of the daughter of My people recovered?"
| Dedication | iv |
| Preface | vii |
| I.—An Appeal to Medical Students and all Members of the Medical Profession who are true Christians and zealous in the cause of Hygiene | 1-11 |
| II.—The History and Antiquity of the Tobacco Habit | 12-18 |
| III.—A List of the Names of the Medical Men who contributed Letters to The Lancet, to be found in Vol I, 1857, condemning the use of Tobacco | 19-24 |
| IV.—On "The Use and Abuse of Tobacco," by Wm. Marsden, M.D., living in Quebec in 1860, Fellow of the Medical Society of London | 25-30 |
| V.—Remarks on The Lancet Tobacco Controversy of 1857, by the Author | 31-41 |
| VI.—Mind your Mind and your Mind will mind your Body, and you will possess a sound Mind in a sound Body | 42-53 |
| VII.—A Letter from G. J. Russell, M.D., dated from Christchurch, New Zealand, 1907, to the Editor of Beacon Light, the official organ of the British Anti-Tobacco League | 54-59 |
| VIII.—The Evils of Tobacco Smoking in France. Letter from Dr. Hall. The Action of Tobacco on the Nervous System and the Heart. The Opinions of |

| French, English, and American Physicians. Malingering in the Army. Effects of Tobacco on Soldiers and Sailors | 60-69 |
| IX.—Twenty-four Cases of Tobacco Poisoning | 70-80 |
| X.—A Series of Thirty-eight Genealogical Histories of Families of Non-Smokers, with the number of Male and Female Births in each family; full particulars of the Miscarriages, Premature Births, Still-born Infants; Illnesses or Accidents in Pregnancy, Parturition, Lactation, and the ultimate Fate and State of each Child; with Tabular Abstract | 81-102 |
| XI.—A Series of Fifty-seven Histories of the Families of Smokers, with Similar Details; with Tabular Abstract | 103-137 |
| XII. —Tables of Comparison between Non-Smokers and Smokers in rates of Male and Female Infants; Conceptions; Abortions; Still-births; Ratio of Abortions and Still-births to Live-births; Mortality in first four years of life; Abnormal Confinements; Abscess of breast; Explanation of the causes of difference; Summary of defects in Class of Smokers | 138-152 |
| XIII.—Histories of the Families of ten Men who were Abusers of Alcohol and Tobacco, with Details as before, and Abstract | 153-160 |
| XIV.—Brief Records of the Families of Twenty-seven Non-Smokers among Acquaintances, Friends, and Patients not included in the other Histories; with Tabular Abstract | 161-166 |
| XV.—Abstract of the Families of Fifty-one Smokers among Acquaintances and Patients of all Classes; with Histories of selected Cases; Analytical Tables of Comparison and Explanations | 167-173 |
| XVI—Ratio of Sexes at Birth. A Method for estimating the Annual Number of Cases of Abortion (including Still-born Infants) which may be traced to the Abuse of Tobacco by the Husbands; also the Number of Cases of Abortion from various Causes independent of Tobacco | 174-180 |
| XVII.—The Action of Tobacco Dust on Workers in Tobacco Factories; Dangers to Pregnant Women; Excessive Mortality among Children of the Workers; International Congress against the Abuse of Tobacco; Observations by Drs. Drysdale, Kostrall, and Omar Bey; The Influence of Tobacco in causing Abortion and Abscess of Breast; Children Poisoned by Tobacco in the Mother's Milk; Nicotism the Danger in Turkey; Alcoholism and Nicotine the Danger in England | 181-186 |
| CHAPTER XVIII.—Marriage; Causes of the falling Birth-rates in Great Britain and her Australian Colonies, and in many European Countries; Sterility in the Male and Female, considered separately and together; Opinions of Curling and Arthur Cooper on Causes of Male Sterility; Opinions of Dr. Matthews Duncan on Causes of Female Sterility; Tables showing age constitution of Bachelors and Spinsters at time of Marriage | 187-208 |
| XIX.—Table showing the Population of the United Kingdom each Year from 1821 to 1910, with the Annual Consumption of Tobacco; Table showing Increase of Population and Increase of Tobacco consumed in Decennial Periods; Table showing the fall in the Birth-rates in the United Kingdom, the Colonies of Australasia, the Chief Nations of Europe; Table showing Rise in Birth-rates in the Province of |
| Ontario, Ceylon, Jamaica, Bulgaria, and Japan; Table showing Relative Fertility of Bich and Poor; Reasons for attributing these falling Birth-rates to the recent Increase in the Smoking Habit | 209-218 |
| XX —Analysis of Birth-rates of Smokers and Non-Smokers; Cause of low Birth-rate traced to great loss of Virile Power among Men, the result of habitual Abuse of Tobacco; Table covering a Period of Seventy Years, showing Marriage Rate, Birth-rate, Ratio of Births of Males to Females, and Ratio of Deaths of Males to Females; Table showing Fertility and Masculinity in my Classes; Table of Birth-rate and Masculinity in Scotland; Table showing Ratio of Males and Females in different Countries; Defects in general Birth-rate in population indentical with those of my Classes of Smokers | 219-232 |
| XXI.—Table showing Decline of Birth-rate and Masculinity in France; Table showing Masculinity in Illegitimate Births; Tables showing enormous excess of Male Infants to Females among Still-births in various Cities and Countries of Europe; Table showing Rate of Still-births in various Countries | 233-239 |
| XXII.—The Aim of Hygiene; The Office of Physicians; The Oath of Hippocrates; The Narcotic Slumbers of the British Medical Association, disturbed by the National Insurance Bill; The Baptismal Vow of the Christian | 240-246 |
| Ed. Note: Where footnotes or references to other books, or to medical journals, are given by Dr. Tidswell, generally they are in abbreviated form. The editor has provided a fuller bibliographic citation. |
AN APPEAL TO MEDICAL STUDENTS AND ALL MEMBERS OF
THE MEDICAL PROFESSION WHO ARE TRUE CHRISTIANS,
AND ZEALOUS IN THE CAUSE OF HYGIENE.
BROTHER CHIPS AND FELLOW-LABOURERS,
"For we are labourers together with God: ye are God's husbandry, ye are God's building. . . . Know ye not that ye are are the temple of God, and that the Spirit of God dwelleth in you? If any man defile the temple of God, him shall God destroy; for the temple of God is holy, which temple ye are" (1 Corinthians iii. 9, 16, 17).It is obvious that St. Paul taught that the body of a Christian is holy and must not be abused. We, therefore, who profess to be Christian medical men, must not forget the high position we occupy as fellow-workers with God. But if we make the mistake of placing our own glorification as the chief purpose of life, and forget to honour God as we should, then our work will be in vain, for God will not bless us. We are specially called upon to be living witnesses for Christ, and to lead "godly, righteous, and sober lives."
| Article XXXVII.— "Of the Civil Magistrates. The King's Majesty hath the chief power in this Realm of England, and other his Dominions, unto whom the chief Government of all Estates of this Realm, whether they be Ecclesiastical or Civil, in all causes doth appertain, and is not, nor aught to be, subject to any foreign jurisdiction." |
We may regard our King as the head of the whole profession. Does he not trust to our honour and intelligence, as legally qualified and registered practitioners, to be faithful and diligent teachers of the laws of health in his realms and dominions?
| Ed. Note: In 1868, James Parton had said likewise. |
Consequently the single and married women do not enjoy their due share of the society of the stronger and more selfish sex. The men have made a poor exchange, if they have forfeited the love and respect of womankind for the comfort and suffering associated with indulgence in narcotism.
| Ed. Note: It was nearly a century later before this finally happened, when the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders, 3rd ed., DSM-III (1980), was issued, listing smoking as a mental disorder. |
We dare not give any encouragement to the continued indulgence in any drug
THE HISTORY AND ANTIQUITY OF THE TOBACCO HABIT.
"There are about thirty species of nicotiana, and some of these are natives or naturalized in most parts of the world; for, although its use was unknown in Europe before the discovery of America, indulgence in its use is so common, nay universal, among the Chinese, and their forms of bamboo pipes and their methods of inhaling so peculiar, that Pallas and many others have been led to believe that the custom is aboriginal with them, and that they and other nations of the East were acquainted with its use before its introduction into the West. Two or more species, N. Sinensis and N. Fructicasa, are also believed to be natives of China, and N. Nepaulensis, of Hindustan."Chardin states that its use was common in Persia, long before the discovery of America, and that it is a native of that country, or at least was naturalized there as early as 1260. The origin of the word tobacco is doubtful. Like coffee and Peruvian bark, tobacco encountered violent opposition when its half-inebriating and soothing properties recommended it to popular use.
"Many governments attempted to restrain its consumption by penal edicts. The Sultan Amurath IV. forbade its importation into Turkey, and condemned to death those found guilty of smoking, from a fear that it produced barrenness. The Grand Duke of Moscow prohibited its entrance into his dominions under pain of the knout for the first offence, and death for the next; and in other parts of Russia the practice of smoking was denounced,
and all smokers condemned to have their noses cut off. The Shah of Persia and other sovereigns were equally severe in their enactments; and Pope Urban VIII. anathematized all those who smoked in churches."In 1654 the Council of one of the Swiss cantons cited all smokers before them; every innkeeper was ordered to inform against all those who were found smoking in their houses. But not only legislators, but philosophers, entered into a crusade against tobacco."
"Surely smoke becomes a kitchen, better than a dining chamber, and yet it makes a kitchen oftentimes in the inward parts of men, soyling and infecting them with an unctuous and oyly kind of soote as hath been found in some great tobacco takers, that after their death were opened [autopsied]."
| Ed. Note: Compare Prof. John Hinds' 1882 analysis. |
"These men that were thus brought back, were the first that, I know of, that brought into England, that Indian plant which they call tobacco and nicotia, which they used against crudities,*____________
being taught it by the Indians. Certainly from that time forward it began to grow into great request, and to be sold at a high rate, whilst in a short time, many men, everywhere, some for wantonness, some for health sake, with an unsafciable depire and greediness, sucked in the stinking smoke thereof, through an earthen pipe, which presently they blew out again at their nostrils, insomuch that tobacco shops are now as ordinary as taverns and tap-houses."
|
"Tobacco engages
Both sexes, all ages, The poor, as well as the wealthy, From court to the cottage, From childhood to dotage, Both those that are sick and the healthy. It plainly appears,
|
|
"To such a height with these is fashion grown,
They feed their very nostrils with a spoon." |
| "Great Britain— | ||||||||||||||||||||
| Local Officers | 32,229
| | Bandsmen | 13,904
| | Corps Cadets | 5,088
| "Colonies and Foreign Countries— | |
| | Local Officers | 24,457
| | Bandsmen | 7,208
| | Corps Cadets | 5,191
| |
A LIST OF THE NAMES OF THE MEDICAL MEN WHO
CONTRIBUTED LETTERS TO The Lancet, TO BE FOUND
IN VOL. I., 1857, CONDEMNING THE USE OF TOBACCO.
(1) Samuel Solly, F.R.S., Surgeon to St. Thomas's Hospital, London.(2) David Johnson, M.R.C.S., Dudley
(3) J. Pidduck, M.D., London.
(4) W. Pugh, M.D.
(5) Maurice Evans, M.R.C.S.
(6) W. Cortis, M.R.C.S., Filey.
(7) J. Ronald Martin, F.R.S., London.
(8) J. Higginbottom, F.R.S., Nottingham.
(9) S. Booth, L.S.A., Huddersfield.
(10) W. McDonald.
(11) C. B. Garrett, M.D., Hastings.
(12) G. Butler, M.R.C.S.
(13) Dr. Schneider.
| "Sir,—I have perused with great interest the tobacco controversy that has lately been carried on in your pages. Permit me, as an Oxford man, to bear witness to the |
-19-
| bad effects of 'the weed and the pipe.' As far as my experience goes, it is my opinion that nine out of ten first-class men are non-smokers, or, at least, smoke so little as not to deserve the name of smokers. Again, its weakening effects are borne witness to by the fact that men in training for boat races are strictly prohibited tobacco.
"When, sir, I see the pale and sallow faces of habitual smokers; when hear them deplore the habit (or rather the necessity); when I hear them confess that they are unable to begin their day's work without a pipe (or, at least, they would be miserable without the indulgence); when I see our College servants aping their masters, and thinking it fine to be seen with a villainous cigar or 'short clay' in their mouths; when I see the boys of Oxford (and even the little white-robed choristers of our College chapel) taking up the odious habit, making their little faces thin and pale, and running their constitutions; when I see all this, what conclusion can I come to but that tobacco is an evil—a tremendous evil; that Sir Walter Ralegh has been a curse to his country; that to him the sickly faces, stunted forms, and shortened lives of so many of our once sturdy countrymen, are in a great degree owing." |
| "To the young man, and more especially to the medical student, in whom we are peculiarly interested, we would say: Shun the habit of smoking as you would shun self-destruction. As you value your physical and moral well-being, avoid a habit, which for you can offer no advantage to compare with the dangers you incur by using it. The bright hopefulness of youth, its undaunted aspirations, and its ardent impulses, require no halo of smoke though which to look forward upon the approaching struggle of life. Your manner of living must be bad indeed if you require anything further than sleep, exercise, and diet, to fit you for your duties as students. Your minds must be emasculated indeed, and arrant cowards must you be, totally unfit for the stern realities of what is to come, if you cannot face your present few and comparatively small anxieties, without having recourse to the daily use of narcotics. We speak from a large experience of medical students, when we say that the intemperate smoker is the intemperate indulger, as a general rule, in all that partakes of the nature of sensual gratification. It matters not that |
-20-
| many may, and do, pass through the ordeal unscathed. Vast numbers do not. Listless minds and languid bodies, slakeless thirst and shaking hands, delirium tremens, madness, and death, we have distinctly and surely seen to follow the unhallowed indulgence in youths who began their studies with bright promise of success, with fair characters, and honest purposes. It is not open to impressible and wavering youths to say, 'Thus far will I go, and no further.'
"To commence the downward course is too easy—to retrace the false step is too difficult; the risk is too great, the advantage too infinitesimally small, the interests at stake too supremely important, to allow the student once to begin. It is no sign of manliness to toy with danger, and sport upon the brink of a precipice. The impulse which may plunge the unreflecting boy into ruin may come, he knows not when, nor with how great force; let him prove his strength by avoiding, not by courting, danger. "Let us enquire further, whether the physiological effects produced in the course of smoking afford any indications to what constitutes excess. Profuse salvation can hardly be compatible with the idea of moderation. Perpetual irritation of a mucous membrane can hardly be kept up with impunity. A large proportion of smokers must be aware that heartburn, eructations and apepsia surely follow one or two pipes, or one or two cigars, beyond the wonted allowance. The same excess is certainly followed by loss of appetite, and especially by loss of morning relish of food. Let the pulse be watched. Does it not decline in frequency below the normal standard, and is it not irregular after a very slight excess? Do not palpitation and prœcordial anxiety much oftener annoy the habitual smoker than he would exactly like to confess? Is not the inclination to seek the recumbent posture, or to respire cold air, of frequent occurrence, when the smoker would hardly like to own it? Do not giddiness, dimness of vision, tremors, nausea, clammy perspirations, and tinnitus aurium frequently occur in the course of a long smoke? And do not each and all of these effects clearly and irrefragably establish excess in every case? We affirm most unhesitatingly that, setting aside idiosyncrasies, there is hardly an habitual smoker to excess who cannot be |
| condemned by the most casual observation of his bodily functions. And the further we move upwards in the social gamut, the more striking will be the physiological evidences of excess in every individual case.
"It is almost unnecessary to make a separate inquiry into the pathological conditions which follow upon excessive smoking. They have been referred to by the way. Moreover, abundant evidence has been adduced in the correspondence in our columns of the gigantic evils which attend the abuse of tobacco. Let it be granted at once that there is such a thing as moderate smoking, and let it be admitted that we cannot accuse tobacco of being guilty of the whole of Cullen's "Nosology," it still remains that there is a long catalogue of frightful penalties attached to its abuse. "Let us briefly recapitulate:
"(2) As people are generally constituted, to smoke more than one or two pipes of tobacco, or one or two cigars daily is excess. "(3) Youthful indulgence in smoking is excess. "(4) There are physiological indications which, occurring in any individual case, are criteria of excess. "We most earnestly desire to see the habit of smoking diminished, and we entreat the youth of this country to abandon it altogether. Let them to give up a dubious pleasure for a certain good. Ten years hence we shall receive their thanks." |
| Ed Note: This 1857 definition of excess smoking = abolishment of smoking by 1867.
Tobacco pushers are cited as killing about a thousand of their best customers every day. Tobacco pushing thus cannot continue unless, daily, new youths are hooked. This is what the FDA found to be so. Tobacco craving does not allow for the non-excess criteria, e.g., no morning smoking, hence typically most all smokers smoke to excess. See the 99½% data. |
ARGUMENTS OF A DEFENDER OF TOBACCO,
AND THE ANSWER THERETO.
| "The fact of smoking being almost universal, appears alone to indicate that there can be no very great harm in it; and so long as thousands and thousands by their acts and its results prove to me that smoking is not injurious, so long shall I despise all theories and statements to the contrary." |
| "The absurdity of this argument for this worse than useless practice, appears evident from the following similar examples of reasoning. Opium eating is very prevalent in some other countries, intemperance in others; ergo, there can be no very great harm resulting from them. It is, in my judgment, anything but an evidence of wisdom, to argue the harmlessness of any practice on the ground of its universality." |
| "It seems very difficult for any man to go through this world with his eyes open, without perceiving thousands of persons who are suffering physically, mentally and morally, through indulgence in this obnoxious habit. What then is the testimony of facts on the subject of smoking? Why, for one inveterate smoker who will bear testimony favourable to the practice, ninety-nine such of the candid of these, are found to declare their belief, that this practice is injurious; and I scarcely ever met one habitual smoker, who did not in his candid moments, regret his commencement of the practice. It is a certain fact, that devoted smokers are liable both to constitutional and local disorders, of very serious characters. Among the former we notice giddiness, sickness, vomiting, dyspepsia, diarrhœa, angina pectoris; diseases of the liver, pancreas, and heart, nervousness, amaurosis, paralysis, apoplexy, atrophy, deafness, and mania.
"Most of these results I have selected from authors of some locus standi, amongst whom I may mention Doctors Prout, Brigat, Laycock, Radcliffe, Ranking, Pereira, Orfeila, Trousseau, Johnstone, Sir Benjamin Brodie, and Professor Lizars." |
| "That a poisonous substance like tobacco, whether in powder, juice, or vapour cannot be brought in obntact with an absorbing surface like mucous membrane without in many cases producing disorder of the system, which the consumer is probable quite ready to attribute to any other cause than that which could render it necessary for him to deprive himself of what he considers not merely a luxury, but an article actually necessary for his existence.
"The quantity of this poisonous weed entered for 'home consumption,' in the eleven months ending November 1856, was 29,776,082 pounds. The deleterious |
| "Sir,—Having had much experience of the baneful effects of smoking in my own country, Germany, which may be considered 'the great tobacco furnace of the age,' which is affected by her reeking atmosphere in many ways. I trust that my opinion may have some weight with your readers.
"The tendency of Germans to diseases of the lungs may be traced to their incredible passion for smoking, and our principal medical men and physiologists compute that out of twenty deaths of men between the ages of eighteen and twenty-five, ten originate in the waste of the constitution by smoking. "So frequently is vision impaired by the constant use of tobacco, that spectacles may be said, to be a part and parcel of a German, as a hat is to an Englishman. "In America, likewise, where my practice has extended, I have noted the same pernicious effects, and it is a well attested fact that the Americans wear themselves out by the use of tobacco." |
ON "THE USE AND ABUSE OF TOBACCO,"
BY WM. MARSDEN, M.D., LIVING IN QUEBEC IN 1860,
FELLOW OF THE MEDICAL SOCIETY OF LONDON.
| "I WAS asked a few days since by one of our ablest surgeons and most distinguished physicians, whether I had remarked the decided increase in the number of deaths from diseases of the brain since my coming into practice. Having admitted the proposition, my friend whose shrewdness and quickness of perception is characteristic, was disposed to assign as the principal cause the character and quality of the spirituous liquors so largely indulged in by all classes. My own experience and opinion, however, turn to another cause—the excessive use of tobacco, and had I not since laid my hand on Dr. Lizar's invaluable book, my own observation in the course of a long and extensive practice would have furnished me with proofs innumerable.
"For several years past the discussion of what has been called the 'tobacco question' has engaged the attention of medical, as well as non-medical writers in Great Britain, and my quondam fellow-student, Mr. Solly, now a surgeon of St. Thomas's Hospital, London, has taken a prominent part in the discussion, and although the evils of excessive smoking prevail as extensively in Quebec, as in Great Britain, the medical profession to which the public looks as the rational exponent of sound principles in relation to man's health and physical habits, has hitherto been almost silent on the subject. If any medical man feels that by simply raising his voice he may |
| be the means of saving the life, or preserving the health of a single fellow being, who may he unconsciously shortening his days by indulging in what he calls an innocent pastime and luxury, he is culpably negligent if he remains silent.
"'The profession,' says Mr. Solly, 'have no idea of the ignorance of the public regarding the nature of tobacco. Even intelligent, well educated men stare in astonishment when you tell them tobacco is one of the most powerful poisons we possess. Now is this right? Has the medical profession done its duty? Ought we not, as a body, to have told the public that of all our poisons, it is the most insidious, uncertain, and in full doses the most deadly?' "Dr. Lizars enumerates the constitutional effects of tobacco by stating that they are 'numerous and varied, consisting of giddiness, sickness, vomiting, dyspepsia, vitiated taste of the mouth, loose bowels, diseased liver, congestion of the brain, apoplexy, palsy, mania, loss of memory, amaurosis, deafness, nervousness, emasculation, and cowardice.' "Frightful as is this list of ills, I can from my own experience endorse its accuracy, and yet how large a number of our own profession are addicted to the vice, and how fatal must be the effect of their example upon the unthinking. "Professor Laycock, of Edinburgh University, says in a most temperate paper in the Medical Gazette, October 2, 1846: 'I have known many instances in which I was unable to prove that the ordinary use of tobacco did any harm; I have known many more in which I could prove that it did do harm; and I have not known any good from it that might not have been obtained by other less objectionable means.' "I will only make a few more extracts from Dr. Lizar's paper, in order to support the view I have enunciated that tobacco is the fruitful source of paralytic affections: "'Congestion of the brain, which is a frequent precursor of palsy, occurs almost only in those much addicted to smoking, in whom a cigar is never out of the mouth. It is denoted by headache, want of sleep, or rather restless nights, and occasionally flushing of the countenance. Apoplexy has been noticed by several authors supervening the smoking of tobacco, also the immoderate use of snuff. |
|
The form of palsy produced by excessive smoking is almost always hemiplegia, and is usually incurable. Mania is a fearful result of the excessive use of tobacco, two cases of which I have witnessed. I have also to mention that a gentleman called on me and thanked me for my observations on tobacco, and related to me with deep emotion what had occurred in his own family from smoking tobacco. Two amiable younger brothers had gone deranged and committed suicide.'
"'I lately visited a gentleman in a lunatic asylum,' says Dr. Lizars, 'labouring under general paralysis, and his mind becoming idiotic. On corresponding with his former medical attendant, I understand his habits were temperate as regarded drink, but he worked hard in a mercantile house and smoked to excess.' "Dr. Webster cites among the causes of mental diseases the great use of tobacco, and he supports this opinion by a reference to the statistics of insanity in Germany. "'Loss of memory,' says Dr. Lizars, 'takes place in an extraordinary degree in the smoker, much more so than in the drunkard.' "A valued and talented medical friend, whose pipe is scarcely out of his mouth when at leisure, is an instance of the foregoing condition, and who, besides, suffers from fearful neuralgic attacks of the head; but alas! I have failed to convince him that tobacco is in any way the cause. To all who have suffered or may be suffering under the pernicious influences of tobacco, I cannot give any more useful or proper advice than is contained in the stereotyped phrase of Dr. Lizars, in the treatment of the different species of disease, induced by the use of tobacco, 'Throw away tobacco for ever.' |
| Medical men, who have eyes for such things, can see the baneful effects of immoderate smoking writ large on nearly every part of the mucous membrane of the throat. It is often the abuse of tobacco that is at the bottom of chronic congestion or other deviations from the normal condition of the throat which are put down to other causes.
"The effects of tobacco on the body are both general and local; it acts on the nervous centres and on the heart, as well as on the parts with which the smoke or the juice comes immediately in contact. It usually finds expression in what is vaguely called 'nervousness,' the pulse becomes flurried, and the muscles more or less relaxed and unsteady: this is why smoking is so strictly forbidden to men training for athletic feats. "An occasional pipe or cigar would probably not be hurtful, but trainers are unanimous in forbidding tobacco in any form. The cause of their attitude in this matter is, no doubt, the fear that moderation might lead to excess, and convinced as I am of the deplorable effects of over-indulgence in smoking on steadiness and precision of muscular movement, I cannot say that I feel surprised at the apprehension of trainers. "So marked is the effect of tobacco in relaxing the whole of the muscular system, that before the days of chloroform it was employed in surgical operation, in which it was necessary that the muscles should be perfectly limp. "It will thus be readily understood that under the influence of a drug possessing these properties, the delicate adjustments of the complicated vocal machinery are to some extent disordered, and the voice is out of tune and harsh. "Something analagous to what takes place in the eye as the result of the abuse of tobacco occurs in the larynx, or in the part of the brain which governs the movement of that organ. Oculists are familiar with "tobacco amblyopia," that is, dimness of sight, due to what may be called figuratively, blurring of the retina by tobacco smoke. "The tongue often suffers severely from the effects of tobacco. Small excoriations, blisters, superficial inflammation, and white patches are formed on the surface of the organ, and a permanently unhealthy condition is |
| induced, which in those predisposed to cancer is apt, under the influence of advancing age, or as the result of prlonged vocal irritation, to lead to the development of that disease.
"The same observation applies to the superficial ulceration which affects the sides of the root of the tongue. In this situation there are a number of delicate projections, or so-called "papillœ," the exquisitely fine points of which readily become inflamed when exposed to irritation. It is in this situation that cancer of the tongue is exceedingly apt to commence. "Smoking at times causes chronic inflammation of the lips, which gives rise to cracks which are always very troublesome, and not infrequently end in deadly disease. "The effects of smoking on the throat, when the habit has not been too long indulged in, can as a rule be easily cured by the simple remedy of discontinuing the practice which engenders them. In considering the evils produced by smoking, it should be borne in mind that there are two bad qualities in the fumes of tobacco: the one is the poisonous nicotine, and the other is the high temperature of the burning tobacco. The Oriental hookah, in which the smoke is cooled by being passed through water before reaching the mouth, is probably the least harmful form of indulgence in tobacco; and the cigarette, which is so much in vogue now-a-days, is most certainly the worst. It owes this 'bad eminence' to the very mildness of its action, people being tempted to smoke all day long, and easily accustoming themselves to inhale the fumes into their lungs, and thus saturating their lungs with poison. "If smoking is indulged in to excess the habit is always injurious, and I am sure that a great many persons either cannot see, or wilfully shut their eys to, the 'scientific frontier' which separates moderation from abuse. "To conclude with a little practical advice: Let him who wishes to keep in the 'perfect way' refrain from inhaling smoke, and take it as an axiom, that the man in whom tobacco increases the flow of saliva to any marked degree is not intended by nature to smoke." |
| Ed. Note: Related practical actions are: an Iowa-type cigarette manufacturing ban, and prosecuting pushers for the deaths they have caused. |
The Opinions of A Parsee
REMARKS ON The Lancet TOBACCO CONTROVERSY OF 1857,
BY THE AUTHOR.
| Ed. Note: As per what happened to other tobacco-dominated nations. |
|
The Human Brain: Its Configuration, Structure, Development, and Physiology (London: Longman, Rees, Orme, Brown, Green and Longman, 1836)
The Human Brain: Its Structure, Physiology and Diseases, With a Description of the Typical Forms of Brain in the Animal Kingdom (London, Longman, Brown, Green and Longmans, 1847) The Human Brain: Its Structure, Physiology and Diseases, With a Description of the Typical Forms of Brain in the Animal Kingdom (Philadelphia, Lea and Blanchard, 1848) The Human Brain: Its Structure, Physiology and Diseases, With a Description of the Typical Forms of Brain in the Animal Kingdom. From the 2d London ed. (Philadelphia: Lea and Blanchard, 1848) Surgical Experiences, The Substance of Clinical Lectures (London, Hardwicke, 1865) |
| Ed. Note: By 2001, we know education does not work. Better solutions: adopting Iowa-style cigarette manufacturing bans everywhere; criminal prosecutions of tobacco pushers for the deaths they have caused. |
| "The wrong shall fail,
The right prevail, With peace on earth, Goodwill to men." |
MIND YOUR MIND AND YOUR MIND WILL MIND YOUR BODY,
AND YOU WILL POSSESS A SOUND MIND IN A SOUND BODY.
What answer does our Lord give to this question; he answers,
It seems to me, thefore, it is the duty of all who know the evil effects of smoking, to do all they can to warn those who are ignorant. Every man knows that smoking is particularly detrimental to boys under twenty-one. It will stop their growth, weaken their minds, and make them short-winded and weak. Do boys know all this?