P. S. Wales, former surgeon-general, U. S. Navy, wrote the following:
| "After disastrous results from permitting the use of tobacco by the cadets at West Point, in 1881 the authorities prohibited smoking absolutely." |
October, 1896, Dr. Larned wrote:
| "My conviction of the unmingled benefits accruing to the graduates of the Military Academy by the prohibition of tobacco is absolute. Unquestionably the most important matter in the health history of the students at this Academy is that relating to the use of tobacco. I have urged upon the superintendent that the future |
____________
1Published by permission from The Century Company.
-70-
| health and usefulness of the lads educated at this school required the absolute interdiction of tobacco. In this opinion, I have been sustained not only by all my colleagues, but by all sanitarians in military and civic life whose views I have been able to learn." |
George Elwers, a former student at the University of Wisconsin, says:"I know that any habit is hard to get out of; and that it is hard to indulge moderately in anything without going to excess. For these two reasons I have never started smoking. I have ample proof here at the University of Wisconsin that cigarettes are harmful, and that they do not help a fellow in any way. Since last October, when I entered the university, I have found only one fellow who sneered when I said, 'No, thank you, I don't smoke.' In the fraternity rushing I got in, and he was left out. Every girl that I have been intimate with has told me she was glad I didn't smoke. Many freshmen, in spite of their smoking, seem to get high standing, but when we look at the senior class, the best men do not smoke. Either they have cut it out, or they have dropped back in work."
Probably the conditions found at Wisconsin by this student occur at most colleges and universities where tobacco is tolerated.
| Ed. Note: See related data by Dr. John Hinds, pages 94-95 (1882) and by Dr. R. B. Carter, page 489 (1906). |
According to Lucy Page Gaston, superintendent of the Anti-Cigarette League, some fellow who is popular in college is often given a percentage from all cigarette orders taken from students. He is even given, for free distribution among students, various brands of cigarettes and thus helps to fasten upon the sons of parents
-71-
who object seriously one of the most harmful habits known among men. The man who obtains his college education in this manner is an offender against society, and the institution which does not use every means to prevent such a practice is not worthy of the boys that come from homes where high moral and religious principles obtain, only to be debauched while in college by a vile and debasing drug.
The writer has no knowledge of this alleged practice, but he was informed on one occasion, by a senior who was acting as chairman of an entertainment committee, that a local firm had furnished cigars for free distribution at a meeting of all men of a certain college. The writer was at another time present at a gathering of college men, under the auspices of the institution, for the entertainment of the alumni, at which cigars and cigarettes were distributed free to all who would take them from the freshmen up. On inquiry, he was informed that the cigars and the cigarettes had been furnished free of charge by a local firm. This in no way excuses the institution, and it is the conviction of many thoughtful persons that colleges that cannot entertain their students and alumni without furnishing free tobacco, whether voluntarily or by imposition, might better not entertain them at all.
Dr. Winfield S. Hall [Ph.D., M.D.], professor of physiology in the Northwest University Medical School, is responsible for the following:"Tobacco does much to undermine the success of young men. Why? Because it is the entering wedge of two lines of dissipation, either of which may defeat success. The first line is the dissi-
-72-
pation of money for things unnecessary. The second line of dissipation is sense gratification. One uses tobacco partly because of its flavor and partly for the sedative action which it exerts upon the nervous system. It is just this sedative effect which steals away a young man's vigilance and alertness and handicaps him in the struggle for success. The use of tobacco paves the way to other dissipation by requiring a compensating stimulant to overcome its sedative effect and by making common, wholesome food taste insipid and flat. A vast majority of drunkards were smokers before they were drinkers. The mental attitude and lack of resistance which permits a man to smoke is likely also to permit other forms of dissipation more destructive in their influence. Though many professional men use tobacco, I have yet to hear the first one advise a young man or a boy to begin its use."
This statement is made by a man of high standing in the medical world, who has had large experience with college men.
The following is from the Journal of Education for March 17, 1914:"Dr. Arthur Dumont Rush, instructor of physiology in the University of Vermont, puts groups of medical students through various smoking experiments. His conclusion is that smoking reduces the mental efficiency of the smoker 10.5 per cent. There is damage done to muscle and brain, he finds; but nicotine does not do it, because he cannot find any in cigar and pipe smoke (his results differ from those obtained by others in thus respect). Fifteen students, who had come from all classes and differed
-73-
considerably in physical characteristics, were chosen for the experiments. There was also an artificial smoking machine employed. The vapors were collected in receptacles and analyzed. Dr. Rush accepts the conclusions from experiments at Yale University that within half an hour after smoking a cigar the muscular power falls 25 per cent. He is chiefly concerned, however, with the effect on mental efficiency. All the instructor's subjects were requested not to smoke for several hours before beginning the test.
- "The first was the 'E' test, before and after smoking. Twelve lines of capital letters, closely placed, were presented, and the students were required to cross out all the E's. This is a test which has been given by Professor Muensterberg and others.
- "Another test requires the subject to say all the words which flow into his mind after a word is spoken to him which suggests a series. This is called the 'chain association.'
"One series of 120 tests on each of the 15 men, it is reported by Dr. Rush, shows that tobacco smoking produces 10.5 per cent decrease in efficiency of the brain. The greatest loss was in imagery, 22 per cent; so that the idea that smoke stimulates the fancy and that smoking makes the mind alert is not sustained by experiments."
We give below a table from the Ohio Wesleyan University, constructed by Dean W. G. Hormell, to show the relation of the tobacco habit to scholarship in 1911-12 and 1912-13. In this table 2 means an average of B, and 1 means below B.
-74-
| 1911 | - | 1912 | 1912 | - | 1913
| No. | Av. Grade | Per cent using tobacco | No. | Av. grade | Per cent using tobacco
| Seniors av. 2 and above | 23 | 2.37 | 16 | 40 | 2.47 | 5
| Seniors av. 1 and below | 9 | .76 | 44 | 14 | .72 | 64
| Juniors av. 2 and above | 38 | 2.42 | 8 | 25 | 2.29 | 20
| Juniors av. 1 and below | 19 | .73 | 58 | 10 | .68 | 40
| Sophomores av. 2 and above | 25 | 2.38 | 12 | 22 | 2.31 | 19
| Sophomores av. 1 and below | 26 | .61 | 70 | 38 | .39 | 50
| Freshmen av. 2 and above | | | | 26 | 2.39 | 15
| Freshmen av. 1 and below | | | | 61 | .49 | 40
| Specials av. 2 and above | | | | 3 | 2.16 | 33
| Specials av. 1 and below | | | | 19 | .23 | 53 | | | | | | | | | | | |
By summarizing the figures in the table, we find that 16 per cent of the high grades and 521/8 per cent of the low grades were obtained by the smokers, conversely, 84 per cent of the high grades and 475/8 per cent of the low grades were obtained by the non-smokers. This agrees with the results obtained in many other colleges and universities as given below.
The late Dr. Jay W. Seaver, who for many years made a close and accurate study of Yale students in relation to the use of tobacco, says:"Out of our highest scholarship men only a very small per cent (about five) use tobacco, while of the men who do not get appointments, about 60 per cent are tobacco users. The kind of mind that permits its possessor to become addicted to a habit that is primarily offensive and deteriorating is the kind of mind that will be graded low on general intellectual tests."
Dr. Seaver studied the effects of tobacco using
-75-
among Yale students for nine years. During this time, he found that smokers who entered Yale were fifteen months older than the non-smokers, but only weighed 14 kilos more than the non-smokers, who averaged more than a year younger. Though older, the smokers averaged .7 of a centimeter shorter and 80 cubic centimeters less in lung capacity. In a study of the men in a class at Yale, he found that the non-smokers gained over 10 per cent more in weight than the habitual smokers, 24 per cent more in height, 26.7 per cent more in chest measurement, and 77 per cent more in lung capacity.
Dr. George L. Meylan's study of Columbia students showed that the smokers had distinctly poorer scholarship. His results have been tabulated thus:
| Classification of Students
| Average marks at entrance
| Marks during first two years
| Failures during first two years
| 223 students | 90 per cent | 66 per cent | 7 per cent
| 115 smokers | 89 " " | 62 " " | 10 " "
| 108 non-smokers | 91 " " | 69 " " | 4 " "
| | | |
Dr. Edward Hitchcock, of Amherst College, says of Amherst students: "In separating the smokers from the non-smokers, it appears that in the item of weight the non-smokers have increased 24 per cent more than the smokers; in growth in height they have surpassed them 37 per cent, and in chest girth 42 per cent. In lung capacity there is a difference of 8.36 cubic inches (this is about 75 per cent) in favor of the non-smokers."
Professor W. P. Lombard, of the University of
-76-
Michigan, found that five cigars smoked on each of two four-day periods with a similar non-tobacco period between averaged to lower the working power of the muscles 41 per cent and often more. These results were obtained by careful experiments with the ergograph and have been recorded on a previous page with those reported by Dr. F. C. Walsh.
The tabulations from leading American institutions by Dr. F. J. Pack show the following data: "(1) Only half as many smokers as non-smokers are successful in the try-outs for foot-ball squads. (2) In the case of able-bodied men, smoking is associated with loss in lung capacity amounting to practically 10 per cent. Incidentally they show that smoking is invariably associated with low scholarship, and that smokers furnish twice as many conditions and failures as do non-smokers. Data relative to try-outs were received from six institutions as follows:
| Number Competing | Number Successful | Per cent Successful |
| Smokers | 93 | 31 | 33.3
| Non-smokers | 117 | 77 | 65.8 | |
"It will thus be seen that only half as many smokers as non-smokers were successful in gaining the coveted positions. But, though the difference in age and weight were both in favor of the smokers, in lung capacity the non-smokers of six institutions reporting showed an advantage of 22.6 cubic iinches as indicated in the subjoined table:
-77-
| Number of Men | Average Weight | Average Age | Av. Lung Capacity
| Smokers, 47 | 162.9 lbs. | 21.06 years | 286.3 cu. in.
| Non-smokers, 61 | 159.6 " | 20.88 " | 308.9 " "
| Difference | 3.3 " | .18 " | 22.6 " " | | | |
"The difference in favor of the non-smoker thus amounts to 7.3 per cent. It is worth noting that in not a single institution of the six reporting was the difference in lung capacity in favor of the smokers, the advantage with the non-smokers ranging from 5.8 to 37.7 cu. in."
In studying 201 men in Clark College from 1906 to 1909, Professor E. L. Clarke found results which may be tabulated thus:
| Habitual Smokers | Occasional Smokers | Non-Smokers
| Numbers and per cent. | 41, 20.0% | 52, 25.9% | 108, 53.7%
| Dropped college or took an extra year | 51.6% | 25.8% | 22.6%
| Athletic honors | 21.5% | 36.6% | 41.9%
| Scholarships, 54 students | 11.1% | 25.0% | 68.4%
| Honors in both athletics and scholarships, 12 students | 16.6% | 25.0% | 58.4% | | | | | |
Mr. Clarke, in closing this report on smoking among Clark students, pointed out the fact that this habit goes with others tending to lower scholarship in which smoking is a vital part of the difficulty. The club room is a lounging place where smokers are tolerated. A man who dislikes tobacco is seldom seen there. He is, therefore, under little temptation to waste time. Hence, the smoker is the one who wastes the most
-78-
time around the college grounds. This is but one of the conspicuous examples leading to the conclusion that smoking is an indicator of other evils as well as being harmful in itself.
These Clark College records show that men who took up smoking after entering suffered two per cent in strength, one per cent in lung capacity, and 10 per cent in scholarship in comparison with those who remained non-smokers. So the cumulative and permanent effects appear shortly even in those who begin the use of tobacco after reaching college age.
The larger proportion of college students who smoke are those who have plenty of money. Consequently, they are often better nourished than the poorer students and may be heavier, not on account of the tobacco habit, but in spite of it. Because of their easy circumstances, they are more likely to have the desirable leisure and get into athletics, unless a sufficient number of poorer students, who have to work their way in part, have time for sports and such tests are applied as will give the positions to the men who are most fit. No one shculd be deceived regarding why smokers are sometimes as large as non-smokers and .are often predominant in athletics in some schools where tobacco is popular.
Again, statistics which do not cover a whole student body are of little value unless they cover a considerable number of men selected by lot. Obviously, statistics secured from such men as may see fit to answer a questionnaire are of comparatively little value, unless nearly all students of an institution are involved. Since
-79-
the results of the tobacco habit are cumulative, statistics covering a freshman class are less valuable than those from upper classmen. Results obtained by studying all the men in a college or a university through a series of years are most valuable of all, and it is such studies as this that gives the strongest verdict against tobacco.
Colleges and universities see that their students hear lectures on ethics and morals, and do a good deal for their religious interests, but allow them to form a habit which is amply proved to be injurious in various ways, to lessen general efficiency, and to shut many out of desirable positions. This often happens without any serious attempt to inform students of the injurious effects of using tobacco.
If some colleges and universities will not of their own accord put this matter and others that have to do with physical, mental, moral, and spiritual life ahead of learning, we believe that the sooner public sentiment requires them to do so, the better.
-80-
10. THE SMOKING MAN AND HIS INFLUENCE
What has appeared thus far has been, for most part, limited to consideration of tobacco from several points of view and to a discussion of the effects of the drug on boys and young men. It has seemed best to reserve treatment of smoking among men to the latter part of the considerations of the tobacco problem.
After going through the scientific evidence carefully, the writer is convinced that the experiments already noted are reliable, and that no man ever smokes or chews tobacco even once without temporary injury; but he knows quite as well that some men do not know that they are being permanently injured by repeated indulgence extended over a long period and would not be convinced by all the evidence that could be produced. [Ed. Note. See reasons].
Many others who know well enough that their efficiency and health are being slowly hurt by tobacco will not give up its use, though they believe much that is appearing from those who are best prepared to speak and write. [Ed. Note. See reasons].
The task of writing on phases that concern men would seem more worth while if any considerable number of men could be induced to abandon tobacco. Though this is too much to hope for, it will surely be helpful to present some of the opinions and results of experiments obtained by those who have made a special study of the tobacco problem.
-81-
Dr. [J. H.] Kellogg, of the sanitarium at Battle Creek, Michigan, condemns the use of tobacco among men in the following strong terms:"It is one of the enigmas of modern life that the average business man, the man who demands the highest degree of efficiency in every department of his business, be it factory, store, or office, should continue to use tobacco, knowing that it is one of the deadliest of poisons and one of the worst of all enemies of mental power. It is astonishing that his business sense, his genius for economy, should permit him to consume so much of his energy in a perfectly useless and harmful way. Any man who stops to study himself, who inquires into the means by which he can conserve his vital energy and increase his efficiency, discovers that the first thing to do is to raise the load off his liver and kidneys and other organs; he discovers, for instance, that the work which his lungs are required to do in eliminating nicotine is far more than all the work involved in the digestion of food and the performance of intellectual labor, and if he is a wise man, he will drop immediately the use of tobaccco."
Dr. Harvey W. Wiley, the pure food expert, says:
"A man has not the shadow of a right to inflict unwholesome smoke and his vile breath on the community at large. There should be a strictly enforced law [Ed. Note: Example: Iowa's] prohibiting smoking and chewing in public places, or on the cars where other persons are obliged to be."
Dr. C. E. Slocum says in his book on Tobacco and its Deleterious Effects:"No one has any right to flaunt his depravity and his depraving habit in public. No
-82-
one has a right to circulate on a street or elsewhere in public reeking with tobacco, much less puffing its smoke in the faces of others. Such bravados are becoming intolerably numerous. In business places, public offices, court houses, hotels everywhere, and restaurants, where free women and free men are obliged to go, it has become necessary to pass through an atmosphere vitiated by tobacco breaths and sputa. These are public outrages upon civilization that self-and-rights-of-others respecting men and women should no longer continue to endure meekly, as they have done in the past. The right of every one to pure air, unadulterated by tobacco or other deleterious odors, should be insisted upon by all clean people, forcefully if necessary."1
W. H. Allen, writing in Civics and Health, says:
"It is selfish to intrude upon others a personal weakness or a .personal appetite. It is selfish to divert from family purposes to "soothing excited nerves" even the small amounts necessary to maintain the cigar or cigarette habit. It is selfish to run the risk of shortening one's life, of reducing ones earning capacity. Because the tobacco habit is selfish it is anti-social and a nuisance, and should be fought by social as well as personal weapons, as are other recognized nuisances, such as spitting in public or offensive manners."2
Dr. T. H. Marable, of Clarksville, Tennessee, says in The Medical Journal:"The cause of cigarette smoking is that boys are very fond of imitating their elders.
____________
1Published by permission from The Slocum Publishing Company.
2Published by permission from Ginn & Company.
-83-
"Smoking in public places ought to be discouraged. Every man, when he smokes in public, ought to think that he is encouraging some boy to smoke."
In an article entitled, "Why Boys Smoke," O. S. Davis says, in the Scientific Temperance Journal, regarding the responsibility of men for cigarette smoking among youths:"Boys smoke cigarettes because grown men smoke tobacco in all kinds of ways. They are imitating their elders and superiors in their efforts to be manly and grown up, as they regard it. The college man's pipe and the business man's cigar are incentives to the boy's cigarette and his first chew of tobacco. The force of the man's example cannot be overestimated in the influences that lead the boy to smoke. He is bound to try in his way what he sees grown men do in their way. Men ought to remember this when they smoke.
"They can endure the toxins in their mature bodies which will wreck the physical organism of the adolescent boy. It is very difficult to show the boy this fact, however; and he does to his lasting harm what the grown man may sometimes may do without serious peril. Every man who smokes ought to reckon with the force of his example in this respect and ask himself if he cannot afford to give up a personal habit that is weighted with such serious possibilities to boys."
Men who smoke may well consider these words of Charles B. Towns, the noted expert on the effects of drugs:"Now, the boys who are certain to be injured by any form of tobacco, invariably smoke in the worst way that they can—that is, smoke cigarettes. How is
-84-
the father going to stop it? We all know with what force the indorsement of a hair-tonic comes from a bald-headed barber. A man cannot expect to have any influence with his son when he advises him not to do the thing he himself is doing. Every man advises his son not to smoke until he reaches an age where tobacco will not hurt him, though he himself has probably heard lately from his doctor that there is no such age. Though tobacco will injure a boy more than a man, it will also injure the man at any time during his life.
"When the father goes on to advise the boy to begin his smoking on pipe and cigars when he is grown up, his position becomes puerile. For he knows
very well that almost no one begins on anything but cigarettes. The father who fills his house with smoke has, in a threefold way, created an appetite for tobacco in his boy;
- "first, the boy has a disposition to smoke because his father does;
- "second, because he is curious; and
- "third, because his respiratory passages are already craving the excitation to which they have become accustomed.
"The smoking father, in forbidding his son to smoke, virtually drives him to sneak around the corner for a cigarette to experiment with on the sly."3
Dr. J. R. Leadsworth says of the effects of the father's smoking:"Can it be supposed for a moment that in a home where tobacco fumes constantly permeate the rooms, such a powerful volatile poison would have no deleterious effect upon the mother and children who spend almost their entire time in such an atmosphere? Does it not seem reasonable that a
____________
3Published by permission from The Century Company.
-85-
child reared from the cradle under such conditions should present symptoms of nicotine poisoning even though it has never become a victim of the habit?
But how few boys, when the husband and father is addicted to its use, escape the injurious habit? When we remember with what pride the boy looks upon his papa, and what interest he takes in a recital of the daily details of the parent's life—all of which proves to him that no other boy has such a father—it is reasonable to expect that he would be eager to follow his example even in this harmful practice. Too often the practice of smoking is taken up during the impressionable years of childhood and youth, with the result that the brain faculties never fully develop."
Dr. Leadsworth writes further of an eight-year-old boy who was ill and showed symptoms of severe poisoning. The boy, who never used tobacco, was subjected to sweating, and his skin gave off a marked nicotine odor and stain." Regarding the father's responsibility, Dr. Leadsworth writes:
"Further investigation elicited the fact that the boy's father was an inveterate smoker, and when at home kept the room saturated with tobacco fumes. The boy never touched the weed. But who can be surprised that the sensitive organism of the child, constantly absorbing such an atmosphere, succumbed to it? And who can estimate the multitude of children whose cheeks are blanched and whose bodies are frail, because of their father's indulgence in the poisonous weed?"
Such cases could be multiplied many times.
The following regarding the relationship between
-86-
tobacco and good manners is from the pen of the well-known missionary secretary, Robert E. Speer:"I have seen many a boy and man, by nature courteous and thoughtful, who would never think of doing an ungentlemanly or rude thing intentionally, guilty nevertheless of the most heedless discourtesy and rudeness in the use of tobacco. Every morning as I get off the suburban train in the railway station, and walk down the crowded platform, I see both men and women dodging to one side or the other in order to escape the necessity of inhaling a cloud of tobacco smoke blown by a smoker into the face of any one whom he was confronting; but who, with no thought whatever of the interests or feelings of others, pollutes the air which they have to breathe. Many a fine-natured boy and man has been made coarse and boorish in this one regard of ignoring the sensibilities of others in the indulgence of this habit."4
Some people condemn the smoking man who confines his habit to his own private room, saying that he is doing just what tlie boy does when he sneaks around the corner to smoke a cigarette. However, the man who practices discretion regarding when and where he uses tobacco usually does so for a perfectly good reason, since the greatest temptation to young men comes from the fact that tobacco has become a social habit, in many places extremely tyrannical. When a really strong man appears before an assemblage of young men with pipe, cigar, or cigarette in month, he does that which is condemned by many of those who
____________
4Published by permission from The Fleming H. Revell Company.
-87-
have studied the tobacco problem most carefully. The larger the number of men that break the habit the better, but the man who smokes helps the matter of education when he carefully uses discretion regarding when and where he smokes.
When, on the other hand, business men or their representatives parade streets with bands to attract attention and smoke pipes, cigars, and cigarettes, they are influencing the boys and helping to lower the character of human beings. Teachers should be among the last persons to tempt young men by public practice and private invitation, and many of them probably do so because they do not know the results of careful observation and research, some of which appear in these pages.
We cannot hope to influence many men to abandon a habit firmly fixed; but there are many users of tobacco who will lend their influence on the right side in the campaign of education. If an occasional man is induced to quit using tobacco, and the number of men who will aid actively in attempts to keep boys and young men from forming the habit can be increased, this part of the discussion will seem well worth while.
[Ed. Note: Due to smokers' brain damage, this educational approach failed, and cannot do other than fail. Real solutions involve passing the 1897 Iowa law everywhere; and immediately prosecuting the pushers for the deaths they have caused.]
-88-
11. DIET AND THE TOBACCO HABIT
Women have shown great interest in the tobacco problem, and many of them will gladly consider any relation between household affairs and this great evil. Therefore, one may present more freely the facts regarding the manner in which women may have a very direct part in preventing the formation of the tobacco habit and in breaking it up when it is once formed. There is much literature dealing with the relation of food to drug habits; but we can consider only some of the best of that which bears upon the tobacco problem.
Many persons are slowly killing themselves by the food that they eat. Habits of eating need to be changed with change of occupation, with advancing years, and often with the formation of wrong habits. Elements of diet found to be injurious to the individual should be avoided. No doubt many men would lose their desire for drugs too, if they could be induced to change to the simple, nourishing elements of diet suggested below. In this the wife and mother may play a large part.
The woman who wishes to save her boy from drug habits or to help her husband to give up one or more already formed should remember that spicy, heavy, and highly seasoned foods usually go with such habits, while a plain diet, composed largely of cereals, fruits,
-89-
and vegetables, does much to destroy the desire for various drugs. She may well ponder carefully the words to follow from high authority.
Dr. C. E. Slocum says:"There can be properly-healthful manhood, and properly-true and sure progress, only as mankind is fed on the plainest most wholesome foods, and the purest water; and the entire life, and action, strictly governed along the line of what is for the best. Poverty, misery, crime, and all the horde of other evils now existing, can be banished only by giving children their proper heritage of sound health, and rearing them along this reasonable, most important, and obligatory line of sanity.1
The following is from Dr. D. H. Kress:"The editor of the London Clarion, England, relating his own experience, said:
| 'I was a heavy smoker for more than thirty years. I have often smoked as much as two ounces of tobacco in a day. I don't suppose I have smoked less than eight ounces a week for a quarter of a century. If there was one thing in life I feared my will was too weak to conquer, it was the habit of smoking. Well, I have been a vegetarian for eight weeks and find that my passion for tobacco is weakening. I cannot smoke those pipes now. I have to get new pipes and milder tobacco, and am not smoking half an ounce a day. It does not taste the same.' |
"This is a testimony of value, since in taking up this diet he had no intention whatever of giving up the use of tobacco. While writing the above I received the following unsolicited testimonial from a former patient
____________
1Published by permission from The Slocum Publishing Company.
-90-
who has been addicted to both tobacco and strong drink for many years. His health being ruined, he found it necessary to apply for medical aid. He said:
| 'It seems wonderful to me, I have now no craving for tobacco or drink, and I also find that I have no need of drugs and patent medicine. I am enjoying excellent health. I must thank you for the kind help you have given me.'" |
Ed. Note: Why smokers smoke, reasons include: craving, brain damage, pre-Alzheimers, abulia, mental disorder, memory loss,
smoking as constituting a disease, and the inability to comprehend the hazard if told.
The focus on 'why' must also note how and why nonsmoker children are tricked into initial smoking:
pusher fraud producing unawareness of the hazard
tobacco-news-censorship
widespread pro-tobacco disinformation
pusher effectiveness against them,
widespread loss of the 1890's regard for a good adult example, etc.
In other words, the 'why' must be a comprehensive response, taking into account societal, medical, and legal aspects, not limited to a single overly-narrow aspect. |
Mothers may well note some words from Dr. Lauretta Kress regarding the relation between food and tobacco. She says:"A most important factor, which may either deter or favor the formation of the tobaco habit, is the food furnished in the home. Irritating and highly seasoned foods produce irritability of the stomach and mind; and in consequence a desire is created for some nerve soother. Condiments such as pepper, mustard, spices, and a large amount of salt all produce irritability of the stomach, and this in turn creates a demand for narcotics. Rich foods do the same, also greasy foods, for the free fats usually undergo decomposition and produce irritating acids. A wise mother will strive to prepare for her family foods which are non-stimulating and non-irritating, and yet so attractive and palatable that they will he relished by all. Good sweetbread and cereals, fresh vegetables, sweet new milk and eggs, fresh fruit, or canned fruit. and so forth, make a non-stimulating diet which will not create a craving for either drink or tobacco. Since agreeable home life and wisely prepared foods act as preventives of the tobacco habit, the intelligent wife and mother can do much to aid husband or son in the
-91-
endeavor to give up the habit. Suitable non-stimulating beverages should replace tea, coffee, and cocoa. Nicely prepared meat substitutes should take the place of flesh food. The use of fruits should be encouraged. The one who can be induced to eat freely of fruits soon loses his desire for tobacco."
Again we quote Dr. Kress thus:
"The intolerable craving for the after-dinner cigar is largely introduced by the juicy beef steak, highly spiced food, and tea and coffee that compose the meal.
"Hence he who wants to be delivered from the tobacco habit should religiously avoid for a time at least, such articles of food as produces a craving for tobacco.
"Why do men use tobacco? There certainly is nothing agreeable in it to the taste. It is repelled by the entire organism, and necessitates considerable perseverance to form the habit. There must be some cause or causes for its prevalent use. I am convinced that it is used for the same reason that alcohol is, because of its narcotic effect.
"Dietetic errors often pave the way to the use of tobacco. Being a narcotic, it allays the disagreeable symptoms arising from indigestion and dyspepsia. When the stomach and nerves are irritated by the use of mustard, pepper, spices, pickles, and incompletely masticated food, or by improper combinations which result in fermentation, tobacco, being a narcotic, is capable of producing partial anesthesia, and thus it affords relief from the disagreeable symptoms associated with the irritation; but being an irritant itself, when the narcotic influence has worn off, the aggravated condition created by its use makes a still louder
-92-
call for something that will again produce a partial state of anesthesia. This something may be found in tobacco, or it may be found in alcohol. For this reason tobacco and alcohol are intimately associated. Where one is, the other is apt to be found, for one naturally leads to the use of the other.
"I have found that a diet free from unnatural irritants will always result in a decrease in the desire for both tobacco and alcohol. I have never yet discovered a drunkard or an inebriate who was not passionately fond of spicy, highly seasoned foods and also of flesh foods.
Ed. Note: The average age of smoking onset is 12. Next in sequence, alcohol follows, average age 12.6; then marijuana, average age 14. See, e.g., DHEW National Institute on Drug Abuse (NIDA), Research on Smoking Behavior, Research Monograph 17, Publication ADM 78-581, p vi (Dec 1977); DuPont, Teen Drug Use, 102 J Pediatrics 1003-1007 (June 1983); Fleming, et al., Cigarettes' Role in The Initiation And Progression Of Early Substance Use, 14 Addictive Behaviors 261-272 (1989); and DHHS, Preventing Tobacco Use Among Young People: Surgeon General Report (1994).
Dr. Kress, ex-smoker, reverses the matter. Actually, the dietary aspect is a result of tobacco toxic chemicals impairing the senses of taste and smell. |
"I have no doubt that one reason why these habits are so common is because dietetic errors are common.
"Several years ago the president of a city railway who was suffering from ulceration of the stomach came under my care for treatment. I soon ascertained that he was an inveterate user of tobacco. No doubt the symptoms accompanying the gastric irritation, which finally resulted in ulceration, called for the relief which tobacco furnished. He promised faithfully that he would give up its use. From the time he first began his treatment, his diet was simple and non-irritating. At the end of six weeks, he called at my office and said:
| 'Doctor, I have just returned from the city. On the way I passed a man smoking a cigar, and the smoke was actually offensive to me. I never thought such a thing possible.' |
His firm will and determination, combined with the aid received by a carefully prescribed diet, made it comparatively easy for him to give up its use.
"Another case was that of a patient who came to me suffering from chronic
-93-
dyspepsia of most distressing form, and who after two months' treatment completely regained his health, affirming that he could not smoke if he would.
"Still another who was weak in will power, after a day's trial, concluded he would make no further attempt to abandon its use. He however continued to subsist upon a diet of grains, fruits, and vegetables, which I prescribed, in order to get rid of rheumatism. Six months later, in relating his experience, he said,
| 'I gradually and unconsciously lost my relish for tobacco. At first I thought there was something the matter with the brand I was using, so I purchased another. But that tasted no better. I tried still another with similar results. It then dawned upon me that I had lost my craving for it.' |
For over three years he has used no tobacco, and probabilities are that he never will again."
We started with the statement that there is a close relation between food and drug habits and passed to views of experts to the effect that this is true of tobacco as well as other drugs. Plain food will certainly help much in the fight against tobacco and at the same time conduce to strong and honest manhood and womanhood.
We can not hope that all members of society will abandon "high living," but it is not too much to hope that the tendency will turn toward care in the choice of foods and drinks if indeed it is not in that direction now. We may believe that a better day is dawning, and that a "survival of the fittest" will one day give us a race stronger because of its more temperate living—a race that will conquer tobacco and other drugs.
[Ed. Note: See Ed. Note, p 44, supra]
-94-
12. HOW TO COMBAT TOBACCO
The efforts of an individual here and there cannot make much headway against tobacco. Facts have been stated in order to stimulate to action many who believe that boys and young men should be saved from the use of tobacco. What has been presented can only aid in a battle which must be waged for many years.
The people must be enlightened in every community, and public sentiment must be aroused before much can be accomplished. There must also be some organization to see that the public is kept interested, that meetings are held for discussion, and that proper laws [Ed. Note: Iowa-style and criminal prosecution-approach] are passed and enforced. There are persons in every community possessed of leisure and genius for organization, who could set forces in motion and keep them at work. Both local and state-wide organizations may well be affiliated with The Anti-Cigarette League of America.
A thorough study of the tobacco habit among boys has convinced Professor W. A. McKeever that prevention is the only way to cope with the evil. He writes thus:
"Prevention is the only practical solution of the cigarette or boy-smoking question. Bovs take up to the practice in innocence. Just for fun, and are usually its victims before the matter is detected by their parents. Any normal, healthy boy will learn to smoke if thrown among young smokers without any caution
-95-
or restraint from those in authority over him. After parents discover the fault there is often a pathetic struggle, perhaps attended by many maternal tears, and then a compromise. That is, the boy tries in vain to quit and finally agrees to compromise on a pipe. But he will likely violate every rule of good conduct ever taught him by his parents before he will give up the habit entirely. But parents must learn more about the nature of this insidious habit and prevent its being taken up. The following methods of prevention are reported effective:
"(1) Begin to talk to the boy as early as his sixth or seventh year about the matter and make a strong appeal to his sense of honor. Do not be too insistent and threaten to inflict punishment, but indicate rather that you think him too worthy to take up such a practice.
"(2) Offer to set aside some material or pecuniary reward to be paid when he becomes of age, provided he continues his total abstinence, and add to his sentiment that he may then do as he pleases. Never ask the boy to pledge away in advance the years of his manhood.
"(3) Remind the boy in every possible way' how much concern you
have for his well being, how much you are willing to sacrifice for him, and how anxious you are to be true to him and to help him. He will then likely never break faith with you.
"(4) Keep in touch with the boy and know at all times his joys and hopes and aspirations. Be his companion and adviser and true friend, and he will respect your wishes in regard to him."1
Mary A. Hunt [1830-1906] states that graded instructions will
____________
1Published by permission from The Macmillan Company.
-96-
stop the cigarette evil.
She says in part:
"The only sure way of preventing cigarette smoking in the high school is to begin in the first primary grade to teach the boy with other laws of health, simple physiological reasons adapted to his capacity that show why he should not smoke, and continue this instruction as a more progressive study with new matter which gives each year more of the physiological reasons for abstinence from tobacco in all forms as well as for the observance of other hygienic laws.
"If this study is thus properly graded, it will be a progressive development and not a repetition and will send the boy to the high school, having been too well informed from the first to dull his brain or to limit his future possibilities by nicotine. The public school study of hygiene and temperance, which includes warning instructions as to the nature of tobacco and its effects upon the human system, is legally engrafted upon the public school system of this entire nation. This legislation began quite generally to go into force about fifteen years ago [1900].
"If, during this time, school committees, school boards, trustees, and school superintendents had more generally made a place in the school curriculum for enough well graded lessons to cover the subject, say twenty per year in the primary and thirty per year in the grammar and first year of the high school, with good books in the hands of the pupils who have books in other studies, there would be fewer cigarette smokers to-day. To limit this instruction to the high grades is to wait until the mischief is begun. We cannot undo this wrong to the children in the past, but inno-
-97-
cent faces of the little ones in the primary grades appeal to us against the repeating of it in the future."
Then follow statements from schools and towns where smoking among boys has been stopped by this method.
Ed. Note: Books by Mary H. HuntA Temperance Physiology for Intermediate Classes and Common Schools (New York: A.S. Barnes & Company, 1884)
Child's Health Primer for Primary Classes; With Special Reference to the Effects of Alcoholic Drinks, Stimulants, and Narcotics upon the Human System (New York, Barnes, 1885)
Scientific Temperance Instruction in Schools and Colleges: from November, 1886, to November, 1887: Mary H. Hunt, Superintendent (1887)
Plan of Work for Securing Scientific Temperance Education in Schools and Colleges for the Woman's Christian Temperance Unions of the United States and Other Lands (Boston: National and International Woman's Christian Temperance Union, Scientific Department, 1888)
Hygiene for Young People: Adapted to Intermediate Classes and Common Schools (New York; Cincinnati; Chicago: Americam Book Company, 1889)
Physiology and Health. Studies of the Human Body and of the Effects of Alcoholic Drinks and Narcotics upon Life and Health. Number One, For Primary Classes (New York: American Book Co., 1889, 1890)
Physiology and Health. Studies of the Human Body and of the Effects of Alcoholic Drinks and Narcotics upon Life and Health. Number Two, For Intermediate Classes (New York: American Book Co., 1889; and Ivison, Blakeman, and Company, 1889; and Philadelphia: E. H. Butler, 1889, 1890)
Physiology and Health for Advanced Classes: Studies of the Human Body and of the Effects of Alcoholic Drinks and Narcotics Upon Life and Health. Number Three (New York: American Book Company, 1890)
A History of the First Decade of the Department of Scientific Temperance Instruction in Schools and Colleges, of the Woman's Christian Temperance Union (Boston, G.E. Crosby & Co., 1891; and Boston: Washington Press, 1891, 1892)
An Epoch of the Nineteenth Century. An Outline of the Work for Scientific Temperance Education in the Public Schools of the United States (Boston, P.H. Foster & Co., 1897)
Reply to the Physiological Subcommittee of the Committee of Fifty: Reported for Adoption to the National Woman's Christian Temperance Union Convention, Cincinnati, Ohio, November 18, 1903 (Boston: 1904) |
The following plan for cooperation of teachers and parents in eliminating the cigarette is copied from the School Physiology Journal [Vol. 17, pp 56-57, 1907] and is worth trying. In a certain school this circular letter was sent to parents:
"We desire to call the attention of parents to the fact- that a large majority of the boys in this city are smoking cigarettes;
- that the boys who smoke are, on an average, one or two years behind the boys who do not smoke, and still farther behind the girls in the same grades;
- that the mental, moral, and physical condition of these boys is extremely deplorable and will certainly continue to grow worse unless the habit is stopped;
- that while the schools are insisting that this and all other unclean and undesirable habits shall not be practiced in or about our schoolhouse or grounds, still crowds of boys are seen daily around the saloons and loafing places of our streets, smoking, loafing, swearing, and cultivating other undesirable habits.
"We ask that parents cooperate with us in eliminating these conditions so far as possible, to the end that we may give our future generations of young men, not only an education, but healthy bodies, minds, and morals.
"We would ask parents to observe from the table given, that the cigarette smoker is already on his way to the conditions which indicate crime, trampdom, the jail, and general worthlessness. Memory goes first, closely followed by low deportment, low rank in studies, bad |
-98-
| physical condition, and general degeneracy.
"We would also point out to parents that while pupils are within our domain as teachers (the schoolyard and schoolhouses) there will be no smoking and that while we shall do all in our power to discourage it anywhere, we are helpless to stop the difficulty without the personal cooperation of the parents [[Ed. Note: and legislators, adopting the Iowa example law], and we may as well add that we are unable to teach anything to the cigarette fiend, as his memory is a blank, his power to reason damaged, ability to study ruined, and usually his ambition to excel entirely gone.
"We would further point out to the parents of the boy who smokes that the desirable places in the business world are being rapidly closed to the cigarette smokers, and that already the banks, railroads, and many other businesses by which the ambitious young man expects to climb to fortune and success have closed their doors as tightly to the cigarette smokers as to the drunken sot. Why? Because the business world has found by experience, as we teachers observe continually, that the cigarette smoker is untruthful, deceitful, untrustworthy, and inefficient.'' |
After quoting the circular letter, the journal continues:
"This was plain talk, and it had an immediate effect. Within a few months it was estimated by the marshal of the town that seventy-five per cent of the cigarette smoking by boys had stopped, and the moral and industrial condition of the school was wonderfully improved. What had been called the worst school in the country was spoken of as doing good work. The school board raised the salary of the teachers and
-99-
principals twenty-five percent. The people were pleased, and the improved condition of the boys was noticeable in their language, dress, manners, efficiency, and in their moral tone."
Professor Arthur Holmes, of the Pennsylvania State College, wrote thus in his paper on "The Psychology of Smoking":
"From the attempt to get at the psychological causes of smoking, we have come upon an inkling or two for its prevention. The cure must be chiefly prophylactic or preventive. If imitation is the chief cause for beginning the practice among boys, then example should be eliminated as far as possible. If men did not smoke, boys would not. All the appeals and all the legislation possible, therefore, which would suppress the open and overt uses of tobacco are good
[Ed. Note: e.g., Iowa's model law]. Herein women can play an important part by the rigorous exclusion, for the sake of their young sons, of smoking from their own presence and from the society which they control."
A recent issue of the Northwestern Christian Advocate has the following:"A movement of more than passing importance has been started in Kansas by the young women who have organized into a 'Good Habits Club,' the purpose of which is to decline the attention of any young men who drink, smoke, gamble, or use profane language. Reports come that in communities in other States the young ladies have adopted the program, and that already the effect is seen in a lessened indulgence in these needless and harmful vices. The young women must come to realize that they are a prime factor in the moral character of the young men.
-100-
"The formation of one or more of these tabooed habits comes synchronously with a special regard for the opposite sex. As long as a young man is given to understand that his indulgence therein need in no way damage the favorable opinion of young women in general and one in particular, he will be inclined to persist therein. It is with the lessening moral sense of the young womanhood as much as with the willfulness of young men that responsibility must rest for the growing indulgence in the habits above mentioned.
"The young woman who permits a young man to blow cigarette smoke in her face without objecting or listens to conversation tinged with profanity without registering a protest is hardly the sort of woman to undertake the lifework of conserving and culturing the moral character of a young man. The great majority of young men who to-day indulge in one or the other of these vices would cease to-morrow were such an edict to go from resolute young womanhood. Such an agreement adhered to would be the best insurance policy imaginable. May the 'Good Habits Clubs' spread all over the country."
Dr. D. H. Kress says, regarding means of getting rid of tobacco:"Reforms must be made by fathers and teachers who say in all their habits of life to those who look to them as examples, 'Follow me.' When this is done our educational and legislative [Ed. Note: e.g., Iowa's] efforts will be consistent and will appeal to the youth."
When we consider the baneful effects of tobacco and the stand that business often takes against it, it is not surprising that men sometimes fail to be appointed
-101-
as instructors in certain schools because they use the weed. The Nebraska Teacher says"Some time no one will be permitted to teach in public schools or in normal schools or colleges who indulges in smoking. . . . In Wisconsin, a movement has been inaugurated to discountenance smoking on the part of all persons, teachers or pupils, connected with high schools."
| Ed. Note: In the case of
Tanton v McKenney, 226 Mich 245; 197 NW 510; 33 ALR 1175 (1924), the Michigan Supreme Court upheld expelling a student in teacher training, for smoking. |
Superintendent J. K. McBroom, of the public school at Excelsior, Minnesota, gives [Ed. Note: in 1906] the following results of some correspondence:
"I wrote to the clerk of the school board of each high-school town and city in the State, asking these two questions:- 1. If you were now electing a superintendent, would a candidate's use of tobacco tend to discredit him with the board?
- 2. Would it be a conclusive objection to him?
"I have received 123 replies.
- Of these, 80, or nearly two out of three, answered "yes" to both questions; it would tend to discredit him with the board, and it would be a conclusive objection to him.
- Only 18, 1-7, answered "no" to both questions.
- The rest answered "yes" to the first and "no" to the second, or in the case of three or four, were non-committal.
"Now that means that when the grand annual hustle of rearrangement and promotion takes place next spring, at only one place in three will the superintendent who smokes, even in moderation and seclusion—at only one place in three will he be considered at all; and only at one place in seven will he be considered on an equal footing with the other candidates."
Superintendent McBroom also says that"Minnesota teachers might get after the college professors who use tobacco; and after the
-102-
college or university whose atmosphere is reeking with tobacco smoke."
Nor is this all, for a nation-wide investigation of conditions in colleges and universities is being considered.
Whatever may be accomplished in time, for the present the fight for the boy and the young man must continue. Regarding this Dr. Arthur Holmes says:
"For the nervous boy nothing in the world is better than a variety of health, invigorating, fresh air, out-door, physically-fatiguing exercises. When such a boy, or any other boy, is given the five or six necessities of life like fresh air, a variety of well cooked, nourishing food, and abundance of clear, clean, water inside and out, eight hours of refreshing sleep, and plenty of play, he will almost certainly acquire such a physical, intellectual, and moral wholesomeness that his diseases and abnormal craving will disappear of themselves."
If the boy acquires the habit, something else may be necessary. The silver nitrate treatment may prove valuable in instances where boys and young men desire to be free from the habit. The treatment consists of swabbing the throat with a weak solution of nitrate of silver, accompanied by superintendence of diet for two or three weeks. This treatment is reported to be successful in most instances, but more experience with it is needed to make sure of its value.
The Anti-Cigarette League of America, 1119 Woman's Temple, Chicago, Illinois, will gladly give any community directions in organizing. This league is a strong organization, whose officers include men of practical insight and national or international repu-
-103-
tation. There is strength in union, and there is wisdom acquired from experience in this league. The league now has a half-million boys pledged against the use of tobacco and is working for as many again in the near future. A call has been issued to churches, Y. M. C. A's, other men's organizations, young people's societies, Sunday schools, woman's clubs, and other organizations. We can quote but a small portion of the call, as follows:
"People of all ages and both sexes in increasing numbers are becoming devotees of the paper pipe. But it is among the youth that its blasting and blighting effects are most evident. No agency to-day is more productive of ills to mankind than the white robed, innocent-looking little cigarette. Striking as it does at the very fountain of life in the youth of the nation, the use of cigarettes is rapidly undermining American health and morals.
"Being a commercialized vice, the young, the weak, the unwary are the easy prey of blood-thirsty and conscienceless despoilers who are coining easy millions by the manufacture of cigarettes.
"The fight on the cigaret requires the rallying of all the forces of righteousness, and the Anti-Cigarette League of America is hereby issuing its call for a million recruits. A very simple plan of organization has been worked out, which it is believed will commend itself to all who are earnestly desirous of giving help. This plan is based on a pledged membership. A small fee is asked to help finance the stupendous undertaking of recruiting a million members in the immediate future."
Many States have anti-tobacco laws.
Recently, bills
-104-
have been introduced into the legislatures of Wisconsin and Ohio, aimed at the use of tobacco in certain or all of its forms, by teachers as well as pupils in both public schools and all higher State-supported schools. Conviction against the use of tobacco is growing as the evil becomes more and more tyrannical and dangerous, and it may be confidently predicted that such legislation will go into effect in many States at no very distant day.
Ed. Note: Tobacco solution involves (a) Iowa-style ban on cigarette manufacture, sale, giveaway; and (b) prosecuting tobacco pushers for foreseeable resultant deaths as murder. The Kansas approach, below, criminalizing the people pushers intend to murder, is therefore erroneous in the extreme. |
Already, Kansas has an anti-tohacco law which prohibits the use of tobacco in any form by minors. This law may well serve as a model for State laws and city ordinances. The Kansas law is as follows:
| "Section 1. It shall be unlawful for any person, company, or corporation to sell or give away any cigarettes or cigarette papers, or to have any cigarettes or cigarette papers in or about any store or other place for free distribution or sale.
"Section 2. Every minor person and every minor pupil in any school, college, or university, who shall smoke or use cigarettes, cigars, or tobacco in any form, or in any public road, alley, street, park, or other lands used for public purposes, or in any public place of business, shall be guilty of a misdemeanor and, on conviction, punished for each offense by a fine of not more than $10, and every person who shall furnish any cigarettes, cigars, or tobacco, in any form, to such minor persons, or who shall permit such minor persons to frequent any premises owned, held, or managed by him, for the purpose of indulging in the use of cigarettes, cigars, or tobacco in any forni shall be guilty |
-105-
| of a misdemeanor and on conviction be punished by a fine of not less than $25 nor more than $100 for each offense.
"Section 3. Every person, company, or corporation violating Section I of this act shall be deemed guilty of a misdemeanor and on conviction shall be fined not less than $25 nor more than $100." |
However much we may differ about the merits of certain statements made and some of the ideas quoted, the evidence as a whole shows the popular but iniquitous tobacco habit to merit the strongest possible opposition. [Ed. Note: most urgently, prosecutions for murder for the deaths caused. It is conspicuous when corrupt/bribed politicians set the penalty for throwing out garbage on the freeway at $500, but re killing a child, a mere $25!].
Men are sometimes heard to say that there is another side to the tobacco question, but the writer knows not one strong argument in its favor. Arguments on the ground of sense gratification and social advantage seem to him pure sophistry when coupled with a habit that is amply proved to be one of the most dangerous to mankind. It seems perfectly safe to repeat that mankind will one day rise against tobacco and make it as unpopular as are now some other drugs.
[Ed. Note: See Ed. Note, p 44, supra].
The sooner the fight against tobacco is won the better for us all.
-106-
13. SUMMARY AND CONCLUSION
Tobacco was investigated for the purpose of ascertaining the facts regarding its merits. It would have been a pleasant duty to defend it, and it has been a most unpleasant one to condemn a drug used by many men. However, in face of the overwhelming expert evidence against tobacco and the weakness of any possible argument in its favor, the writer is not disposed to write one word that might influence any person to use it.
We have noted the deplorable effects on boys and young men; have found the expert evidence to be overwhelmingly against the habit; have carefully considered the cigarette habit; have examined the relation of tobacco to delinquency and degeneracy; have looked into the opinion and the practice of business with respect to the tobacco habit; have studied statistics on the enormous and sinful waste of money on a worse than useless drug; have touched upon the tobacco habit among men; have shown how women can aid in keeping men and boys from forming the habit; and have considered some of the best means of combating tobacco.
The evidence presented will never be controverted as a whole, though some of the results of study are doubtless faulty. Should one go into an honest study of the question believing that the tobacco habit could
-107-
be upheld, he would soon find his error. When the world becomes fully aroused to the urgent need of fighting the tobacco evil, the tobacco industry may be expected to put forth arguments as spurious as those which the liquor interests have used. Many will be influenced by these arguments, but right will finally prevail.
[Ed. Note: Sadly, yes on the spurious arguments,
but no on right prevailing, see Ed. Note, p 44, supra].
With all the facts before us, no concluding words can adequately condemn tobacco. Conscience may be stilled by indulgence, and those who do not indulge may be hardened by contact with the habit. Yet all must suffer [Ed. Note: universal malice] more or less for this useless and poisonous drug, whether user or non-user.
It may well be doubted whether anyone who is handicapped by such a habit can attain the full measure of usefulness and possess so good an influence as he might have exerted otherwise. It appears like a strong statement to say that everyone who uses tobacco is, in this respect, an enemy of public welfare.
Yet the facts regarding the effects of the drug justify this statement and admit of no milder one [Ed. Note: the conclusion of tobacco being "an enemy of public welfare"]. Tobacco
The college man and the upright and influential business man with pipe, cigar, or cigarette are sowing to the whirlwind, working injury to themselves, and by their example causing injury to many who come within their influence. Every periodical that carries tobacco advertisements is patronizing one of the greatest evils of all time and deserves to be boycotted by all who wish to help sup-
-108-
press tobacco. Every magazine article or novel that makes mention of the cigar, pipe, or cigarette is also helping the evil cause and deserves condemnation for carrying such matter.
Though many excellent men, young and old, use tobacco, the habit is so detrimental that we may not expect to see any large proportion of those addicted to the use of the weed grow into a rich moral and spiritual experience not possessed before the habit was formed. The evolution is much more likely to be retrograde, as is abundantly proved by observation and by the results obtained by scientific study of the effects of tobacco.
According to opinion and the evidence, there seems to be little choice between nicotine, morphine, cocaine, and opium. Jenkin Lloyd Jones [1843-1918] says:"The Chinese have their opium joints and the American his clubhouse, where both absent themselves from the free intercourse with the world for a like reason; one to narcotize himself with opium, the other with tobacco."
In aggregate results, nicotine is probably doing more harm to-day than is opium.
We have considered but a small proportion of the great mass of medical evidence against tobacco, nor can we attempt more than a brief summary here. Tobacco is commonly charged by the medical profession with producing
By lowering resistance, it invites
- Bright's disease,
- apoplexy,
- tuberculosis,
- other infectious diseases,
- and many more pathologic condi-
-109-
tions.
It stupefies the brain and weakens the will and the intellect. It may weaken any organ or any physiological action and cause or invite any disease.
How a God-fearing man, careful of his influence and desirous of working good instead of evil can take up the tobacco habit or even continue in it after he knows the facts regarding it is difficult to understand. How the Christian merchant can sell the weed after he knows its nature is quite as great an enigma.
[Ed Note: See the abolitionist answer, re the typical Southern origin, the state of mind involved.]
Certainly there can be no justification based on financial gain. Aiding the tobacco traffic can be only less subversive of the general good than engaging in it. The Master whom many of us strive to follow surely stands against this great evil. How can the Christian do less?
Finally, every man who stands for the best things in morals, in religion, or in both must, if he knows the truth regarding tobacco, use his influence in aiding those who are fighting the tobacco habit.
-110-
BIBLIOGRAPHY
Abbott, Twyman O. "The Rights of a Non-smoker." The Outlook 94: 763-767. 1910. A sensible article about the use of tobacco on streets, in hotels, in restaurants, in public buildings, in parlor cars, on board vessels, in sleeping cars, in public and private parlors, in elevators, in dining cars, in theaters, etc. The article should be read by non-smokers that they may know their rights and by smokers that they may realize the bounds of propriety.
Allen, Alfred H. Allen's Commercial Organic Analysis. 6: 1-721. Philadelphia: P. Blakison's Son & Co., 1912. Pages 242 to 252 contain a good treatment of tobacco from the chemical point of view.
Allen, William H. Civics and Health. I-XL. 1-411. Illustrated. Boston, New York, Chicago: Ginn & Company, 1909. Chapter 36 contains a very sane discussion. [Ed. Note: Text]
Angstman, Charlotte S. The Power of the Tobacco Habit. 1-35. Battle Creek, Michigan: Good Health Publishing Company, 1899. An excellent treatment of the tobacco problem.
Angstman, Charlotte S. Anti-cigarette Literature. 1-9. Detroit: The Twentieth Century Club, 1913. The list contains most of the best articles and books.
Black, Samuel L. "The Patriot's Duty to the Boy." Sci. Temp. Journ. 19: 131, 132. 1910. This article is the result of Judge Black's experience in the juvenile court at Columbus, Ohio. The article should be read by every boy, young man, teacher, and parent.
Black, Samuel L. "An Address by Judge Black before the Ohio Senate Chamber, March 25, 1908." It is a strong indictment of the cigarette habit. The Boy Magazine 1: N. S. 11, 12. Jan.-Feb., 1913.
-111-
Bodine, W. L. "The Cigarette as Related to Truancy, Delinquency, and Crime." The Boy Magazine 6: No. 3. 17-23. 1907. An excellent article by the superintendent of compulsory education of the Chicago public schools.
Carter, R. Brudenell. "Alcohol and Tobacco." Littell's Living Age 250: 479-493. 1906. The article contains a strong indictment of both habits, whether practiced by children or adults.
[Ed. Note: Excerpt]
Clarke, Edwin Leavitt. "The Effect of Smoking on Clark College Students." The Clark College Record 91-98. 1900. Tabulates results of investigation, classifying men into three divisions—habitual smokers, occasional smokers, and non-smokers.
Crothers, T. D. "Tobacco on the Brain and Nervous System." Life and Health 22: 366, 367. 1907. An excellent article which should be read by every smoker.
Crothers, T. D. "A Practical Experience in Cigarette Smoking." School Physiology Journal 17: 98, 99. 1908. Tells of a graduate in engineering who lost position after position as soon as it was found that he used cigarettes.
Dowling, Francis. "Tobacco and the Eyes." The Lancet-Clinic 99: 699-702. 1908. A valuable article based on many examinations and much medical treatment.
Dunn, Percy. "Tobacco Amblyopia." The Lancet 1906. 1491-1493. 1906. A good treatment of this disease of the eyes.
Farnam, H. W. "Our Tobacco Bill." The Unpopular Review 1: 3-20. 1914. An excellent article, which shows that an enormous sum of money is worse than wasted each year.
[Ed. Note: Pp 55-58 Excerpt].
Fink, Bruce. "The Men's Meetings." The Miami Student, Feb. 6, 1913. A protest against calling a meeting at which tobacco is not passed a "smoker," the name being objectionable for a meeting where the best interests of a college are considered. A second similar article appeared in the same serial, Dec. 4. 1913.
Fink, Bruce. "Some Considerations of the Tobacco Habit."
-112-
A series of 15 articles which appeared in the Oxford Forum, Oxford, Ohio, from March to July, 1914.
Fink, Bruce. The Tobacco Habit. 1-77. Miami University, Oxford, Ohio, 1914.
Fisher, George J. "On the Physiological Effects of Smoking." Health League Bull. No. 16: 4-7. 1912. Contains two charts and a discussion of the effects on heart action.
Fisher, George J. "Physiological Effects of Cigar Smoking." Health League Bull. No. 19: 3-5. 1913. Gives a discussion and a tabular presentation.
Frankl-Hochwart, L. Von [1862-1914]. "What the Smoker May Pay for His Indulgence." Sci. Temp. Journ. 22: 85, 86. 1913. A thoughtful article by the professor of neuropathology in the University of Vienna.
Gaston, Lucy Page. "Perils of the Cigarette." Life and Health 22: 388-370. 1907. A strong indictment by one of the best workers in the Anti-Cigarette League.
Gray, H. S. "The Boy and the Cigarette Habit." Education 29: 294-310. 1909. This is an excellent article and should be read by every young man.
Hall, Winfield S. [Ph.D., M.D.] Tobacco. 1-36. Chicago: The Anti-Cigarette League of America, 1900. A symposium on the effects of tobacco on bodily growth, mental development, moral and spiritual health, physical strength, the nervous system, the heart, susceptibility to disease, and the drink habit. About forty medical opinions are quoted.
Hall, Winfield S. [Ph.D., M.D.] "The Use of Tobacco—A Personal Letter to Young Men." Sci. Temp. Journ. 22: 88-90. 1913. Reprinted from Tobacco by the same author.
Hamby, W. H. and King, E. A. The Cigarette and Youth. Cooperstown N. Y.: The Arthur H. Cnst Co., 1913. Partly a revision of King's paper cited below.
Hamilton, Harold. Cigarettes. 1-29. Chicago: The Anti-Cigarette Publishing Co., no date. "A fair and unbiased statement concerning this growing evil, by a reformed victim."
Hervey, H. D. "The Cigarette." Journ. Education 65: 485-
-113-
487. 1907. The paper contains valuable results of an investigation conducted by H. D. Hervey, superintendent of schools at Malden, Massachusetts.
Holmes, Arthur. "The Psychology of Smoking." 1-15. Hartford, Wisconsin. The Woman's Christian Temperance Union, no date. A strong paper from the standpoint of the psychologist. [Ed. Note: P 100 Excerpt]
Hubbard, Elbert [1856-1915]. "The Cigarettist." 1-8. Boston. The Massachusetts Anti-Cigarette League, 1905. The article contains some excellent arguments, and some valuable observations based upon experience.
Hunt, Mary H. [1830-1906]. "The Cigarette Habit in the High School." School Physiology Journal 17: 116, 117. 1908. The article states that proper instruction from the lowest grades up will prevent and has, where tried, prevented cigarette smoking in the high school.
[Ed. Note: Pp 97-98 Excerpt].
Hutchinson, Woods. A Handbook of Health. I-XVIII. 1-337. Many figures unnumbered. New York: Houghton, Mifflin Company, 1911. The effects of the tobacco habit are treated very sanely on pages 103 to 107.
Hyatt, Edward. "The Cigarette Boy." 1-18. Sacramento, California, State Printing Office, 1911. This article by the Superintendent of Public Instruction contains some of the best expert opinion and statistics, and should be read by boys and men.
Hyatt, Edward. "A Talk to Schoolboys." The Youth's Instructor 60: No. 10. 22. 1912. A helpful article by the Superintendent of Instruction for California.
Ingalls, Eliza B. "Give the Boy a Chance." 1-16. Illustrated. Saint Louis: Mrs. E. B. Ingalls, 5250 Westminster Place, no date. A series of quotations regarding the effects of the cigarette habit.
Ingalls, Eliza B. "Testimony Regarding the Cigarette." 1-24. Saint Louis: The National Women's Christian Temperance Union, no date. A series of quotations.
Ingalls, Eliza B. "Doors Closed and Doors Open." 1-8. Illustrated. Saint Louis: The National Women's Christian
-114-
Temperance Union, no date. A series of quotations regarding the curtailed business chances